online dating service

Free Dating Site    

REGISTER | MAIL/PROFILE | HELP | NOW ONLINE | SEARCH | RATING | FORUMS | SUCCESS STORIES
Plentyoffish dating forums are a place to meet singles and get dating advice or share dating experiences etc. Hopefully you will all have fun meeting singles and try out this online dating thing... Remember that we are the largest 100% free online dating service, so you will never have to pay a dime to meet your soulmate.
     
Show ALL Forums  > Relationships  > Catholicism vs Wiccan      Mod Threads Home login  
Page 17 of 15 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15
 Author Thread: Catholicism vs Wiccan
 Jacobus101

Joined: 12/30/2007
Msg: 339
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/16/2008 6:57:20 PM
Allow me to weigh in on the original topic.

notime4boys said:


<div class="quote">I am Catholic also, and I date people of many faiths, but I would never date someone from the occult. Wiccan people will tell you they are witches with powers. I work with someone who is wiccan. Scary scary stuff. I think you should thank God you have a family who loves you enough to be honest and would like for you to live with the Christian values you were raised with. I'm not saying she is evil, but where do you draw the line?
Good Luck to you

Personally, I don't see much of a difference between a Catholic choosing to date a Wiccan and him choosing to date a Muslim, Buddhist, or an atheist. I'm not saying any of those are alike, but they're all non-Christian. So, if one is okay with dating a non-Christian of any kind, a Wiccan is simply one who belongs to that category.

As for me, I have no problem dating people of other denominations or religions, as long as they're not anti-Catholic. However, if she wants to marry me, she'll have to sincerely convert. For those who see Catholicism or any other religion as more of a cultural or ethnic thing, or something practiced in private, mixed marriages might work. I can easily see that if I had a mixed marriage, though, it would be a disaster. When I start a family, I would like to set up a special room in my house as a chapel, complete with stained glass windows and an altar to pray at, and for a priest to say Mass at sick calls or house blessings. I'd try to pray at least Lauds and Vespers (the morning and evening hours of the Divine Office) daily with my family at home, if not attend daily Masses. It would really be just too much for a non-Catholic wife to handle without going nuts.
 outofthedesert

Joined: 12/9/2007
Msg: 340
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/17/2008 4:35:36 AM
Should anyone need to post to me--email me. I am sticking a fork in this thread because for me it is done.

I am heading over to the other end of the pond.






 redarcangel

Joined: 1/12/2007
Msg: 341
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/18/2008 12:30:21 PM
Claypot..

Your statement; Once again, Red needs to have the last word, HER word is the only TRUE version.

I have NO idea what this is supposed to mean..I give MO..and do the research on the facts I state..I ask questions..and am not afraid of learning something about which I have no education..such as the Catholic/catholic religion. I continually state how grateful I am to others such as Jacobus..OOTD..and others who are willing to provide me with intelligent insight. To those..that teach..I am humble. To those that spew venom..and give false information..I once again..remain humble. Blessed be Claypot.

Your statement; BUT if one chooses to research either, they would find out the the catholics put the BAD NAME of the Wicca.

This statement sounds pretty matter-of-fact to me..and as though YOU chose to do the "research" yourself.

Your statement; Wicca evolved long before the 50's, it was in fact(researched) that practicing Wicca's scraced the crap out of the higher ups in the catholic faith.

The reason I was laughing..was because this is a statement that has been researched..and already provided in the thread..and it is "not" a fact. If you had been reading all along..you may have seen this. I took it in a rather light manner I think.

Your statement; Personally, I don't practice on a regular basis, but I have done the leg work and have read the history, and yes, even played around with it. What I felt at the time of experimenting was in fact COMFORT.

By stating that you "have done the leg work and read the history"..I assumed you meant you researched this religion..would know who brought Wicca to light..and the "experimenting" meant that you didn't actually practice..but had "experimented" in the practice of Wicca.

You may also want to think of this as a learning tool..as I have. Just a suggestion of course..for I certainly don't think I reign supreme. I also try not to make statements that are contradictory of facts..but try to learn a humble lesson from others.

Then again..I wasn't taking my statement to you as seriously as you obviously took mine. Again..my humble apologies. I thought the icons provided some insight to the lightness of my reply..as I was trying to be helpful..by correcting an "oversight" you stated as factual.

I just thought this was an attempt you were making at being light;

Your statement; BTW........I didn't hit ALL the pages, LOL, it was cracking me up to much, so first 2, then zipped to the 9th, by then I had to just say my piece, so if you have read this all before, So sorry, but this is my 2 cents worth.

Your statement; I could go on, but I won't push the fact that SOME do not practice what they preach. I give those who spew out bs room all the time and don't call them on it, so don't come here and say I DON"T know what I'm talking about.

If you were insinuating that I don't practice what I preach means..me. I don't preach my faith to anyone but..tell the facts as they are stated..there's no bs involved. I'm also sorry to see when someone spouts what they "believe" to be facts..but don't know..or care..for whatever reason..to do the actual research "before" disputing facts that have been previously presented..as being someone that doesn't know what they are talking about as being upsetting enough to stoop to such childish behavior as SCREAMING your thoughts and making accusations "at" someone. I think I could have been very harsh..or cruel..but I have no room in my heart or enough time on my hands to waste with such hostilities. May you find peace and love in your heart.
 redarcangel

Joined: 1/12/2007
Msg: 342
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/18/2008 1:07:39 PM
Jacobus..

Once again..I want to thank you for all this information and the time it took you to present it so well. I feel more knowledgeable of the facts..and have found it a true pleasure in conversating with you. OOTD will also get a thank you in her e-mail.
I have a true passion for learning..and feel very satisfied in your answers and love the way you you presented this information.

I do wonder about prayer though..is that..or rather..could that be considered a form of meditation as well as offering conversation? That is..talking to your God..right?

I was raised in the United Methodist church from the time I was baptized..until I was 14..a Protestant church. LOL. I found it to be less than satisfactory as a way of life for me. I researched a few different religions that were available to me..and found Celtic Witta Traditional Solitary Practitioner to be the most insightful..comfortable..and giving religion in my area at that time. I have since moved to an area that is mainly of the Catholic/catholic religions..and have been in a querry as to their beliefs..and especially as they reflect on and towards my own beliefs. I think you have provided some very vital information for me that is only found within the Catholic/catholic Churches/churches..and will now feel much more comfortable when conversating with someone of these strong religious beliefs.

Arapaho..

I am still uncertain of which type of Wiccan faith you follow. I hope I brought a tad of insight to you on the different types of Wicca and Paganism that be.

For those that are scared of Wiccans..I have no idea why. Our reliegion teaches us to be humble and thought worthy..to be giving before receiving..to love nature and to be humbled by its voracity..to love ourselves..to be strong in our convictions..and to harm no one..ever. Blessed Be to all!
 lindy_3333

Joined: 3/6/2006
Msg: 343
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/24/2008 4:42:05 AM
I can't believe this thread is even going still.... Oh well, I figure if someone really wants to discuss this realistically, email me... I lived both sides of these issues. I researched and for now found my path. If anyone has new knowledge, my opinion is open to change. But not if your knowledge is based soley on tradition and stories. I'm open to deep thinking, not mimicking and copy pasting what some church tells it's people to do and believe.

Brings to mind the Matrix... red pill, or blue. You know which one I chose, since I am not longer hooked up to the machinery!!

Have a wonderful life .. in reality or fantacy, which ever you chose!

Linda

 Jacobus101

Joined: 12/30/2007
Msg: 344
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/24/2008 9:45:47 AM
Lindy 3333 said:


Brings to mind the Matrix... red pill, or blue. You know which one I chose, since I am not longer hooked up to the machinery!!


The Matrix films can be interpreted to mean a lot of things. As for myself, I often tend to look at them as a Christian allegory. The Wachowski brothers have said that they drew a lot of material from Gnostic Christianity. Like the red and blue pill, Christianity presents a man with the choice to decide between the kingdom of God and the kingdom of the world (or as St. Augustine has it, the city of God and the city of man); to be enslaved by sin or freed from it by Christ. In the Matrix films, there's also a Messiah figure in the character of Neo.


Redarcangel said:


I do wonder about prayer though..is that..or rather..could that be considered a form of meditation as well as offering conversation? That is..talking to your God..right?


The contemplative life is something that's almost unheard of in American Christianity. American religion inherited the anti-monastic attitudes of the Reformation. Monasteries and convents were seen as houses of sodomy and/or brothels, such as in 19th century literature like "Maria Monk" and Charles Chiniquy's "Fifty Years in the Church of Rome".

But in the whole Christian tradition, we know of the many communities of men and women (monks and nuns) who separate themselves from the world to dedicate themselves to God in a lifetime of prayer and meditation. They assemble seven times a day for prayer services in what's called the Divine Office. The tradition of Christian meditation can be found in the spiritual writings of the 16th century abbess, St. Teresa of Avila and her concept of the four interior castles of the soul.

If I may show from Wikipedia:


The kernel of Teresa's mystical thought throughout all her writings is the ascent of the soul in four stages (Autobiography, Chs. 10-22):

The first, or "heart's devotion," is that of devout contemplation or concentration, the withdrawal of the soul from without and specially the devout observance of the passion of Christ and penitence.

The second is the "devotion of peace," in which at least the human will is lost in that of God by virtue of a charismatic, supernatural state given of God, while the other faculties, such as memory, reason, and imagination, are not yet secure from worldly distraction. While a partial distraction is due to outer performances such as repetition of prayers and writing down spiritual things, yet the prevailing state is one of quietude.

The "devotion of union" is not only a supernatural but an essentially ecstatic state. Here there is also an absorption of the reason in God, and only the memory and imagination are left to ramble. This state is characterized by a blissful peace, a sweet slumber of at least the higher soul faculties, a conscious rapture in the love of God.

The fourth is the "devotion of ecstasy or rapture," a passive state, in which the consciousness of being in the body disappears (II Cor. xii. 2-3). Sense activity ceases; memory and imagination are also absorbed in God or intoxicated. Body and spirit are in the throes of a sweet, happy pain, alternating between a fearful fiery glow, a complete impotence and unconsciousness, and a spell of strangulation, intermitted sometimes by such an ecstatic flight that the body is literally lifted into space. This after half an hour is followed by a reactionary relaxation of a few hours in a swoon-like weakness, attended by a negation of all the faculties in the union with God. From this the subject awakens in tears; it is the climax of mystical experience, productive of the trance. (Indeed, St. Theresa herself was said to have been observed levitating during mass on more than one occasion.)

Teresa is one of the foremost writers on mental prayer. Her definition was used in the Catechism of the Catholic Church: "Mental prayer [oracion mental] is nothing else than a close sharing between friends; it means taking time frequently to be alone with him who we know loves us."
 DamCute

Joined: 8/10/2007
Msg: 345
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/26/2008 11:06:35 PM
Jacobus101

WOW!
Not snarky. Not super-defensive. Not self-righteous at all. I love your posts. I actually (no offense guys) bypassed everyone else's just to read your posts.

And you didn't mangle any Italian words. hehe

I would like to know where you get your information though. Could you message me with the info you quoted about St. Theresa? Someone was talking to me in refrence to her and I'd like to read up on her. EWTN.com's just not cutting it for me at the present moment, as I have '98 dialup and well, you know that's going to crap as far as loading pages. Someday.

Much appreciated.

Have you ever heard of Cursillo?
 DamCute

Joined: 8/10/2007
Msg: 346
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/26/2008 11:08:41 PM
Also, Anyone heard of Strega?

May I ask your thoughts and input on that or am I just opening up another can of worms.. . hmmmmmmm

 Cueil

Joined: 11/13/2007
Msg: 347
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/26/2008 11:14:17 PM
This shouldn't even be an issue... if you love her that's fine, but if you were truly in love with this woman this question wouldn't even be posed... I know i told my grand parents and mother to goto hell when they raised the issue up... my ex was Wiccan and I loved her intensely so all the family disagreement in the world meant nothing... if you truely love this woman then this is a non issue... she's your woman not theirs so they can live with the idea and move on
 Cueil

Joined: 11/13/2007
Msg: 348
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/26/2008 11:35:19 PM
Who could be part of a passive religion? There is noone in here who doesn't have something they wouldn't fight for... tell me that if someone tried to kill your child that their lives would not be forfiet... if another country invaded that you wouldn't stand next to me to defend this country?...it is a good thing in theory, but we are humans and in practice it only can exist as long as there are people like me who defend them... it is the job of the strong to protect the weak from those who would kill them for being weak...

BTW different religions in a relationship works just fine... just remember let the children choose their own religion for themselves...
 Jacobus101

Joined: 12/30/2007
Msg: 349
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/26/2008 11:57:21 PM
damcute:

Thanks, I'm glad you like my postings. About St. Teresa of Avila, let me send you some links about her.

Patron Saints Index: most basic biographical info, how she's portrayed in art, date of canonization, feast day, and some quotes from her writings. http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/saintt01.htm

Catholic Online: A more comprehensive biography, but still an easy read. http://www.catholic.org/saints/saint.php?saint_id=208

The Catholic Encyclopedia: The most in-depth, but complex, bio. http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14515b.htm

The Carmelite Sisters: Site where you can read all of St. Teresa's books online. "The Way of Perfection", "The Interior Castle", the Autobiography, the Letters, and the Poems. http://www.carmelite-seremban.org/Spirituality/books.html

Finally, there's always good ol' Wikipedia. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teresa_of_Avila

This is a good Wikipedia page on Gian Lorenzo Bernini's famous sculpture (and one of my all-time favorites), the Ecstasy of St. Teresa. Interestingly, her heart shows signs of being pierced, as though with an arrow. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecstasy_of_St_Theresa



Have you ever heard of Cursillo?


LOL, I had to look it up on the Internet. I've never heard of it before. I found the Cursillo website for my archdiocese, though, and saved the phone number so I can call them about it later for more info. Their organization is having a pre-Lent retreat of some sort that I could probably use. Man, Lent is really early this year.


Also, Anyone heard of Strega?


I assume you mean the Italian form of witchcraft? It seems to be a set of pre-Christian beliefs mixed/syncretized with Christian ones. Can't say much more than that, though.


Cueil said:


Who could be part of a passive religion? There is noone in here who doesn't have something they wouldn't fight for... tell me that if someone tried to kill your child that their lives would not be forfiet... if another country invaded that you wouldn't stand next to me to defend this country?...it is a good thing in theory, but we are humans and in practice it only can exist as long as there are people like me who defend them... it is the job of the strong to protect the weak from those who would kill them for being weak...


I agree, and I freely admit to holding to a more "militant" form of faith, although I'm certainly not a violent person by nature (although I am also a soldier). "No greater love a man hath than to give his life for his friends." Although I don't criticize those who take up a more pacifist approach to Christianity or other faiths. Certainly,t he world could use less fighting.

In my uniform shoulder pocket, below the flag, I carry a small booklet written by Bishop Fulton J. Sheen, when His Excellency was still a priest during the Second World War, called the "Wartime Prayer Book". Inside it contains a lot of various meditations and thoughts by Sheen about war. Since it was written for American soldiers in WWII, there are many references to fighting Hitler, etc. But regarding your comment, this excerpt is quite relevant. Bishop Sheen quotes the 19th-century French Dominican priest, Father Henri-Dominique Lacordaire:


The great French preacher Lacordaire once said the vocation of a soldier is next in dignity to the priesthood, not only because it commissioned him to defend justice on the field of battle and order on the field of peace, but also because it called him to the spirit and intention of sacrifice.
 outofthedesert

Joined: 12/9/2007
Msg: 350
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 4:14:22 AM
I can't believe I am back on this thread............somebody shoot me.............

Cursillo is a retreat to help you have a deeper walk. You normally are sponsored by another who has attended. If you are part of a Church, ask the priest or someone in the educational department. Most larger Churches have a Cursillo Alumini group who continue to meet long after the retreat time.
 TheS0urce

Joined: 1/3/2008
Msg: 351
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 4:44:12 AM
I guess i shouldn't date catholics since many catholics priest have molested mainly boys. Even worse they allow gay catholic priest to continue. They will even defend the priest that molested the kids. Didn't Jesus walk on water? wouldn't be that considered witch craft? Didn't he heal people just by saying so? I have seen christians being healed on tv, heck they might be a witch according to their own standards. I used to be christian but eventually I figured out the bible didn't make any sense at all. It was one big joke. The bible is translated from hebrew text. Translated inaccurately and lies added on to benefit themselves and to make more money with donations. Isn't this against god? Look at Jim Baker? Catholics don't have any room to judge, their better look at their own first. Wiccans have higher moral standards than most catholics. I have seen many catholics drink til they get stupid, fight among themselves, mistreat people, and more. They think doing bad things and then confession will allow them to go to heaven.

funny how catholics doesn't like pagans either but celebrate Christmas. Christmas was started by the pegans, to make matters even worse jesus wasn't born in dec. people believed he was born in april.

In buddhism they say when a person thinks he's bad, that means you're bad. Otherwise why would you be here on earth to suffer why aren't you in heaven? If you really good person you be in heaven not here.
Wiccans believes in natural healings, being a good person that values virtue how can that be considered a bad person?

Anyways your family shouldn't control your life, your family is not you. For the people said you're not a good christian if you go out with wiccans, well according to the bible you're not a good christian because you can't forgive and the bible also states to judge others as thy judge himself. The bible does state to worship him only but he didn't say your partner or who you date has to worship him.
 Medina49

Joined: 12/17/2007
Msg: 352
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 4:55:23 AM

I guess i shouldn't date catholics since many catholics priest have molested mainly boys


dude, I'm totally against dating catholic priests.
 angelah1975

Joined: 10/12/2006
Msg: 353
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 7:09:07 AM

But is she wiccan or wicca?


Huh? You can't BE Wicca. It is a noun.

Wicca is a religion. Followers of this religion are called Wiccans.

Much like Catholicism is a religion and Catholics are followers of it.
 angelah1975

Joined: 10/12/2006
Msg: 354
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 7:14:01 AM

Just a question--why were the guys allowed to go free? Last I heard, there are sorcerers, evil magic men, warlocks, etc.


Witches can be male or female. True followers of the Craft don't call themselves warlocks just because they are male. In fact, followers of Wicca consider the term warlock to mean "oath-breaker".

I think you may be watching too many Harry Potter movies!
 ahistorychic

Joined: 1/23/2008
Msg: 355
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 7:51:32 AM
All I can say is WOW!

I grew up Catholic and had major issues with it. I researched many different religions and found Wicca to be more closely in sinc with what I believe in. The most common code of conduct among Wiccans is the Rede:

Bide the Wiccan law ye must, in perfect love and perfect trust;
Eight words the Wiccan Rede fulfill;
'An ye harm none, do as ye will';
Lest in self-defense it be, ever mind the rule of three;
Follow this with mind and heart;
And merry ye meet and merry ye part.

Basically, the Reed commits us to have personal responsibility. We must love unconditionally because we are all brothers and sisters, connected to each other and every living thing. Life is a balance between light and dark. Nature is both beautifully creative and frighteningly distructive.

If your family has a problem with that, well, then I don't know what to tell you other than What Would Jesus Do?
 Jacobus101

Joined: 12/30/2007
Msg: 356
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/27/2008 2:16:42 PM
TheSOurce:

That statement of yours was about as ignorant and judgmental of Catholicism as any post against Wicca or paganism:


I guess i shouldn't date catholics since many catholics priest have molested mainly boys.


The rate of child molestation by Catholic priests is actually lower than those committed by ministers of other denominations and religions. According to the Chicago Sun-Times, the New York Times, and the Detroit News, 260 reports of abuse yearly in Protestant churches. In the Protestant churches collectively, there are 260 accusations of sex abuse by clergymen against minors, whereas in the Catholic Church, there are 228. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/06/16/us/16protestant.html?_r=1&oref=slogin


However, the media prefers to report cases of Catholic priests because lawsuits against them generate much more money. Lawyers sue an entire diocese (often 100 to 300 parish churches collectively), rather than an individual church. It also reflects a bias against Catholicism that has been latent in American culture ever since our foundings under our Puritan ancestors. See the book "The New Anti-Catholicism: The Last Acceptable Prejudice" by Philip Jenkins. http://www.amazon.com/New-Anti-Catholicism-Last-Acceptable-Prejudice/dp/0195176049/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1201469258&sr=8-1


Did you know that public school teachers commit child sex abuse at a rate literally 100 times higher than clergy of any religion? By your logic, we should never date teachers or kids who attended public school.


Even worse they allow gay catholic priest to continue.


A lot of people would argue that the homosexuality factor doesn't make a difference. I'm undecided. However, the Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, was under fire by the media in 2005 for issuing a document that renewed the ban on actively homosexual men from joining the priesthood. Of course, actively sexual men of any kind should not be priests, but since you mentioned a false statement, here's what the document says in contradiction to you: "If a candidate practises homosexuality, or presents deep-seated homosexual tendencies, his spiritual director as well as his confessor have the duty to dissuade him in conscience from proceeding towards ordination."


They will even defend the priest that molested the kids.


Who are "they"? Maybe a few erroneous bishops have defended their criminal priests, but my archbishop has not, nor have those bishops which teach and defend the orthodox Catholic faith.


Didn't Jesus walk on water? wouldn't be that considered witch craft?


Yes to the first, no to the second. Terms like witchcraft and divination refer to attempts to harness supernatural power from someone or something other than God.


I have seen christians being healed on tv, heck they might be a witch according to their own standards.


And many Catholic saints throughout history have been able to heal, raise the dead, fly or levitate in the air, bilocate (appear in two places at once), read minds during confession, multiply food, or live off of absolutely nothing but Holy Communion without eating anything else.

But since all of these miracles and powers come from God or one of His agents, they are not considered witchcraft or divination.


I used to be christian but eventually I figured out the bible didn't make any sense at all. It was one big joke.


I used to be an atheist and thought that about the Bible as well. Later I realized that it makes a lot of sense. That's irrelevant, though. It is, however, certainly not a joke. It's a pretty serious text. I don't believe in the words of the Muslim Qu'ran, but at least I know it's not a joke. It's dead serious stuff.

BTW, if your entire knowledge of Christianity was based on just the Bible, I think that's a problem. Traditional Christianity involves much more than just a book, you know.


The bible is translated from hebrew text. Translated inaccurately and lies added on to benefit themselves and to make more money with donations.


Part of the Bible is translated from Hebrew, and part from Greek and Aramaic.

You don't seem to be familiar with Biblical scholarship. There are many translations of the Bible on the market, and we can cross-reference them with the oldest Biblical texts we have, such as Codex Vaticanus, Codex Sinaiticus, and the Dead Sea Scrolls. It's easy to find Bibles that provide every possible translation for every single Hebrew, Greek, or Aramaaic word in the entire text. There are books called concordances that help with this.

But again, Christianity, and especially Catholic Christianity, is about so much more than just a book.


Isn't this against god? Look at Jim Baker? Catholics don't have any room to judge, their better look at their own first.


Jim Bakker isn't a Catholic, he's a Protestant minister. I don't know a lot about him.

The Catholic Church has a roster of many of her own who have lived Christ-like lifestyles. To name a few off the top of my head.....

St. Nicholas of Myra, the wealthy shipowner who gave all his wealth to become a bishop (now known as Santa Claus in the U.S.);
St. Francis of Assisi, the man who almost single-handed reformed the medieval Church with his example of holy poverty and founded the Franciscan Order;
St. Anthony of Padua, who continued St. Francis' work;
St. Dominic de Guzman, founder of the Order of Preachers aka the Dominicans;
St. Teresa of Avila, Spanish mystic and reformer of the Carmelite Order;
St. Thomas Becket, archbishop of Canterbury who was murdered at his altar for standing against King Henry II of England;
St. Thomas More, Lord Chancellor of England and renowned scholar who gave up his life for refusing to submit to King Henry VIII's annulment and break from the Church;
St. John Fisher, bishop of Rochester who also stood like John the Baptist against Henry VIII and died for it;
St. Edmund Campion, priest who was drawn and quartered for ministering to Catholics in Elizabethan England;
St. Margaret Clitherow, a woman crushed by stones for using her a house as a safehouse for Elizabethan-era priests;
St. Elizabeth Ann Seton, established homes for orphaned girls around New York;
St. Therese de Lisieux, spiritual mystic and teacher of the "Little Way";
St. Edith Stein, a Hebrew Catholic nun killed at Auschwitz;
St. Maximilian Kolbe, a Polish priest also killed at Auschwitz by offering his life in exchange for a prisoner's who was sentenced to die;
St. Padre Pio, the Italian priest who lived with stigmata;
and famously in recent times, Mother Teresa of Calcutta.



Wiccans have higher moral standards than most catholics. I have seen many catholics drink til they get stupid, fight among themselves, mistreat people, and more. They think doing bad things and then confession will allow them to go to heaven.


Most Wiccans at the present time have, as I understand it, converted to Wicca. They are naturally more devout in Wiccan teachings because they chose to be in that religion.

Next time, try comparing Wiccans with people who have converted to Catholicism.


I have seen many catholics drink til they get stupid, fight among themselves, mistreat people, and more. They think doing bad things and then confession will allow them to go to heaven.


Another bad stereotype which misrepresents what Catholicism is really about.


funny how catholics doesn't like pagans either but celebrate Christmas. Christmas was started by the pegans, to make matters even worse jesus wasn't born in dec. people believed he was born in april.


1.) the word "Christmas" is a contraction of "Christ's Mass". I doubt a pagan would have thought of making up that word.

2.) There is good reason to believe Christ was born on or around December 25. I already ststaed my argument for it earlier in the thread. I said:


Actually, the only time shepherds spend the night with their sheep is when the sheep are giving birth. The ewes are attracted to the rams in July, after the longest day of the year. The gestation period is about 5 months, so the sheep give birth in mid-December. Thus, the shepherds having been out at the time of Christ's birth is a positive indicator of Christ's birth being in December. Furthermore, it is only fitting that the "lamb of God" is born at the time when all other lambs are born, especially in 1st-century Hebrew culture, which was born out of shepherds.

There are two other reasons why Christmas is dated December 25, although to understand, one must have a full grasp of the entire Christian calendar, not just the days that people like to go to church. The specific date of 25 was chosen because of the belief that a prophet is martyred on the day he was conceived in the world. March 25 is the date of the feast of the Annunciation; that is, the day the angel Gabriel announced to the Blessed Virgin Mary that she would conceive a Savior in her womb. This date was chosen because on the Friday of the Passover in 33 AD, the day Christ died, it was on March 25. Nine months later is December 25, the feast of the Nativity (Christmas).

Another indicator of Christ's birth on December 25 is the date of the feast day of St. John the Baptist, on June 25, after the summer solstice. We know when John the Baptist was born through Scripture because his father, Zecaharias, was a Temple priest who lived according to a strict ritual calendar. See Luke 1:23-24. He went home to his wife "as soon as the days of his ministration were accomplished". We know when this is because the Temple priests offered perpetual sacrifice according to their shifts. Zecharias' shift was "the course of Abia" (Luke 1:5), which ends in October. Thus, Zecharias went home to his wife in mid-October and John was conceived at some time between October 15 and the end of the month. This means he would have been born in mid-to-late June.

Not surprisingly, the feast day of John the Baptist is on June 25. And, we know from Scripture that Jesus was born six months after John: December 25. The significance of each being close to the summer or winter solstice derives from what John said about Christ: "He must incease, and I must decrease". After John's day, the days decrease in length. After Christ's, the days lengthen.
 xarock

Joined: 10/18/2007
Msg: 357
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/30/2008 1:38:05 PM
a religon is just a belif and no one should have a problem with any one elses belifes
 Frostiness01

Joined: 8/15/2007
Msg: 358
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/30/2008 3:28:33 PM
Speaking as a pagan myself I feel confident to tell you that your beloved will not want to hide in her broom closet. Don't tell an untruth to your family. Way not cool. If they can't accept her for who and what she is then that is THEIR problem, not hers or even yours.

Honesty really is the best policy. You can't chance the way people feel. If you like her then give her enough respect to be honest about her.

Blessed be and all that good stuff.
 wassupwassabi

Joined: 10/5/2007
Msg: 359
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/30/2008 4:47:36 PM

Didn't Jesus walk on water? wouldn't be that considered witch craft? Didn't he heal people just by saying so? I have seen christians being healed on tv, heck they might be a witch according to their own standards.


Well, one theme about the supernatural in the Bible is that the devil likes to mimic whatever God is doing. From a Christian perspective, witchcraft would be a cheap copy of God's true miracles, used for evil purposes.
 bucsgirl

Joined: 5/13/2006
Msg: 360
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/30/2008 5:27:23 PM
I have read with interest and followed this thread.

The word religion...kinda like politics...either it makes someone passive or it raises the hair on the back of your neck.

I do belong to an "organized religion" church. I am a member....my faith is personal. Maybe I'm one of the few members of my church that don't accept all the church doctrine as my own personal belief and faith.

There is no "organized religion" or set of beliefs that totally fits what individuals really believe or ascribe to. We join...and go and share in that with other members, IMO because there's more that we share than what we don't. Otherwise we'd all be our own "religion" belief system.

I speak from personal experience to say this, there have been times (more than one...haha) when I had struggles, conflicts with the "set mentality" of being a member. I resolved that myself, didn't think it was up to the organized religion or church to do so. Just my thoughts and experiences from my own life, I will say that sometimes when a member is going through this, the leaders are the most dumbfounded and ill equipped to help or guide someone...a "member" how to cope.

I'm not mad, disappointed or ashamed of any of it. I have talked to some of the supposed leaders at times and gone away feeling more confused and frustrated.

I do know what I believe and I DO believe that there is a soul born and living forever in every person. I do fall back on the supposed premise that I thought was what religion and faith had to offer. Peace of mind..peace within yourself and relating to all the other humans you deal with, have relationships with and encounter.

Peace, acceptance...love, acceptance. That's my "religion" if you will, that's what I always fall back on go to and it's always worked.

If I can say or so something for someone that gives them an inward peace...WOW I'm so happy. What my religious or faith thing is...if I'm asked...and only if I'm asked...I'll say what I believe and share how it's helped me. If it has, I've also shared with other people their conflicts within the faith.

I can only share my experiences and my own personal road to inner peace and contentment. And I'm happy to...and more often than not...it's not about religion or faith...more often than not..it's about people and relationships.

If someone has another path, goes to a different church or holds fast to another faith. It's never been a problem yet in relating to them on a personal level. And forging, strong, lifetime relationships.

It hasn't been a barrier for me personally. For some others it is and a dealbreaker. I understand honestly I do and wish them no ill will or have any bad feelings.

Who wouldn't want inner peace. Many turn to a proscribed religion to find that. Nothing wrong at all. The thing that churches and doctrines and leaders IMO don't know how to guide, advise is how to make it your own. Personal...I know this myself, as a member of a church and a strict..ehh organized religion.

I agree, abide with and support and believe in more than I don't. And I've met and talked to many people and yes I ask...and haven't found one who fully, totally subscribes to everything. I don't have a conflict with that, I don't think they should. It's how important in the big picture the commonalites and the difference are. IMO!

My "religion" being christian means christ like. And I won't quote the scripture...but it's a core belief that I can espouse, embrace and be happy with. Accepting and loving...tolerance..I think it's great.

Not tolerate like putting up with but wow...a new person, maybe just chatting in line...we bump up against come across all sorts of people. And I love that I have the choice, I can choose to see them as someone like me, a human, who's wanting acceptance and understanding. I relate, I like that too! So if I can give that out, just as a fellow human being to another one, if they accept that. Great! If not, I understand, too.

And it is something I've noticed when you meet someone or share a ride on the elevator...or chit/chat in a line at a store. There is that...that yearning that need....and religion not only hasn't answered or addressed basic human needs, when someone plops out a religion...I'm this or that. It doesn't draw them closer..it tends to repel.

That's what I find the saddest about it all, and the hardest to deal with. I have my own faith, my beliefs and as a member I have chosen to have a label.

For those that get to know me...it's not a hinderance. But I do undertstand labels...and it's heartbreaking that it keeps people apart. From what they seek and want and should. Caring relationships...my label doesn't "match" yours. I have no problem with that...I know those who embrace their labels so much..well I don't know.

Because I haven't and it is a label, I'm just thankful it's not prevented me from having terrific relationships and loving so many people that love me and we don't have to be branded with the same label. I like the label of "canned peas"...i'd prefer frozen...but ehhh..
 dani143831

Joined: 6/12/2006
Msg: 361
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/30/2008 6:22:02 PM
haha i had to stop and think about this for a min ! love the analogy :D
 Jacobus101

Joined: 12/30/2007
Msg: 362
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 1/31/2008 8:35:45 AM
I just thought I'd drop in once again and say that, in the time between my last post here and now, I've started dating a Wiccan myself. Her parents are both Wiccan and she was raised in a Wiccan community. It'll be interesting to see what the reverse situation of the OP's is whenever I get around to meeting the parents! Thankfully, she herself seems to be pretty accepting of my religion and has expressed interest in attending the Latin Mass.
 tkdblake93

Joined: 10/18/2006
Msg: 363
view profile
History
Catholicism vs Wiccan
Posted: 6/17/2008 8:24:31 PM
Someone mentioned Christmas (December 25) being opposite St. John's Day (June 25). When the Church came up with those dates, the Western world was on the Julian calendar and later when we switched to the Gregorian calendar, we skipped about 3 days. Therefore, when we were on the Julian calendar, December 25 was the day on which the winter solstice was observed; June 25 was when the summer solstice was observed. In Rome, particularly, Saturnalia was observed on December 25. It makes sense when Kronos/Saturn was considered the father of time and the winter solstice marks the time when the day is at its shortest. I think the birthday of the Persian god Mithras was also observed on December 25.

At any rate, anybody today following a religion based on ancient pre-Christian European religious beliefs have Christian monks and Muslim scholars to thank for keeping the knowledge and heritage of ancient Europe intact for future generations.
Page 17 of 15 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15
 
Show ALL Forums  > Relationships  > Catholicism vs Wiccan