| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 5:39:42 PM | | There is a strong correlation. While they are different species how you treat one will give a good indication on how you are going to treat the other. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 5:49:19 PM | ""To say that these relationships are on par with human-human relationships and to infer that human ownership of animals somehow prepares a human adult for parenting, makes them better parents, or is a sign of affection capacity is an inane and presumptious claim with little merit.""
I think a first here. I usually agree completely with the great and wise Sombient however not this time. My business IS dogs - mostly working dogs but pretty much all dogs from Police, SAR, GDFtB(lind) all the way to pampered pets. I get GREAT enjoyment from meeting as many of my clients as I possibly can too so I can say those I have met number in the thousands - no tens of thousands.
I have YET to observe one solitary case where a person or couple had well behaved kids and a BRAT for a dog OR vice versa. Never. Not once.
On the other hand I have seen MANY cases where a couple or single parent had an obnoxious brat for a kid and the dog was untrained, dangerous or destructive.
I obviously can't say that is 100% true for EVERY case where there are kids or dogs involved but it is so overwhelmingly true in the majority of cases that I find Sombient's statement to be a gross error in analysis and / or observation.
I have been asked by friends about getting a dog when they already had kids or having a baby with a dog already in the house. I have always said, "Look at your kids. They're great. Your dog will be too." or "You have a great dog. A new baby will be fine with the dog." and it has always worked out. Only once did I ever tell a couple NOT to get a dog. When they asked why I told them. Their kids were untrained and the dog will be too. A BAD combination. They got the dog and they had it put down at 18 months when in truth they should have had their kids euthanized for society's sake. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 6:08:37 PM | No sir, you made a mistake in your reasoning. I said that pet care doesn't prepare a parent for child care (not a good socialization model). I agree that there is a correlation in success using reasoned and sensible training of animals and humans, as you point out: where we see socialization problems in children who lack boundaries, so we see them in the pets in these same households for the same reasons. The socialization processes have similarities, but the socialization of children is far more complex and requires a longer, dedicated effort for success than it does for pet training. I don't think we're in basic disagreement.
Edit: I still don't think pet-human interaction is a good model for predicting human-human affection (or bonding). I don't treat animals with the same type of affection I would a human. Do you? | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 6:15:47 PM |
I witnessed a man discipling his dog in a manner that made me wonder if he disciplined his child in the same way.. it was very agressive and he was very stern in his voice.. he was not abusive to the dog however it got alot of people staring at him. Yes, he likely disciplines his child the same way. Also keep in mind that people are likely to tone their behaviour down while in public - so he may be even worse in his own home. And since, as Sombient pointed out, raising children is a much longer, more complex and thus far more difficult process than raising a dog, it can lead to much more frustration and the physical expression of same.
With the whole serial killer thing people are using the extreme... There is a trend with rapist and serial killers Torturing and Killing animals. Now depending on your defintion of torture, it's very different from what some people might precieve as being mean or "not-right" ... Yes, you're absolutely right - the example of serial killers does take things to the extreme - but it's an extreme used to make a point. The correlation between violence to animals and violence to people is continuous across levels of violence.
From Broward County Sheriff Ken Jenne: (emphases in all of the below are mine)
ABUSE OF CHILDREN, ANIMALS AND SPOUSES IS OFTEN RELATED There is an element of child abuse prevention that is being overlooked by too many people who deal with the cycle of family violence. ... The broader cycle I believe we need to address is the one that connects one violent individual to several vulnerable individuals – and animals – on the receiving end of his or her cruelty. Someone who batters an intimate partner is also likely to harm children, elders, family pets or any other vulnerable being. Likewise, if a family pet or neighborhood animal has been maltreated, chances are the individual who brought harm to the animal is connected in some way to mental, physical or emotional abuse taking place among people. For example, if little Johnnie strangles a cat in what is interpreted to be “child’s play,” chances are little Johnnie has witnessed or been the recipient of violence in his home. In order to protect our youngsters from family violence and to expand our prevention efforts, it is crucial that all of us recognize this connection between human abuse and animal cruelty. Research shows that violent acts are not separate and distinct, and that animal cruelty is a potential indicator of disturbed family relationships that often lead to violence among humans, including children. ...
Because we have learned that abusers are motivated by internal desires for power and control – not in a narrowly focused propensity to abuse children only, or animals only, or intimate partners only – we need to understand that abusers do not distinguish between victims. The challenges of protecting and nurturing our youngsters are certain to continue if we fail to recognize and address all of the varied, but related, forms of cruelty. www.sheriff.org He's not alone in what he's saying:
Mahatma Gandhi said, "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated." Animals feel pain and fear like we do, but they are often helpless victims because they can't say what happened to them. In fact, some people choose to abuse animals instead of people for this very reason! ... Animals in homes with family violence are also often victims of violence. One study1 found that animals were abused in 88 percent of the homes in which a child was abused. Another study found that 83 percent of families reported for animal abuse also had children at high risk of abuse or neglect. Although most of the abuse toward the animals came from the parents, about a quarter of abused children abuse animals. http://www.aspca.org/site/PageServer?pagename=cruelty_kidsandcruelty
Animal Abuse: Part of the Cycle of Violence Acts of violence directed against animals by children are among the earliest sentinel indicators of conduct disorder and manifestations of the intergenerational cycle of violence that researchers are just now coming to understand. "Cruelty to animals is a predictor of violent behavior, and as good a predictor as I have seen," says William Ritter, District Attorney for Denver, Colo. Anthropologist Margaret Mead has written that the worst thing that can happen to a child is to harm an animal - and get away with it. Virtually all of the mass murderers and schoolyard killers of recent years had committed prior acts of animal abuse. When asked how many serial killers had a history of abusing animals, the FBI responded, "The real question should be, how many have not?" Aggressive acts against any member of the family endanger all members, and put others in the community at risk as well. In households where there is animal abuse, there likely are other forms of abuse. Inter-agency collaboration may help reduce levels of violence. http://www.animaltherapy.net/ChildAbuse.html
When you teach a child to be kind to animals, you help pave the way to a brighter future for all living beings. ... Children benefit because learning about compassion and empathy early in life builds moral character, reduces violence, and builds a sense of empowerment and responsibility. And society as a whole benefits when its members are more caring towards each other and the animals who live among us. Animal cruelty is a heinous act punishable by law in every state, but in recent years, there has been increasing recognition of the link between animal cruelty and violence to other humans as well. … Sadly, violence begets more violence, and those who start off abusing animals often end up abusing people too. People who deliberately abuse animals are five times more likely to commit violent crimes against people, four times more likely to commit property crimes, and three times more likely to have a record for drug abuse or disorderly conduct than those who don't, according to a study by American Humane. In fact, the FBI reportedly even uses reports of animal cruelty to assess the potential threat posed by suspected and known violent criminals. http://www.charityguide.org/volunteer/fewhours/kind-to-animals.htm So, YES there IS a correlation between how pets are treated and how other members of the family - spouses and children - are treated. To deny it is to deny the reality that research has shown us.
sv | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 6:34:58 PM | ..and so owning a pet prepares you for raising a child how????LMAO...
Guess we could all regergitate other's words....damn if I wasn't a parent I would have all the frikken time in the world to search the web looking for spewed out crap....and I have little doubt I would find it....
Anyways...refer to my ealier posts.
Like I said, when you are a parent, then you'll realize how ridiculous this all is, not even close.
But I will give you the extreme side of things....woman beats dog, woman beats kids. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 6:51:11 PM |
..and so owning a pet prepares you for raising a child how????
Perhaps you should go back and read the original question. Since you don't have a lot of time with all those kids, I'll post it for you.
so do you think that a way a man or women treats there pet(s) is any indication on how they may treat there child or future children?????? Esp when it comes to discipline???
There's nothing here about raising kids...it's just how one treats animals vs. children in general.
I believe you're the only one being ridiculous here.  | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 6:58:38 PM | The OP wrote in the introductory text of this thread:
....do you think that a way a man or women treats there pet(s) is any indication on how they may treat there child or future children??
I think that would be interpreted to mean does pet ownership influence how we we conduct child socialization training? | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 7:09:18 PM | the OP then clarified:
Just to clarify as to why i asked this question is because I witnessed a man discipling his dog in a manner that made me wonder if he disciplined his child in the same way.. it was very agressive and he was very stern in his voice.. This is not referring to how children are raised, it is referring to how children are treated.
None of this has anything to do with whether or not owning a pet prepares you for having children (though on that point I would have to say if you aren't responsible enough to look after a gerbil, I would have doubts that you are responsible enough to look after a child - which IMO is a much greater responsibility than a gerbil).
Like I said, when you are a parent, then you'll realize how ridiculous this all is, not even close. Yeah, all that scientific research is just ridiculous. LOL
But I will give you the extreme side of things....woman beats dog, woman beats kids. Yeah. Beating dogs = beating kids. Uh, that's my point.
sv | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 7:13:11 PM | I couldn't be with anyone that mistreats an animal. Someone that does has issues they're taking out on an innocent creature that didn't ask for it and it's sick. Yes I would think it would give some insight as to how they would treat other living beings under their control... god forbid. Having said that I know of people that treat their animals far better than their children. Perhaps it's because animals are usually lower maintenance and don't talk back... most are trainable and loyal.
Seems to me abusers seek ultimate control and there is a loss of control when a child who has their own personality and as they start discovering the world will put the validity of their parent's right to control to the test ~ or when an animal isn't being obedient. While the two differ greatly in that one is a pet and the other is human, it still says a whole lot about the type of person they are if they can even comprehend how something like that is OK. It makes me so angry. People like that need a taste of their own medicine. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 7:35:48 PM | | I think how anyone treats another living being is a good predictor of how they will treat others...whether it be their spouses or children. Having pets teaches patience and responsibility. I also think that couples who are thinking of having children should try getting a pet first...as their "parenting/pet care" skills may differ greatly. One person may be over indulgent, while the other not so much. It's a good indicator for how you will fare as a couple when it comes to child rearing. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 8:35:04 PM | Owning a pet does prepare you for child rearing.
It teaches you responsibility , compassion, empathy, sympathy and discipline. It teaches you to beyond yourself, to reach out and not be selfish.
It teaches you what it means to rush home and look after the pet. To take it for exercise , to monitor what it eats, to be sensitive to signs when its not feeling well and to discipline it with consistency and restraint plus it teaches you to set expectations for behaviour.
It will also teach you what type of children you will have by introducing a pet into the household.
A study was done with a group of kindergarden aged kids. Each child was brought into the kindergarden room alone with an adult. The adult showed them all the toys and the pet rabbit the class had. He went on to explain the poor rabbit is hungry as it had not been fed yet. Before they could play he told the kid the rabbit needed to be fed.
At that moment a knock comes to the classroom door. THe teacher is asked to step outside into the hallway for a brief meeting. Child is left alone in the room while being secretly videotaped. Some kids looked around and also looked at the rabbit . The ones who had a good sense of guilt, conscience, empathy and sympathy ignored the toys and started opening cupboards to search for food for the rabbit.
The kids who tended to not have an abundance of the above character traits would play and ignore the rabbit's hunger. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 8:58:47 PM | | I cant believe you can say pets are not people, then again you dislike them and have never had one, They r mans best friend, the most loyal companions youll ever know, there love is unconditional 24/7, there always happy to see u if only u leave for 5 minutes, they r well behaved and obideient!!!!!!!!!!!! HMMMMMMMMM!!, can u say that about children???????????????LMAO! | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/12/2007 9:51:22 PM | kids pee in the yard, dog pee's in the house......... I think I really messed up somewhere, who'd have thought I'd be a role model  | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/13/2007 3:50:15 PM | | well,you can forget the dog bowl and water for a start! | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/23/2007 1:22:11 PM | | Yes! You can really tell how a person is by the way they treat their pets. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/23/2007 1:24:12 PM | | Hell no! My X was very aggressive when he was training our dog and we ended up with a well trained dog. My daughter (same age ) was his princess back then and she is well behaved as well without any beatings or screaming matches like he had with the dog. Kind of a crappy comparison............. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 3/27/2007 2:18:03 PM | | if somebody has to muzzle their dog because of bylaw infractions or the such.. does that mean they will muzzle their kids when they have them??.. Obviously if they abuse their pets, its not a good thing.. and thats not thinking of kids in the future.. its wrong to treat animals like that, and it should be stopped before there are ever any kids in the first place. But it doesnt necessarily mean that that same person is going to beat there kids. EVERYTHING in this world is situational. Different situations dictate different reactions and actions needed to be taken. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 5/8/2007 7:37:21 AM | | I am unsure as to whether or not pet care and raising children is 100% related. I do know however that I would not be caught dead with a person who didn't treat animals with the utmost respect. I also know that I would not trust a person who loses their temper and takes it out on animals, to me it's a question of how easily the person's buttons get pushed... | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 5/8/2007 9:54:42 AM | | I have both, no correlation! The boy doesn't lick his butt or hump your leg and the dog doesn't backtalk. Although I have threaten to have my son "fixed". | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 5/8/2007 10:13:25 AM | | Commitment to the well being of the child or animal is the only correlation I can see. There are no variables training the dogs, I am always the leader of the pack. With the kids, it was a constant challenge to convince them I knew more than their friends, tv characters, movie actors, and complete strangers. | |
|
| Parenting vs Pet Care Posted: 5/8/2007 10:54:30 AM | ..and so owning a pet prepares you for raising a child how????LMAO... 'Bout as much as the "egg sitting" experiment in High Schools. Break it and F
I've seen enough of it to know that there is a correlation. yup...
Russell Weston Jr., tortured and killed 12 cats: burned and cut off their tails, paws, ears; poured toxic chemicals in their eyes to blind them; forced them to ingest poison, hung them from trees (the noose loose enough to create a slow and painful death.) Later killed 2 officers at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, DC.
Jeffery Dahmer staked cats to trees and decapitated dogs. Later he dissected boys, and kept their body parts in the refrigerator. Murdered 17 men.
Kip Kinkle shot 25 classmates and killed several in Springfield, Oregon. He killed his father and mother. Said he blew up a cow once. Set a live cat on fire and dragged the creature through the main street of town. Classmates rated him as "Most Likely to Start WWIII.”
As a boy, Albert De Salvo, the "Boston Strangler," placed a dog and cat in a crate with a partition between them. After starving the animals for days, he removed the partition to watch them kill each other. He raped and strangled 13 women. He often posed bodies in a shocking manner after their murders.
Richard Allen Davis set numerous cats on fire. He killed all of Polly Klaus' animals before abducting and murdering Polly Klaus, aged 12, from her bedroom. 11-year-old Andrew Golden and 13-year-old
Mitchell Johnson tortured and killed dogs. On March 24, 1998, in Jonesboro, Arkansas, Golden and Johnson shot and killed 4 students and 1 teacher during a fire drill at their school.
Most serial killers have abused animals at some point—By Kerry Kester, 2002 Cape Gazette Luke Woodham, a 16-year-old boy, once described beating, burning and torturing his dog to death as an act of °true beauty.° Later, he slew his mother with a knife, murdered two classmates and injured seven other people at school.
Jeffrey Dahmer had his mother’s permission to impale dogs and stake cats in his back yard. When he moved from abusing animals to humans, he opted to dismember the 17 boys and men before cannibalizing them.
Arthur Shawcross repeatedly threw a kitten into a lake until the kitten drowned from exhaustion. Killed a young girl. After serving 15-1/2 years in prison, he killed 11 more women. http://www.kinshipcircle.org/fact_sheets/AnimalVictimsHumanVictims.pdf BlindISee. Truth^^^
looking for spewed out crap Really....you researched it to the contrary....or *?* it materialized for amusement?
The FBI has recognized the connection since the l970s, when bureau analysis of the life histories of imprisoned serial killers suggested that most, as children, had killed or tortured animals. http://files.hsus.org/web-files/First_Strike/Investigators_Factsheet_2004.pdf#search=%22ANIMAL%20ABUSER%20PSYCHOLOGY%22 BlindbutseesAnyways...refer to my ealier posts. The flatulence? Pass...figuratively of course...
OT: Discipline of pets/animals /kids or even complete lack of interest in their well being is a cause for concern. | |
|