online dating service

Free Dating Site    

REGISTER | MAIL/PROFILE | HELP | NOW ONLINE | SEARCH | RATING | FORUMS | SUCCESS STORIES
Plentyoffish dating forums are a place to meet singles and get dating advice or share dating experiences etc. Hopefully you will all have fun meeting singles and try out this online dating thing... Remember that we are the largest 100% free online dating service, so you will never have to pay a dime to meet your soulmate.
     
Show ALL Forums  > Current Events  > FREE Federalized Health Care      Mod Threads Home login  
Page 2 of 31 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31
 Author Thread: FREE Federalized Health Care
 Merc4aGoodCause

Joined: 2/10/2006
Msg: 26
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/17/2007 9:20:44 AM
Ihaveaname, my post above yours differentiates between universal care and socialized medicine. You DO NOT need to rid the system of private care to obtain universal coverage.
 Ihaveaname4you

Joined: 6/12/2005
Msg: 27
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/17/2007 11:27:37 AM
merc4agoodcasue, well that is nice but why buy coverage when the governemnt is supplying it? I buy my own covereage at this time in my life but if it is free why pay? Also, why would companies continue to offer coverage as a benefit when the government will already be doing it for them ? I can see businesses canceling insurance policies along with individuals like me when government forces me to pay for their program instead of what I have chosesn. We are not going to pay for two policies! So, it is going to be up to the governement to take over the entire system when all the people who have insurance jump on the government train into the world of free everything.
 designingwoman

Joined: 9/4/2005
Msg: 28
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/17/2007 5:05:27 PM
We no longer have Free Care for the poor in Massachusetts because Mitt the Nitwit Romney decided to mandate that everyone have private insurance even if people can't afford the premiums.

Having real universal health care would be much better. I would love to have the choie to opt out of risking medical bankruptcy, etc. I'd rather pay a couple of extra bucks in taxes rather than see my assets go up in flame because a private insurer would not pay the medical bills or because of the excessive amount of copayments involved. UHC would benefit EVERYONE from the richest to the poorest.
 mfrotyl

Joined: 8/27/2007
Msg: 29
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/17/2007 8:21:51 PM
Death is part of life and unfortunately we can not change it. Yes it is sad, when someone's life is cut down by a terminal disease. especially the younger they are.

What we need is universal catastrophic healthcare and let the market decide what the rest of us pay.
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 30
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/18/2007 8:09:19 AM


Death is part of life and unfortunately we can not change it. Yes it is sad, when someone's life is cut down by a terminal disease. especially the younger they are.

What we need is universal catastrophic healthcare and let the market decide what the rest of us pay.


The ENTIRE advertising budget for the AMERICAN cancer society is about the LACK of access to medical treatment for people in the USA who have NO health insurance.
 designingwoman

Joined: 9/4/2005
Msg: 31
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/18/2007 7:26:44 PM
That's so true, nice guy. I feel that we as a society should pull together and have a good health care system so that the American Cancer Society can focus on other issues such as cancer research. No one should be denied care because of a greedy private insurance company or because the person cannot afford health insurance. Besides, even the wealthy can benefit from universal health care by not worrying about their hard earned assets being taken away due to overly high medical bills because of using an inadequate or greedy private insurance carrier when faced with catastrophic illness. Basically, UHC benefits EVERYONE, and I believe that it is high time that we as Americans stood together and demanded real health care for all.
 Merc4aGoodCause

Joined: 2/10/2006
Msg: 32
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/18/2007 7:36:28 PM
I wouldnt advocate for the goverment to give health benifits to those who are not in need of it. Like I said before the Clinton Plan makes BUISNESSES a substancial contributor. I wouldnt want it to be a large scale medicare or medicaid system as it costly with its buerocracy. Let the private system handle it. Crack the whip to make sure the docs, insurance programs, ect are doing the right thing and tell employers they need to cover their workers.
 logicalnonsense*

Joined: 10/12/2007
Msg: 33
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/18/2007 8:16:36 PM
Let me preface by saying I have no health insurance nor am I wealthy.
I am not interested in government funded or sponsored healthcare, no matter how low the cost. They are already taking freedom regarding our health and healthcare choices. Think: CODEX and WFO, compulsory vaccinations, human experimentation, think: Tuskegee experiment and Manhattan Project.

A VA hospital sent my grandfather home with 2 bottles of Maalox, when he had double pnemonia and then he almost died when they gave him steroids for the pneumonia without monitoring his blood sugar. The poor care isn't always because of unskilled help, but under compensated and overworked staff.

Every day we have new reports re: scientific evidence (adverse reactions, serious side effects, death) supporting lack of safety with drugs previously APPROVED by the FDA. The studies that the FDA uses to determine market safety are often done by scientists and labs bought and paid for by big pharma. You scratch my back, I'll scratch yours bullsh1t! I don't trust the government with mine or my childrens healthcare, therefore I would not participate unless tremendous changes were to occur and that's not likely in my lifetime. I'll take responsibility for my own healthcare. Apparently our government can't touch anything without corrupting it...

A link with a time line re: Goverment sanctioned experimentation

Experimentation on US Citizens. And the Beat Goes On

http://www.healthfreedomusa.org/index.php?p=474

Just a few of the things it touches on:
(1985)
A former U.S. Army sergeant tries to sue the Army for using drugs on him in without his consent or even his knowledge in United States v. Stanley, 483 U.S. 669. Justice Antonin Scalia writes the decision, clearing the U.S. military from any liability in past, present or future medical experiments without informed consent (Merritte, et al..

(1990)
The United States sends 1.7 million members of the armed forces, 22 percent of whom are African-American, to the Persian Gulf for the Gulf War (”Desert Storm”). More than 400,000 of these soldiers are ordered to take an experimental nerve agent medication called pyridostigmine, which is later believed to be the cause of Gulf War Syndrome — symptoms ranging from skin disorders, neurological disorders, incontinence, uncontrollable drooling and vision problems — affecting Gulf War veterans (Goliszek; Merritte, et al.).

The CDC and Kaiser Pharmaceuticals of Southern California inject 1,500 six-month-old black and Hispanic babies in Los Angeles with an “experimental” measles vaccine that had never been licensed for use in the United States. Adding to the risk, children less than a year old may not have an adequate amount of myelin around their nerves, possibly resulting in impaired neural development because of the vaccine. The CDC later admits that parents were never informed that the vaccine being injected into their children was experimental (Goliszek).

The FDA allows the U.S. Department of Defense to waive the Nuremberg Code and use unapproved drugs and vaccines in Operation Desert Shield (Sharav).

(1996)
The Department of Defense admits that Gulf War soldiers were exposed to chemical agents; however, 33 percent of all military personnel afflicted with Gulf War Syndrome never left the United States during the war, discrediting the popular mainstream belief that these symptoms are a result of exposure to Iraqi chemical weapons (Merritte, et al.).

(2002)
President George W. Bush signs the Best Pharmaceuticals for Children Act (BPCA), offering pharmaceutical companies six-month exclusivity in exchange for running clinical drug trials on children. This will of course increase the number of children used as human test subjects (Hammer Breslow).

 MikeTheWriter

Joined: 2/27/2006
Msg: 34
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/18/2007 9:53:14 PM
Agreed, logicalnonsense, this is an "organization" who cannot even deliver the mail correctly. Government funded schools cost four times what private schools do to educate kids. And think about any dealings you have with the government at any level and you realize you pay a chunk of money to be treated poorly by the bureaucrats who act as if they are doing you a favor by doing their jobs. Government healthcare is merely a way for the government to put your hands further into your pockets and increase their own power base.

I have private insurance that I pay for monthly. Last year I paid $2400 in premiums. I was able to deduct $240 on my taxes! If the legislators were truly sincere about caring that people received better coverage they would make all medical insurance premiums as well as what people pay out of pocket a deduction. However, their "sincerity" begins and ends with reaching into your wallet.

Viva libertarians! Viva Ron Paul!
 mfrotyl

Joined: 8/27/2007
Msg: 35
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/18/2007 9:54:18 PM
Go to any US Emergency room to request treatment. If they fail to treat you, they have violated federal law and you will have a nice settlement when the civil lawsuit is over, so how can you say there is no ACCESS????

Some people do not have medical insurance since they are:
a. so rich they do not need it. see Bill Gates.
b. between jobs and choose not to get COBRA
c. Illegal aliens, who can still get FREE healthcare
d. College graduates(a very health group compared to the rest of us) who have not found a job yet.

Also if Medicare and Medicaid are already for people who have no health insurance, are those programs failing to do their jobs?????
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 36
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 7:29:31 AM


Go to any US Emergency room to request treatment. If they fail to treat you, they have violated federal law and you will have a nice settlement when the civil lawsuit is over, so how can you say there is no ACCESS????


You can not get a nice settlement if you are DEAD !!!!!!



Some people do not have medical insurance since they are:
a. so rich they do not need it. see Bill Gates.
b. between jobs and choose not to get COBRA
c. Illegal aliens, who can still get FREE healthcare
d. College graduates(a very health group compared to the rest of us) who have not found a job yet.

Also if Medicare and Medicaid are already for people who have no health insurance, are those programs failing to do their jobs?????


Many of the uninsured can NOT get private health insurance due to an pre-existing condition or can NOT afford the premiums.

a. not too many people are that rich
b. if you are between jobs then many people can NOT afford COBRA because the income from unemployement insurance is not enought to afford the COBRA premiums
c. Illegal aliens are only about 12 million of the 45-50 million americans who are uninsured.
Illegal aliens do NOT get free healthcare and is a big myth.
d. many jobs now do NOT include health insurance or the health insurance is crappy.

Medicare is ONLY for people 65+ or on government disabitity pension (ie. steve stavros sp?)

Medicaid is for people under 130% of poverty line.

Only universal health care as proposed under bill HR676 will solve the acccess problem.
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 37
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 7:45:18 AM


Agreed, logicalnonsense, this is an "organization" who cannot even deliver the mail correctly.


You mean every social security cheque is NOT delived by the US postal service.

How much does it cost to send a letter from Los angeles to New York by the post office compared to FEDEX or UPS.



Government funded schools cost four times what private schools do to educate kids.


Source ?



And think about any dealings you have with the government at any level and you realize you pay a chunk of money to be treated poorly by the bureaucrats who act as if they are doing you a favor by doing their jobs. Government healthcare is merely a way for the government to put your hands further into your pockets and increase their own power base.


In canada the current federal government is a right wing one and totally in suport of our health care system and is pumping in more money to improve it.

I guess Canadians know better to run an government than americans do or elect better politicians.



I have private insurance that I pay for monthly. Last year I paid $2400 in premiums. I was able to deduct $240 on my taxes! If the legislators were truly sincere about caring that people received better coverage they would make all medical insurance premiums as well as what people pay out of pocket a deduction. However, their "sincerity" begins and ends with reaching into your wallet.


In my lifetime i have paid LESS then $200 out of pocket and that include drugs.

There are only deductables or co-pays in canada for drugs ONLY.

Canadians pay about the same FEDERAL income tax as Americans and that include the taxes that pay for our health care system.

The highest Federal Tax bracket in the USA is 35% and in Canada it is 29%.

A canadian has health insurance from before they are born till they die and canadian do NOT go bankrupt from medical bills.

A typical nursing home in Ontario costs $800 to $1500 a month depending on the resident's income and regulated.

I am a member of the family counsil at my mother's nursing home and once a month we meet with the staff to discuss ways to make life better for the residents.

There is also a resident counsil too.

When there is NO profit involved in health care then people only decide what doctor or hospital to go to based on QUALITY of service and NOT price.

HR676 (medicare for all) is NOT run by the federal government but by new health insurance companies who are run by STATES.

The current medicare administration system will be used for Universal health care (HR 676) and only additional employees and computer equipement will be needed.
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 38
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 7:51:02 AM


Yes socialized medicine is great in Cuba but is a Cuban stye economy what is best for America. you just have to realize that a whole lot of poeple are going to loose jobs and businesses are going to disapeer when we go Cuban style. I am not sure how many jobs there are in the health care sector that will have to be taken over by the government. Will if be cheaper for the government to buy the buildings and infrastructure from the private sector or rent them from the private parties? I think that the governement should think about how many people it is planing to take jobs from when no one no longer is paying their salries.


Under HR 676 the governent health insurance companies runs by each of the states will PAY the bills ONLY but the current health care system (doctors, hospitals) will stay the same.
 Jiperly

Joined: 8/30/2006
Msg: 39
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 8:35:28 AM
>>>
How much does it cost to send a letter from Los angeles to New York by the post office compared to FEDEX or UPS.

Cheaper, but not because the post office does it better or even cheaper- its because its against federal law to transport letters cheaper than the federal post office- they have whats called a Statutory monopoly. Basically, if you offer to do their services for less, you're breaking the law. The exemption that UPS and Fedex have is they can deliver it, but at a higher price and cannot use mailboxes.

According to Wikipedia, this has been outlined in Article I, Section 8, Clause 7 of the Constitution, which lasted up until 1979, when competition was allowed, so long as it was twice the cost of the post office.

In the mid 1800's, there was direct competition with the postal office, spefically with Lysander Spooner, who offered a superior service at a lower cost to the US Mail, which quickly forced the US Mail to rapidly drop its prices in order to stay competitive, before Mr. Spooners business was closed down by the government because he dared to build a better business. The average price for postage in 1845 for federal systems was 14.5 cents, while private systems was 5 cents. By 1851, the federal system was cut down to 3 cents, with all private systems by then being outlawed. Also, by 1860, the United States Postal System officially depended on taxes for over half of their expenses, while 15 years earlier, they were entirely self sufficient.

So its not unrealistic to imagine the government closing businesses because they can't compete. They've done it before.

>>>In canada the current federal government is a right wing one and totally in suport of our health care system and is pumping in more money to improve it.

Because if something isn't working, throw money at it!

>>>In my lifetime i have paid LESS then $200 out of pocket and that include drugs.

I will be lucky if I don't have to shell out $1000 next year, despite never once requiring medical services.

Hell, I had to shell out $200 out of my pocket before I was 15, so I dunno under what rock you've been living- drugs and treatment are not universally free in Canada. Could you please justify why I should have to pay for other peoples medical expenses while my actual medical needs are completely ignored?

>>>canadian do NOT go bankrupt from medical bills.

Anyone wanna take this one?

>>>When there is NO profit involved in health care then people only decide what doctor or hospital to go to based on QUALITY of service and NOT price.

What about to the Doctors? They certainly have a mountain of school bills to pay? Why shouldn't they profit after nearly a decade of training?

Not to mention, Quality of service may be one thing, but Quantity is a huge issue in Canada- there simply are not enough Doctors to go around.
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 40
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 8:56:39 AM


I will be lucky if I don't have to shell out $1000 next year, despite never once requiring medical services.


In the USA they have deductable and that is now much you pay out of pocket for a medical bills each year BEFORE the health insurance pays anything.

If you are talking about $1000 in taxes ... then a healthy american pays from $1000 to $2000 a year in health premiums and that is comparable.



Hell, I had to shell out $200 out of my pocket before I was 15, so I dunno under what rock you've been living- drugs and treatment are not universally free in Canada.


I did NOT say anything about dental and that is what i have spend money out of pocket.

i am almost 46 ... and OHIP started when i was about 7.

I have rarely need drugs and my diebitics is under control with out pills.


Could you please justify why I should have to pay for other peoples medical expenses while my actual medical needs are completely ignored?


You are young so do NOT understand that when you are older then other people are helping to pay for your medical treatment.



>>>canadian do NOT go bankrupt from medical bills.

Anyone wanna take this one?


In the USA about 1 in 2 bankrupt are at least partly or fully the result of medical bills.



What about to the Doctors? They certainly have a mountain of school bills to pay? Why shouldn't they profit after nearly a decade of training?


A GP in canada make about the same as ones in the USA but medical education for a canadian doctor is much less. Also admistration costs are much less for a canadian doctor.



Not to mention, Quality of service may be one thing, but Quantity is a huge issue in Canada- there simply are not enough Doctors to go around.


That is an issue in most countries including the USA and a concern because many doctors will be retiring in the next ten years.
 MikeTheWriter

Joined: 2/27/2006
Msg: 41
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 9:01:09 AM
Well, nice guy, glad you asked: So, if some social security checks get to the the right places we should celebrate? Sorry but I get at least 1 to 4 pieces PER WEEK of incorrect mail sent to me at my home and business. I'd hate to have a government Dr. who had this "success" rate when it came to surgeries. And while we are on the subject of screwups let's take a look at the big picture of the US government keeping their promises to the electorate. When social security was first established under the administration of that wonderful socialist Franklin Roosevelt it was NEVER supposed to exceed 3% maximum employer and employee contributions well guess what skippy, it's now 15.3%. Take a look at all the changes and ponzi scams made towards social security in this country and you can see it is a shell game played by greedy politicians who merely wanted another way to control something else from the uneducated populace.

And if you want to look at government making a mess of something you just have to look at health care in general. In the 1960's (the Great, ha ha, Society) going to the Dr. was affordable for most Americans. Enter Medicare/Medicaid and guess what? Dr.'s bills went from reasonable where you didn't need insurance to astronomical where you had to have it.

As for government schools being a waste of money just take a look at the graduation rates of states like NY and NJ who throw massive amounts of money into the system vs a place like Minnesota who spends a lot less but has higher graduation rates. Then compare what students who get a public school education vs students in other countries and you will see that US students rank at the bottom in math and science when compared to students in other countries (where far less is spent per student)

We might agree on the point that perhaps Canadian citizens may elect better people to office. The system here is inherently corrupt and as for getting the best and brightest to run, look who our president is and you can see that this does not apply. And this further illustrates my other point that you missed re: the political actors and their woeful attempts to "give me government run healthcare because they are just good guys wanting to help out all Americans." Once again, my point is that I paid a decent amount for my benefits and 10% was deductible. Why? Because the corrupt politicians want me to scream, "TAKE CARE OF ME" to them and they want me to gladly give them carte blanche because they currently run a system that they have A) caused out of control inflation and B) refuse to give people tax breaks to insure that the system remains broken so that they can come to the rescue and confiscate more money from the taxpayers. Right now an American has to work till around May to take care of their tax burden based upon the current system. If this country did institute nationalized healthcare what then, would we have to work till August to pay our taxes? Why don't we all just have our checks directly deposited to the federal government? Because that is their goal. As you yourself wrote, Americans have a tax rate where the highest bracket if 6% higher than in Canada and that is without a national health plan. (we also have a deficit that is killing the dollar, thanks GW) The bottom line here is that the current system in the US is VERY CORRUPT and the smoke and mirrors show that both parties show is a very bad joke and, personally, I don't want to give them any more power over my life.
 prescient

Joined: 10/6/2007
Msg: 42
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 9:28:03 AM

In my lifetime i have paid LESS then $200 out of pocket and that include drugs.

Yeah, those must be the drugs you smoked to arrive at the conclusions you posted.

For you Americans who are sick and tired of Canadians telling you that we pay a similar amount of taxes, watch this 30 second clip for the real picture on taxation in Canada. Refer any Canadian to this clip when they start going on about the Canadian "utopia".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66-we_JsG8M

I would imagine that the only people in Canada who pay the same taxes as their American counterparts are homeless bums.

For starters, people in Ontario with a salary of over $20,000.00 have to pay a $300.00 - 900.00 health care Premium (On top of taxes that they already pay).


Almost every Canadian household (98.2%) reported health care expenditures in 1998, spending an average of close to $1,200, up from around $900 in 1978. In 1998, households dedicated a larger share of their average after-tax spending (2.9%) to health care than they did 20 years earlier (2.3%). Health insurance premiums claimed the largest share (29.8%) of average health care expenditures, followed by dental care, then prescription medications and pharmaceutical products.

http://www.statcan.ca/english/studies/82-003/feature/hrab2000012001s3a04.htm

This was in 1998, I can only imagine how much more this figure has climbed to in 2007. For one thing, prescription glasses are no longer covered by the health insurance plan, so all you four-eyes out there would be paying a whack more on top of this. This is all on top of the apportioned amount of your taxes that go to health care

Now we get to the nitty gritty of how much of your tax dollars go towards health care.
Federally - 1.6 % of your tax revenue goes towards health care. (Don't forget though that 17.5% of your federal tax dollars are transfered to the provinces)
Provincially - 30.5 % of your tax revenue goes towards health care.
http://dsp-psd.pwgsc.gc.ca/Collection-R/LoPBdP/EB/prb0235-e.htm#expenditurestxt

So now, work out the math a bit.
If you earn $36,000 a year in Ontario - barely a living wage in Ontario.
You are paying $ 144.00 in federal taxes to healthcare
$1592.00 in provincial taxes to healthcare
$ 500.00 in health care "premiums"
$1200.00 in extra "health care expenditures".

You've paid almost $3500.00 and can't even get a pair of reading glasses.
What happens when you work outside of Canada for a significant part of the year? Well, on top of paying all your taxes, you have to purchase extra insurance.

We pay all this for;

High-priced Canadian health care system provides poor access to care compared to other nations

http://www.taxtyranny.ca/index.php?command=show&ID=12159
 Jiperly

Joined: 8/30/2006
Msg: 43
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 9:30:47 AM
>>>I did NOT say anything about dental and that is what i have spend money out of pocket.

I need glasses- that means I have to pay for a Doctor for a prescription, and a technician to construct my glasses. Furthermore, I have a few chipped teeth. None of these are included in the taxes I pay towards my health- I have lived a relatively healthy life. And yet a fair sum of my money for each paycheck goes towards something that, if I were to choose not to pay because for 1/5 of my life thus far it is completely worthless, I would be sent to a place to be raped by criminals.

>>>You are young so do NOT understand that when you are older then other people are helping to pay for your medical treatment.

Oh, i get it- I cannot possibly comprehend the fact that my money is being taken from me not to benefit me, but to benefit others against my will.

See; MikeTheWriter's comments about the Government having their hand in my pocket

And what if I want to reject it? What if I want to take my money over the years and set it aside in case of future accidents? Or what if choose to take my money and invest it in, of all things, a private insurance company that actually contributes to my medical needs? I work hard for my money, and even if I'm wrongfully investing it, who are you to decide where I should spend my money? Moreover, if we're taking decades from now, then save the most extreme circumstances, I would easily be able to afford it with the taxes saved, let alone afford it through private insurance.

>>>In the USA about 1 in 2 bankrupt are at least partly or fully the result of medical bills.

Gotta source?

>>>A GP in canada make about the same as ones in the USA but medical education for a canadian doctor is much less. Also admistration costs are much less for a canadian doctor.

Once again, Source please.

But I don't think its really a great thing to brag about how Canadian doctors have less education- nor does it really address my issue. You claimed that healthcare shouldn't be led by profit- but even ours is- all healthcare is, and to believe that people will spend nearly a decade in study and ask for nothing but the bare minimum in return is living in denile.

>>>That is an issue in most countries including the USA and a concern because many doctors will be retiring in the next ten years.

And is universal healthcare really attracting the doctors our country desperately needs?
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 44
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 9:39:55 AM

The evidence is overwhelming; the Canadian health care model is inferior to those used in other OECD countries. The models that work best have user fees; alternative, comprehensive, privately funded care; and private hospitals that compete for patient demand,” Esmail said.

“None of these reforms mean the Americanization of Canadian health care. The choice is between what we have now and finding a better way to deliver universal access to health care. It’s about emulating the successful models in European and Asian countries that do a better job than Canada’s at delivering on the promise of universal access to high quality care in a timely fashion regardless of ability to pay.”




fraser institute is NOT a creditable source for information.



THEY ARE PUSHING FOR TWO-TIER HEALTH CARE.

[quite]
http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/publications_show.htm?doc_id=620087

U.S. health spending is projected to increase from 16 percent of GDP in 2006 to 20 percent in 2016—from $2 trillion to $4 trillion. Meanwhile, the number of uninsured Americans continues to rise. In this report prepared for The Commonwealth Fund Commission on a High Performance Health System, the authors examine 15 federal policy options that have the potential to lower health spending relative to projected trends. They include policies that would: produce and use better information for health care decision-making, promote health and enhance disease prevention, align financial incentives with quality and efficiency, and correct price signals in health care markets. Combining policies would capture the synergistic benefits of individual changes. If implemented along with universal health insurance, a combination of selected options could save $1.5 trillion in national health expenditures over 10 years, while also improving value in terms of access, quality, and health care outcomes.


The American health care system in the USA is a mess



So now, work out the math a bit.
If you earn $36,000 a year in Ontario - barely a living wage in Ontario.
You are paying $ 144.00 in federal taxes to healthcare
$1592.00 in provincial taxes to healthcare
$ 500.00 in health care "premiums"
$1200.00 in extra "health care expenditures".


A family of 4 health care costs in the USA are in the $12000 a year range and you are comparing a $2,400 in Ontario..

Most american WANT a health insurance system like OHIP.

HR 676 makes OHIP look like a poor cousin ... but people in Ontario can elect people to improve OHIP and people in the USA have no contol over an health insurance company.
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 45
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 9:46:10 AM


I need glasses- that means I have to pay for a Doctor for a prescription, and a technician to construct my glasses.


You have a FREE eye exam every 2 years in Ontario



Furthermore, I have a few chipped teeth. None of these are included in the taxes I pay towards my health-


People have private insurance for dental and eyeglasses and it was usually paid 50/50 by employee and employer so chipped teeth is not a issue.

I have all my wisdom teeth pull while i had dental insurance.



I have lived a relatively healthy life. And yet a fair sum of my money for each paycheck goes towards something that, if I were to choose not to pay because for 1/5 of my life thus far it is completely worthless, I would be sent to a place to be raped by criminals.


Just whining about taxes.... ok ... taxes pay for roads, police department, fire department, etc ...
 capegardengirl

Joined: 4/29/2006
Msg: 46
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 10:58:06 AM
"Let the private system handle it..Crack the whip to make sure the docs, insurance companies ect are doing the right thing"

A very simplistic answer that doesnt address the real problem...Healthcare providers are doing the right thing....We are forced to...We are forced to jump thru the beaurocratic expensive wasteful hoops of managed care...Its the insurance companies who waste money, change the rules and deny healthcare coverage and benefits so they can make a profit...They dont have to do the right thing...WHY do people allow that?......Why do people mistakenly assume private healthcare doesnt have beaurocracy and waste?....It has more, much more because they are unregulated and dont have to follow any rules like heathcare providers do and the govt. does.......How is that fiscally responsible???....Insurance companies are the cause of the beaurocracy much more than any govt programs...Govt programs are regulated, health insurance companies are NOT regulated by anyone....How do you "crack the whip" on beaurocratic insurance companies who have dont have to answer to anyone?...Why would you support unlimited corporate welfare run amuck?...Make insurance companies accountable for their decisions instead of letting them pass the buck and responsibility.....Why do you want a business MBA to make your healthcare decisions rather than your doctor?.....This politically correct hero worship of private health insurance is rediculous
 MikeTheWriter

Joined: 2/27/2006
Msg: 47
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 11:36:04 AM
I used to pay claims for an insurance company and it was pretty brutal and most people didn't understand what they had signed, however, they did sign the forms.

There is a lot of blame to go around for the problems in the US re: healthcare. First and foremost it is the attorneys. And what profession makes up the largest portion of the Congress? Yep, the attorneys. Lawsuits and fear of them jacks up the costs for doctors and that results in their fees being more expensive. Related to this are lobbyists who are the customers for the political whores (known as elected officials) who have prostituted themselves for money which enables them to stay in power. The question is: Should we create a system that gives politicians and bureaucrats more money out of our pockets and more power to do as they please? Not until massive reforms occur and the onus of this MUST be put on the electorate to clean house and reform the political system which (and this may just be an unrealistic ideal) actually serves those who elect them.
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 48
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 5:31:35 PM

For you Americans who are sick and tired of Canadians telling you that we pay a similar amount of taxes, watch this 30 second clip for the real picture on taxation in Canada. Refer any Canadian to this clip when they start going on about the Canadian "utopia".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66-we_JsG8M

I would imagine that the only people in Canada who pay the same taxes as their American counterparts are homeless bums.


The highest FEDERAL tax rate in the USA is 35% and in Canada it is 29%.

Most american states have state taxes and also sales taxes and property taxes etc.

The difference is not much but in Canada our taxes pay for our health care and in the USA the person and employer still have to pay health insurance premiums.



For starters, people in Ontario with a salary of over $20,000.00 have to pay a $300.00 - 900.00 health care Premium (On top of taxes that they already pay).


In the USA a family of 4 usually pays about $12000 a year for health insurance ....



Almost every Canadian household (98.2%) reported health care expenditures in 1998, spending an average of close to $1,200, up from around $900 in 1978. In 1998, households dedicated a larger share of their average after-tax spending (2.9%) to health care than they did 20 years earlier (2.3%). Health insurance premiums claimed the largest share (29.8%) of average health care expenditures, followed by dental care, then prescription medications and pharmaceutical products.

http://www.statcan.ca/english/studies/82-003/feature/hrab2000012001s3a04.htm


Minor problems in canada with cost of medical treatment but in the USA a completely different story.




http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/publications_show.htm?doc_id=568237


Skipping Care Because of Costs
In the U.S., 37 percent of all adults surveyed—and 42 percent of those with chronic conditions—skipped medications, did not see a doctor when sick, or did not obtain recommended care in the past year because of the cost. These rates are well above those found in the other six countries. Few people in Canada, the Netherlands, and the U.K. reported skipping care because they could not afford it.

A high proportion of U.S. adults also have serious problems paying medical bills—nearly one-fifth (19%), more than double the rate in the next highest country. Nearly one-third (30%) of U.S. survey respondents spent more than $1,000 in the past year in out-of-pocket medical costs. Nineteen percent of Australians and 12 percent of Canadians spent this much; rates were even lower elsewhere.

Affordability concerns may well be the reason that a third (34%) of U.S. respondents said the health care system needs to be rebuilt completely. This was the highest rate of any of the seven countries



Commonwealth fund is a solid source of information and the fraser institute is NOT and only libertarians and far-right people quote them.
 mfrotyl

Joined: 8/27/2007
Msg: 49
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/19/2007 10:37:15 PM
If Canadian healthcare is so great, why do Canadians,especially those with terminal diseases come to the US to get treatment, since they can not get timely treatment in Canada???
 niceguy99a

Joined: 3/5/2006
Msg: 50
view profile
History
FREE Federalized Health Care
Posted: 12/20/2007 7:55:46 AM


If Canadian healthcare is so great, why do Canadians,especially those with terminal diseases come to the US to get treatment, since they can not get timely treatment in Canada???


source ???

The population of Canada just went over the 33 million mark and the number of canadian who get medical treatment in the USA is small.

Many canadian goto the USA on business trips and vacations.

Many canadian senior live in Florida for part of the winter and get out-of-country health insurance so if they get sick in the USA and need medical treatment then PART of the cost is paid by the provincial health insurance company and the rest by the out-of-country health insurance.

Long Waiting list in canada are a MYTH.



http://www.cancercare.on.ca/index_waittimesRadiation.asp#Trend

This radiation treatment wait time information helps patients and physicians make decisions about cancer treatment. Patients and physicians should decide together whether it is appropriate for the patient to be referred to a treatment facility outside their area or Local Health Integration Network (LHIN). If it is appropriate, the physician will contact the treatment centre and make the necessary arrangements. If the physician refers the patient to a regional cancer centre outside of the patient’s LHIN, the patient is responsible for all travel and accommodation expenses incurred as a result.

Over the last three years, median provincial radiation wait times have dropped 31%, from 6 weeks in fall 2003 to 4.1 weeks in fall 2006. From fall 2005 to fall 2006, radiation wait times went down from 4.3 weeks to 4.1 weeks, a decrease of 7% in one year.


In ontario the waiting time for cancer treatment are decreasing and in the USA the American cancer society ad budget is for LACK of access for cancer patient who DO NOT HAVE health insurance.


For a cancer patient with NO health insurance in the USA then the wait time could be till they die from cancer.


My mother had breast cancer and GOT very timely treatment and is now cancer FREE for over 20 years...

She did NOT need chemo or radiation since the cancer was caught in STAGE 1 during an routine yearly mamogram.

Can you say that someone you know.
Page 2 of 31 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31
 
Show ALL Forums  > Current Events  > FREE Federalized Health Care