| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/17/2005 9:05:27 AM | | so then.. what i hear you saying is that it is ok for those ten people to spend their time BETTERING YOUR LIFE instead of their own. what a joke. maybe nobody should work for you if you can't afford reasonable compensation for their efforts. After all, they are just wasting their time, right? | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/17/2005 9:13:19 AM | I tried to make the analogy simple so I wouldn't lose anyone, seems that effort failed. That is why I didn't make any claims as to how much revenue or profit the business took in. This was just simple economics and the chain reaction a minimum wage hike causes.
Be that as it may, a business owner has a right to make more than their employees. After all they started the business, worked all the hard, long hours before there were any employees, made all the sacrifices and took all the risks. | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/17/2005 9:15:43 AM | Igotoosu, no one is being indentured into servitude. Everyone is choosing what to do with their own life. If everyone is given the same opportunities, then I don't really want to hear about how "society is keeping them down". If you don't want to work for minimum wage, then get off your ass, go to school, or do something to make things better for yourself. Society is not going to do it for you, as much as some people would like. (I mean "you" in general, I know you're in school)
Btw, YES a business owner is out to make a profit. If he didn't, he wouldn't be a business owner for long. | |
|
| |
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/17/2005 7:49:17 PM |
Posted By: bulldogmedic on 06-09-2004 06:43 PM
Message: Igotoosu, no one is being indentured into servitude. Everyone is choosing what to do with their own life. If everyone is given the same opportunities, then I don't really want to hear about how "society is keeping them down".
Yeah, I'm sure if George W. Bush was born in harlem to a poor inner-city single mother, he'd still be where he is today.
See how I skillfully brought the subject around to Bush? I learned that in Damn Socialist Liberal Traitor camp. | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 6:38:18 AM | Watchman, you said:
"I have a business and pay 10 people minimum wage."
I am not naive at all.
My immediate family members have a business too, in a very competitive field. They do not pay anyone minimum wage. In fact they pay slightly over what the average skilled worker in their field makes, and they take less out of their business than the average owner takes. The result, loyal and very productive employees and a business that is more successful. Customers who come back every season, a growing reputation for excellence. Yes, like all business owners they occasionally have to fire people, but it's rare and they find their approach is well worth the risk. In other words, being an employer with a "heart" makes good economic sense. They also share their profit with their employees in several different ways, Guess what - this rather "socialist" approach is working very well.
"The Government raises minimum wage 20%"
How totally unlikely verging on absured. . "I'm not making any more money because minimum wage was raised."
Aww, you could, if you motivated your employees.
"I lay off 20% of my workforce (2 people)"
Does not apply because the government will not raise the minimum wage by 20%. If they raise it slightly you can practice other economies.
"People need to have an opportunity to better their lives. In America EVERYONE has that opportunity. You cannot expect Government to force businesses and taxpayers to pick up the tab for people who do not have the drive to try and better their lives..."
A reasonable minimum wage does not stop people from trying to better their lives, it enables them to do so. You seem to have the attitude that everyone who is at the bottom is there due to lack of ambition, and that is simply wrong.
lyrical | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 7:06:00 AM | Just FYI, I think the number of folks who actually work only 40 hrs a wk is lower than you think. I agree that people who work hard should be able to pay their bills and still live, but a 50-60 hr work week is what we should base that 'living wage' on.
Entry-level jobs (which minimum wage jobs usually are) are not designed nor required to enable a worker to support a household on. While there is nothing wrong with them, it's good, honest work, one is expected to achieve more if planning to support a family.
There are folks who try and make it work, but they typically have two or more such jobs and work 60-80 hours a week, the only to make such low pay support themselves. Such folks in rural areas also hunt, fish and garden seriously to fill their larder and make those few dollars go further. It can be done, but not on 40 hrs a week.
Also, speaking economically, while raising the minimum wage does initially show an increase in purchasing power for workers it also spurs inflation which quickly returns their purchasing power to where it was or even lower.
MajMike | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 7:30:48 AM | MajMike: Well, George Bush tried to cut combat pay by 1/3 and you still support him, so I know where YOU're coming from. You're very compassionate about enlisted men and working people, huh?
| |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 7:36:13 AM | Eleood re:
It's not like Canada where education is more affordable. There are people down here who live in places without hot water..
There are people in Canada who live in places without hot water.They live a slow death on the streets,in parks or in wooded areas,right here in Vancouver because the economy is the grossly unjust economy of a Socialist dungheap with its business destroying/repelling extraordinarily high taxes.These taxes are sky high so public sector union employees can be paid three times what they're worth.Bus-drivers,cops,healthcare workers and firemen making $100,000 a year walk past homeless people dying in the streets. | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 8:08:37 AM | BVM: to me, that's a legitimate concern. My argument is that the economy should INCLUDE people. People shouldn't be left out on the streets to die or starve. If government wages are out of sight and not comparable to the private sector, then they ought to be kept within the range... | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 8:32:16 AM | Does not apply because the government will not raise the minimum wage by 20%
What's the minimum wage now? 6 Dollars? Okay, 20% of minimum wage is 1.2 so that woudl raise it to 7.20. I can conceive of gov't raising it to that amount. Further, I can see dem's pushing for all they can get because they no they don't get many chances to raise minimum wage and they think it will help them at the polls.
But we all know that raising minimum wage is one of those issues that sounds good in to the public but in reality causes a lot of problems. I brought this up before. If Employee A makes minimum wage and Employee B makes 2 dollars above mininum wage, who is hurt by the wage increase? Well, Employee A will get a slight raise in the short term. But after inflation adjusts for the wage increase, the real purchasing power of Employee A will remain the same. Employee B on the otherhand will most likely be hurt by the wage increase because Employee B will not get the same increase as did Employee A but will have to deal with the inflation. Therefore, in real purchasing power, Employee B will lose money.
So, what we'll do is sacrifice Employee B because we want to score political points and give some college kids and part-time workers a raise that in reality is not a raise for long. | |
|
| |
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 9:16:15 AM | The analogy I used is not what I pay my employees, just to clear that up right now. It was an analogy using 10 employees so people could follow the math. My employees are highly skilled and make many times over the current minimum wage.
Lyrical, what is totally absurd is you saying a 20% increase is never going to happen:
On April 1, 1990 the federal minimum wage was increased from $3.35 per hour to $3.80; a year later it was increased to $4.25, for a combined increase in excess of 25 percent
In a one year period there was a 25% minimum wage increase, so much for your argument lyrical...
You seem to have the attitude that everyone who is at the bottom is there due to lack of ambition, and that is simply wrong.
Actually I never said anything remotely resembling your supposition so I have no idea where you got that idea from. What I do believe is that anyone that STAYS at the minimum wage level is doing so by choice... | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 11:24:38 AM | Elwood you idget
Once again you prove your one-track mind, while I am able to support some things W does and oppose others, you hear 'Bush" and lose your ability to distinguish between the good and the bad things he has done (and yes there have been a few good).
I don't support ANY cuts in combat pay or any other type pay cut for our active-duty military, just as I am angry at Congress for not fully funding Veterans programs. While I don't expect your memory to be any better then your reasoning there have been many times/issues here at POF that I have not supported Pres. Bush's stance, including agreeing that the Iraqi war was technically illegal.
However, I can still support his goal of democracy in the Middle East, starting with the fairly optimistic current situation in Iraq.
Lastly, I am very compassionate towards working people, but I want our govt to have as small a role to play in our collective lives as possible. Supporting assistance programs is fine but when we have generations of welfare families (as we do) I begin to think perhaps this approach isn't working as we intended. Give folks a hand up, not a hand-out.
MajMike | |
|
| |
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 11:51:18 AM | You didn't have a point, you were just (once again) reminding everyone here that you hate everything about Bush and whenever he or his admin are involved you assume that they are actively trying to bring about the rule of Satan on Earth.
For a man whose best rebuttal is "nanananah" you sure use it a lot, see if "nananagoogoo" wil work every once in a while just to give a change of pace.
MajMike | |
|
| |
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 12:28:53 PM | See here the Elwood paradox:
you're just mad because I've shown the inconsistency in your reasoning (again)
This was said about:
I don't support ANY cuts in combat pay or any other type pay cut for our active-duty military, just as I am angry at Congress for not fully funding Veterans programs. While I don't expect your memory to be any better then your reasoning there have been many times/issues here at POF that I have not supported Pres. Bush's stance, including agreeing that the Iraqi war was technically illegal.
However, I can still support his goal of democracy in the Middle East, starting with the fairly optimistic current situation in Iraq.
While I agree the thinking is complex (obviously too complex for Elwood), it is certainly not inconsistant. His apparent problem is that you must either love Bush or hate him, there is no (to him) middle ground. Well, as with most things in life, the middle ground is where most rational people meet, and it seems that we have managed to lose the riff-raff on the way.
Either you are one of the most obstinate people I have ever met, or you are really much dumber that I thought. I don't know which is sadder.
MajMike | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 12:38:46 PM | Well Mike, are you saying that you see Dubyah as a snake in the grass for wanting to cut combat pay?...
or are you going to call me a madman for hating him?
Which?
inconsistency, muhman.... | |
|
| |
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 12:59:57 PM | yeah...okay mr. Economist.... doesn't understand inflation or how people who make 1/5 of what someone else does can't pay the same rate of taxes at the same percentage *LMFAO*
Whutta friggin JEAN E YUSS!!!
 | |
|
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 1:03:23 PM | The whole debate over 'cutting combat pay' was a white elephant brought up by Edwards in the Presidential race:
Cutting Combat Pay?
Edwards twice accused the administration of having "lobbied the Congress" to cut the combat pay of troops in Iraq, when in fact the White House never supported such a plan.
Rather, the Defense Department proposed allowing a temporary pay increase for all troops worldwide (even those not in Iraq or Afghanistan) to expire, and promised to maintain current pay levels for troops in Iraq and Afghanistan with separate pay raises if necessary.
Army Times reported in its issue for the week ending Aug. 18, 2003 that a Pentagon budget assessment sent to Congress in July called for letting a temporary combat pay raise enacted earlier that year for troops worldwide expire at the end of the fiscal year, Sept. 30. The result would have been a cut of $75 a month in "imminent danger pay" and $150 a month in "family separation allowances."
But according to an Aug. 15 American Forces Press Service report, David S.C. Chu, defense undersecretary for personnel and readiness, said the department could raise hardship duty pay or incentive pay. The bottom line: "We are not going to reduce their compensation," Chu said. The Pentagon also said in an Aug. 14 news release : "This is an issue of targeting those most deserving, and certainly people serving in Iraq and Afghanistan are in these categories."
Puts a little light on the whole 'non-issue' doesn't it?
And no, I don't think you are a madman for hating Bush, but your inability to tolerate any mention of him or his policies in a positive light is obsessive at the least. No person is all bad as you seem to think, even Hitler came up with the Beetle and the autobahn. You have to realize that:
- mention of things Bush has done well don't erase those he has not - mention of Clinton's lies/mistakes doesn't negate Bush's lies/mistakes - the hope for a real democracy in Iraq doesn't mean we approve of the way the war was started - a rational person can approve of some of his acts and not approve of others - people who don't see Bush as evil are not 'stupid, fascist war-mongers' - people who oppose increased welfare programs are not 'heartless **stards' In fact, to generalize and sum up: - people who do not agree with you are not 'stupid, fascist, heartless **stards'. They may have a carefully considered point of view based on information you do or do not have, and they also may (if approached nicely) listen to information you think vouches for a different point of view and actually alter their position based on that info. But, that exchange has to be a two-way street that does not veer into "you're stupid" if at first we do not agree.
MajMike | |
|
| |
| Why do people try and live off of minimum wage? Posted: 4/18/2005 1:20:59 PM | even Hitler came up with the Beetle and the autobahn
MajMike... do you realize what you're doing here? You're using Hitler to justify Bush... So, you would say because Hitler did these "good" things he shouldn't have faced loud violent opposition to his overall administration of tyranny?
I don't think you mean to make that argument, but you are...and no, it doesn't justify Bush either. It's ridiculous.
Now don't blame me for criticizing this argument, big guy. YOU made it.
You have to realize that:
- mention of things Bush has done well don't erase those he has not
of course...that's MY point.
- mention of Clinton's lies/mistakes doesn't negate Bush's lies/mistakes
Of course not. But there's no reason to bring Clinton up at this point. He's been gone for four years. He's just being used to take attention off the terrible things Bush is doing.
- the hope for a real democracy in Iraq doesn't mean we approve of the way the war was started
I go along with that, BUT; WHEN ARE WE GOING TO GET OUT? ... and even being there puts us in a very vulnerable position.
- a rational person can approve of some of his acts and not approve of others
a rational person can DISAPPROVE of almost everything he's done. He's done some terribly STUPID things as president and disgraced our nation in the eyes of the world NUMEROUS times. Not just the lies to invade... but breaking treaties, insulting our allies... not to mention robbing the US treasury blind investing in a missile system that doesn't work and it's already obsolete.
- people who don't see Bush as evil are not 'stupid, fascist war-mongers'
but they either very uninformed or are very ignorant...
- people who oppose increased welfare programs are not 'heartless **stards'
don't think I ever said this *LOL*
- people who do not agree with you are not 'stupid, fascist, heartless **stards'. They may have a carefully considered point of view based on information you do or do not have, and they also may (if approached nicely) listen to information you think vouches for a different point of view and actually alter their position based on that info. But, that exchange has to be a two-way street that does not veer into "you're stupid" if at first we do not agree.
I don't think I ever said this either MajMike... it's just your impression... I don't like people saying I lied when I didn't. I also don't like people insulting me for where I live or how I think.
If I think something is wrong, I'll say it's wrong. If you prove ME wrong, I'll say it's wrong.... but prove it first. Don't go "summing up" with "he's a liar."
Bad form. | |
|
| |