|
|
|
|
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 10:45:43 AM | maybe it's just me but what's wrong with getting attention form guys.. even if it's a come-on in a form of opening a door for a woman? Is that going to harm her? I think all this sexual harrasment and related concepts were taken way too far. I personally see nothing wrong with men expressiong attention in the form of compliments (not ambiguous), opening doors, helping with something heavy. Even if a man is interested and the woman is not, she can always still appreciate the attention but indicate that she is unavailable or unintirested. I think men became way too scared to display notrmal interest to a degree that they don't want to even approach the women, court, express interest because they don't know if it will be well received. Seems like many of normal expressions have been driven "underground" and supressed, and as a result often comes out as deviation or inapropriateness, which is clearly visible in the cyberspace. I am sure some of guys that are terrified to even approach a woman IRL or Gawd forbid "come on" to her with a compliment are often the same ones that send risque emails and IMs. Sure there are pervs no matter how you look at them, no excuse, but if there was not so much supression of what used to be normal interaction between the genders, perhaps some people would not take out their frustrations and confusion out on cyberspace strangers. Maybe I am playing devil's advocate here, but something to think about.
The other thing.. more than 10 years ago the "sexual harrasment" topic was popular. I noticed that in a lot of cases when there were interviews, looking at the female accusers made me seriously doubt the validity of accusations, or the degree of harrasment. I am sure there were legitimate cases that warranted serious attention, but I cannot help but think is some of the accusers either overreacted, or exhagerrated, or were having some agenda. Telling someone that they look nice in a [red, green, brown, whatever] dress is not harrasment and should not warrant a media storm. JMO. ready to be flamed here... | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 1:50:46 PM |
The key is to realize that times HAVE changed (although I'm not sure that this type of chivalry was ever universal). Some women deserve to receive this kind of courteousness, and some don't. Be shrewd enough to make the distinction.
And yet another key, is that I do NOT have to change, and recognizing with my innate shrewdness, that the type of woman that doesn't deserve this distinction, is hardly worth my consideration. Just my bit | |
|
| |
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 4:28:33 PM | I see you are kindapicky ^ there
Sauders post is important, I think. It outlines the difference between 'being' a gentleman, and 'acting' like a gentleman, to get what you would consider as the 'reward'. in this case.. it would 'get' you the girl. Sauder made a decision, that even if no one appreciated his manners, or that it didnt get him the girl,.. he was going to do it anyway.. he would carry on having manners and standards of behaviour for himself, wether they were beneficial or not. That is 'being' a gentleman. Women are very good at knowing who is really a gentleman, and who is acting the gentleman to get their reward. It's an act that slips. After all, being a gentleman is no more than having kindness, and respect for someone else. Its just being a good honourable human being. Women, the sensible ones,.. know that if a man shows kindness, consideration,.. and respect to others, then he's most likely going to treat her that way too. Thats what we want.. but there are too many so called 'nice' guys who arent reallly that nice at all, they're just acting nice,.. and it soon starts to show if they're putting on an act. Being a gentleman should'nt be for the perceived reward,.. it should be its own reward. You'll be growing and evolving as a man and a human being.. you'll be a mensch. its something every man should aspire to. Miss Eyre.
I agree Miss Eyre, that certainly does show what 'being a gentleman' is.
It has actually been a very difficult task teaching my son that gentlemanly behaviour & chivalry is very important & always should be, particularily considering all the varying standards of behaviour people show nowadays. Although he slips & forgets occasionally, it's his continual attempts - in aspiring to be a gentleman that shines through  | |
|
| |
| |
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 6:49:47 PM | | Truthfully, I behave in a gentlemanly manner for me, not for others. I was raised in a certain way and hold my self to fairly strict standards of behavior. I have to be able to respect myself. Yes, I've been rebuffed by women who were offended to a door being opened or a chair being held. I think that says more about her than it does about myself. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 6:55:53 PM | I think so ... and I like the feminine side of all this too. It makes me more receptive, and responsive, but then I am an older fashioned gal. To me it is not a game , but a court ship thing... and I like it... and I like doing the things a lady would do... too  | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 7:00:56 PM | Yes it is !!!
A little test that I have is that I unlock and open her door, wait for her to get in - then I close her door If she reaches over and unlocks my door, then I know she is really a lady | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 9:24:59 PM | | Guess I am not a lady since I am a short woman and if I were to reach over and unlock the door I might be crawling around and if I was wearing a dress that might be unladylike...I see your point to some extent, manners are important to me also. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 9:43:41 PM | Something interesting happened to me today that really deomostates just how far behind the times the women really are when it comes to civilised behaviour.
Me and a few buddies were taking breakfast at a Maccas. We noticed a car on the main road with it's hood up. Engine trouble! Three of us wandered over and helped the guy push the car off the road, where it wouldn't cause an accident and he could work on it.
First double standard! Becasue the unfortunate was a guy this sort of behaviur is called "mateship" in Australia. And the womens (not feminsit) movement has roundly foul mouthed it for years as a bastion of sexism. IFF the stranded driver had been female then pushing her off the road would have been called "gentlemen behaviur" This double standard, based on gender, is sexism.
Second double standard! Most of the guys were over fifty, one was WELL over. When we finished pushing the car of the road we noticed a young woman had been sitting in the passanger seat the whole time, completely ignoring the proceedings. She was certainly in far better physical shape, to help push the car than any of the elderly gentlemen who did. But she was definitly hiding behind her gender to be a lazy slob.
COURTESY, and CIVILITY is still important. But many many women fail miserably in these areas, even using expressions like beechcraft, as if rudeness was some sort of artform. Chivaliry, and gentlemanaly behaviour are sexist cop outs to try to excuse rudeness among women while condemming it among men. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/11/2008 9:49:47 PM | With me......gentlemanly behavior is an absolute must do. I open doors for women. I hold their chair while they sit down. I assist them getting into, or out of a coat and this one that most guys don't know about, or have forgotten: While walking along a sidewalk the gentleman always places himself between the woman and the street. No! I don't toss my coat over a mud puddle! I do, however, tip my hat to a woman, or remove it if I am talking with her.
The "Woman's Lib" movement back in the 70's sort of killed chivalry. We were considered "male chauvinist pigs" if we opened a door for a woman! I was called that several times. But.....chivalry is coming back. Thank GAWD! | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/12/2008 6:49:39 AM | | We appreciate chivalrous men Arapaho7, I thought hat tipping was a thing of the past. Men standing when a woman enters the room is something that is seemingly obsolete. My mother is 74, and the men her age at her church are the most gentlemanly group I have ever met. My sister and her husband have been married 30 years, and he still opens car doors for her and for other women who might be getting in the car. I was at the grocery store recently, and although I enjoy driving my new SUV ( 60 dollars to fill it up is not enjoyable, though) being a woman who is 5 feet tall makes for having to be creative about reaching for things, etc. I was placing the grocery bags in the back of Scout as I have named it, and a man asked if he could help since I had bought a huge bag of cat litter . I said yes, thank you and he tipped his hat. Made my day. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/12/2008 4:23:57 PM | I replied, "No m'aam, I opened that door because "I" am a gentleman"
Hey cowboy, I like that response. I have actually been pushed through a door after opening it for a woman. She got pissed off and pushed me ahead of her..... | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/12/2008 4:30:46 PM |
Hey cowboy, I like that response. I have actually been pushed through a door after opening it for a woman. She got pissed off and pushed me ahead of her.....
Now that is just rude, where do you people live!?!
My question is, do you hold open doors for little, shuffling old men too? Or is it just the pretty ladies? That's what shows true character right there. I have seen a man jump in front of a door to hold it for a pretty girl, but totally ignore the little old dude, and I thought that was downright deplorable. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/12/2008 6:27:09 PM | I'm going to say it again for some of the guys on here who want to market themselves in the Sir Galahad role. Chivalry is situational. You're gonna want to show that kind of respect and gentility to your Mom. Your wife. Your girlfriend. Your female relatives. Your female friends. Also to women you don't know who strike you as classy and appreciative.
But, let's be clear. This type of gentility is not for everyone you encounter out there. You can have your a$$ handed to you by trying to play Sir Galahad when a woman you don't know thinks your gesture is inappropriate. It doesn't matter what your intent is, guys. If the total stranger that you're doing the gesture for doesn't like it, you're defeating the purpose of it and it becomes a selfish ego-trip instead of a classy gesture. Adapt to your circumstances, and don't be a tool. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/13/2008 10:56:44 AM |
My question is, do you hold open doors for little, shuffling old men too? Or is it just the pretty ladies? That's what shows true character right there. I have seen a man jump in front of a door to hold it for a pretty girl, but totally ignore the little old dude, and I thought that was downright deplorable.
Most generally if I am at the door first, I will hold it for "anyone" behind me (it's apparently part of my paranoia, which I wouldn't be paranoid if everyone wasn't out to get me)
Seriously, it just feels "mannerly" to behave as such , so there ];Þ~~ | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/13/2008 2:11:47 PM | The two great ages of "chivalary" were the crusades era and the Victorin eras. The two eras absoloutely reeked with pomp, ceromomy, and rituial, to hide the underlying brutality of these eras.
Crusaders raped,pilliagedm and murdered their way accross Europe to the holy land. This was the first record of progroms, (mas murder of Jews) and the first record of canibilism by nobels.
The Victorian era coined the term "rule of thumb" whereby a man could legally beat his wife, as long, and hard, and often, as he liked, provided the cane he used was no thicker than his thumb.
Me thinks the average woman would be more than happy to have the men remain seated , if it meant that she didnt have to put up with continuious beatings.
A final touch. Do you know why Henry VIII s fifth wife Cathrine Howard was executed? Becayse she wasn't a virgin at the wedding. No other reason. Stuff the chivaliry. Its something that any real woman, with ant real brains, would be happy to abandon. | |
|
| |
| |
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 1/14/2008 8:08:02 PM |
crayonzz; Msg: 143 - Stuff the chivaliry. Its something that any real woman, with ant real brains, would be happy to abandon. I disagree - ^
In deciding whether I do or don't want to discard chivalry, I initially looked into history resources; - the origin of chivalry, such as -
Chivalry’s Origins It is known that knighthood and the concept of chivalry date back to the early centuries of Medieval Europe. The exact region or group responsible for the primary influence of chivalry’s birth is, however, often debated. Some scholars have traced it to 12th century France while others maintain that it is of Arabic origin, transmitted to Europe through Muslim Spain. There are many others that insist it began in the Scandinavian countries. Nevertheless, the concept and ceremony of knighthood and chivalry probably originated from the interaction and combination of very early military customs, the nature of Medieval warfare with its emphasis on cavalry and the impact of Christian influences. It is reasonably evident that the principles of chivalry are of Gothic origin, influenced by the strong religious character of the early Middle Ages. Although religious character, which distinguished ancient chivalry, arose out of the manner of the times and the state of society, it is evident that the feudal system, although it did not actually give birth to chivalry, was instrumental in bringing it to maturity. The feudal system was a structured system of defense and governance whereby knights were rewarded with land and privileges in return for fighting and governing. Early in the 11th century, the rudiments of the laws of chivalry were defined by the Council of Clermont in France. In 1025, several archbishops authored a set of laws for the maintenance of order and protection of the weak, and submitted these to the Council of Clermont which confirmed them. This chivalric code compelled a knight to be brave, courageous, honorable, true to his word, loyal to his feudal overlord, to defend the Church, protect the weak, aid the poor, seek justice and revere pure womanhood. This set of high standards of conduct significantly refined the character of Medieval civilization and later had a profound impact on the shape of modern life. The conduct and ideals of the knightly class of the Middle Ages came to be standardized and referred to as “chivalry,” a term derived from the French word “chevalier,” meaning knight. http://www.kappaalphaorder.org/resources/varlet_materials/varlet_chivalry.asp
I then looked into some modern day recources, such as; - Code of Chivalry; Modern, based on the "Old Code" - http://www.chronique.com/Library/Chivalry/code. And; -
Not long ago, chivalry was a concept that was largely ignored. It was something that was known to literary scholars and history professors, but it didn’t seem to have any place in the world of business, sports, politics or relationships in the modern world. Women had been taught that displays of chivalry were demeaning and condescending, and men had come to believe that courtesy and respectful attitudes weren’t “manly.” Recently, however, those ideas have changed. Current events and front-page headlines have made us all aware of how crucial ethical conduct and personal integrity are in creating a fair and functional society. New understandings of issues such as military ethics, political integrity, athletic scandals, gang violence, cheating in school and the workplace, road rage and corporate accountability — not to mention the simple desire to restore a sense of tolerance, discipline and fair play to the world at large — have brought the ideals of chivalry and honor to the level of a national debate like never before. People are realizing that the 21st century needs a Code of Chivalry. And people are realizing that anyone — men and women, teachers and coaches, students and soldiers, doctors and athletes — any one of us can be a knight in shining armor. http://www.chivalrytoday.com/ - 7 Knightly Virtues
Also - Modern Chivalry; What place is there for modern chivalry in an age of 'equality' and sexual litigation? Modern Etiquette; - http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/A934887 | |
|
| |
| |
medana
| Joined: 12/8/2005 Msg: 149 | |
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 3/4/2008 1:02:13 PM | chivalry is VERY important to me. it makes ahuge difference on a date, if the guy has outstanding old school manners. i LOVE it.
even if the date doesn't work out, it will be a man i will always remember and admire for being outstanding.
i remember one time i went on a date w a guy that looked like a good prospect. it was our first 'real' date, the first meeting was an impromptu to figure out if there is anything there, since we met online.
when i got there, he had ordered my drink, and was waiting for me OUTSIDE! i had just called and told him i was parking, and he came out, then showed me to our table and drinks.
i just never forgot that!
so many people talk about flowers and manners, but VERY FEW still do it. THAT is the secret to that. most just talk about it, but DONT do it. | |
|
| is gentlemanly behavior and chivalry still important? Posted: 3/4/2008 1:16:59 PM | I always try to act as a true gentleman would... I'm amazed when the woman I'm with at the time is surprised by my actions. I get a lot of "No one has ever done that for me before." Amazing!!!
What is a Gentleman? (Words to live by): 1) His conduct proceeds from good will and an acute sense of propriety, and whose self-control is equal in every situation. 2) He does not make the poor man conscious of his poverty, the odd man of his obscurity, or any man of his inferiority or deformity. 3) He is himself humbled if necessity compels him to humble another. 4) He does not flatter wealth, cringe before power, or boast of his own possessions or achievements. 5) He speaks with frankness but always with sincerity and sympathy. 6) His word is his bond. 7) He thinks of the rights and feelings of others, rather than his own. 8) He appears well in any company. 9) Above all else he is a man with whom honor is sacred and virtue safe.
Opening doors, removing or tipping his hat, and pulling out chairs for a lady is just part of the whole package. It takes all of the above to make a gentleman.
I agree with several of the previous posts... If you act chivalrous, you will stand out, and that will give you an edge over the other men out there. However, do not forget that being a true gentleman does not stop once you have won the ladies' heart. The true gentleman lives his life by the these words each an every day...  | |
|
|
|