online dating service

Free Dating Site    

REGISTER | MAIL/PROFILE | HELP | NOW ONLINE | SEARCH | RATING | FORUMS | SUCCESS STORIES
Plentyoffish dating forums are a place to meet singles and get dating advice or share dating experiences etc. Hopefully you will all have fun meeting singles and try out this online dating thing... Remember that we are the largest 100% free online dating service, so you will never have to pay a dime to meet your soulmate.
     
Show ALL Forums  > Relationships  > Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?      Mod Threads Home login  
Page 9 of 10 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
 Author Thread: Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
 eatablekisses

Joined: 8/18/2007
Msg: 201
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 7:27:03 AM
well you are so not into curvacious woman i was a size 12 when i married and i was 4mths pregnant and yes the pounds came on but he still loved me any way well three more babies later i was big but he loved me for who i was my heart and the loving and warm person i am it doesnt matter about size she is still the same woman you married so you dont like being warm in winter and beleive me the curveir woman are the better lovers they make so why should it matter if she gained weight its her love for you that counts so why worry turn the tables what if it was you that got fat and she doing and saying what you are you would feel so bad that she stopped loving you so think about feelings first
 Scubacody

Joined: 12/27/2007
Msg: 202
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 7:31:44 AM
Having a girlfriend who becomes overweight most certainly would influence any relationship I am in. I mean I try to keep in shape for myself it is something like taking pride in yourself and your appearence. I would probably try to get her to workout with me or something subtle and if that didn't work I would have to really think hard about where the relationship was going.
 ExplosiveSheep

Joined: 9/22/2007
Msg: 203
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 7:43:07 AM
I ain't worried about baby weight, if I was thinking girl could keep a lithe body while being pregnant i'd be foolin myself a bit much there.

I'm just sayin, if a woman said "We've been together for a while and I've noticed you've started to put on a lot of weight and not only am I worried about you but I'm not finding you as attractive as I did." I'm young, if she ain't finding me attractive that means no sex, no sex!? No thanks, time for the elliptical and a diet haha. I dunno, call me crazy but I wouldn't be that offended if it wasn't part of the original package she was taking.
 jf468

Joined: 12/4/2007
Msg: 204
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 7:48:11 AM
Msg 202: I don't think having kids is an excuse for becoming obese. Yes some women might gain some weight because having kids, but not a large amount of weight. I know plenty of women who didn't gain a lot of weight after having kids. Like another poster mentioned earlier, when a person gains or loses weight ( because of reasons that they control ), they aren't always the same person. Physical appearance is a part of who a person is just like personality and other things. A lot of people feel different about themselves when they gain or lose weight. BTW curvy and BBW are 2 different things.
 rachelmybell

Joined: 7/6/2007
Msg: 205
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 7:48:29 AM

Anyone who says, "I don't want a fat partner because of health issues" is a liar. As other posters have stated, it's because of appearances, not health. Maybe if you're 0ver 65 and looking for someone to spend your golden years with, I'd buy it, but if not, you're fooling exactly nobody.



How do you that they are lying? Appearances are a factor, but maybe a family member, a friend, or a co-worker had health problems that were caused by being obese. It is the same thing as not dating a smoker because of potential health problems caused by smoking.


I've never seen a foxy asthmatic hurt for a date. But don'tcha know, people who have asthma statistically live shorter lives. Also, someone beautiful may have poor genes or diseases that run in their families, such as breast cancer. I don't see an attractive woman sitting across from a guy telling her, "It's just not going to work out. I mean, your grandmother had breast cancer, and so did your mother and sister. I CAN'T DATE YOU FOR HEALTH REASONS."


I have many good qualities. I'm a member of MENSA and recently had some creative writing published. I work at a major metropolitan newspaper as a WRITER (in New York, of all places) and am the youngest person at the company, and just got my first promotion after being there for five months. I volunteer at a homeless shelter, wrote a 400 page dissertation in college, graduated from said college with honors, and am politically active.

But when I was fat, none of that mattered. FAT negated ALL OF THE ABOVE, and nobody cared who I was or what I was, because in the public eye, all I could ever hope to be was FAT.

Now, all of a sudden, the phone rings off the hook? Aren't I the same person? Didn't I have feelings, merit, and worth before I lost weight?




Physical appearance is a part of how you are. If I met a nice woman that I wasn't attracted to. Then I might be friends with her, but not date her. Also many people who lost weight often feel better about themselves. Therefore many people aren't the same person after the weight loss.


The examples I listed had nothing to do with my weight. Some people are the same after weight loss, and some aren't. Now that I'm thinner, I AM different. I'm pickier and enjoy turning down vapid men that wouldn't give me the time of day last year. Maybe that makes me meaner.


I have a younger sister who is obese and has an eating disorder. The girl is afraid to leave the house because of the nasty people outside who stare at her and make comments. When she comes home from college, she lets me know it was a good day by saying, "Nobody made any remarks to me today." How very sad.




Some people can be rude to fat people, but this is a two way street. Some fat people can be jealous, angry, and bitter. They put down thin women by calling them "Barbie dolls", bony, self-centered, high maintenance etc.


My heart bleeds. How horrible it must be for people to yell "Barbie" at you when you walk down the street, as opposed to being afraid to leave the house because last time you did, a car filled with teenage boys pulled up next to you, threw trash at you and heavily implied, "You make me want to hurl, you disgusting pig." I don't know any skinny people afraid to leave the house because they can't eat at a restaurant or walk to the store without people staring and making remarks at them.


Anyways, all of this is simply to try and explain to those who don't get it, that weight gain is rarely a simple issue of being lazy or overeating. The issues involved are complex and many.




Most people can lose weight with a good diet and proper exercise. I think some people make excuses for their weight.


I wonder why you did not quote my earlier statement about scoliosis and asthma here? Yes, I am making excuses. My spine is crooked and I deal with chronic pain. That's no excuse for not getting up at the crack of dawn to bust my butt at the gym so that guys I wouldn't date if you paid me would consider me "acceptable".

It breaks my heart to see so many overweight women who I CAN TELL are delightful, wonderful, intelligent, and kind people be overlooked and ignored by people who don't bother to look past the outside. I have fallen in love with people who weren't the most attractive people in the world, but I looked past that and ultimately found them beautiful. Quality people do the same.
 Srohack

Joined: 1/6/2008
Msg: 206
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 7:49:51 AM
I'm going to take a gamble and NOT be politically correct here: YES IT DOES INFLUENCE RELATIONSHIPS. Im sure many people wont fess up to it, but there's alot of people who do feel this way. I mean there's things like getting into an accident and just natural aging which are not under your control. But that and letting yourself go are two completely different things.

Scenario : Your husband had a marvelous body when you guys got married. 10 years down the road he's a got a kegger and his face looks like a blowfish. By now you're most likely pushing him to start exercising. What goes through your mind? *Of course* you want him to start exercising again for a variety of reasons: Because it's healthy, 2: because you want him to look better. You still love the person, but that's not even the issue here. It influences you because your SEXUAL attraction (A very valid form of attraction, no matter what people say) starts to wane. I think that's perfectly acceptable as long as you aren't being hypocritical and maybe you guys can even exercise together! This can apply to a woman as well, of course!
 northeast25

Joined: 12/4/2007
Msg: 207
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 8:06:32 AM

I've never seen a foxy asthmatic hurt for a date. But don'tcha know, people who have asthma statistically live shorter lives. Also, someone beautiful may have poor genes or diseases that run in their families, such as breast cancer. I don't see an attractive woman sitting across from a guy telling her, "It's just not going to work out. I mean, your grandmother had breast cancer, and so did your mother and sister. I CAN'T DATE YOU FOR HEALTH REASONS."


If an attractive woman was a smoker, used drugs etc, then a lot of men wouldn't date her. Sometimes it is health issue. BTW just because someone in your family has a certain disease, it doesn't always mean that you are a higher risk for getting that disease. Not all diseases are caused by genetics.



My heart bleeds. How horrible it must be for people to yell "Barbie" at you when you walk down the street, as opposed to being afraid to leave the house because last time you did, a car filled with teenage boys pulled up next to you, threw trash at you and heavily implied, "You make me want to hurl, you disgusting pig." I don't know any skinny people afraid to leave the house because they can't eat at a restaurant or walk to the store without people staring and making remarks at them.


My point is that rude comments are wrong and can hurt regardless of who the victim is. Calling thin women barbie dolls, self centered, high maintenance b-tches among other things, is just as bad as calling fat women pigs. I know some thin women are on the receiving end of rude comments by fat women on a regular basis.



I wonder why you did not quote my earlier statement about scoliosis and asthma here? Yes, I am making excuses. My spine is crooked and I deal with chronic pain. That's no excuse for not getting up at the crack of dawn to bust my butt at the gym so that guys I wouldn't date if you paid me would consider me "acceptable".


I said some ( NOT ALL ) fat women make excuses. That was a general comment in response to something that I had quoted from another poster. Not you.



It breaks my heart to see so many overweight women who I CAN TELL are delightful, wonderful, intelligent, and kind people be overlooked and ignored by people who don't bother to look past the outside. I have fallen in love with people who weren't the most attractive people in the world, but I looked past that and ultimately found them beautiful. Quality people do the same.


I have dated people that weren't that attractive because of their personality, but there is a limit to that. I'm not going to date someone who I think is completely gross. Many other people feel the same way.
 liontotema

Joined: 7/18/2007
Msg: 208
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 10:42:13 AM
Regarding the original post, I have never heard of anyone putting on a HUGE amount of weight IMMEDIATELY after the wedding, it sounds rather like an extreme and quite improbable case to me....
 rachelmybell

Joined: 7/6/2007
Msg: 209
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 1:44:33 PM

I have dated people that weren't that attractive because of their personality, but there is a limit to that. I'm not going to date someone who I think is completely gross. Many other people feel the same way.


I feel the same way. I would rather be single than date someone with a "gross" heart and a "gross" mind.
 bostonsportsgal789

Joined: 12/4/2007
Msg: 210
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 2:01:10 PM
I feel the same way. I would rather be single than date someone with a "gross" heart and a "gross" mind.


A person does not necessary have a gross heart and mind because he/she wouldn't date someone that he/she thinks is physically ugly. That's pretty normal. Some men have rejected me because I'm thin and they are physically attracted to larger women. I don't complain about it. For many people there needs to be at least some physical attraction in a relationship. ( That doesn't mean that a person must have super model looks ) I tried dating a man that I was thought was very unattractive because he had a great personality. It simply didn't work out. I simply could NOT be romantic with a man who I think is ugly.
 dancestildawn

Joined: 6/24/2005
Msg: 211
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 2:21:10 PM
Well I have a problem, I have several friends that at over weight to extremely over weight and they will remain my friends. Physical attraction however is not there, sorry but I can't make myself to attracted to them. My ex put weight on after our child was born and I never stopped loving her because of that, it was the controlling factor that ended it. So I know if I love someone and they put on weight I won't stop loving them. There would be a point where I would put my foot down and demand yes demand she loss weight. When you love someone you have to be concerned about their health. That is what love is and some times tough love is needed to save a relationship just like other problems that need to be resolved in order for the relationship to survive.
 ksbbw972

Joined: 10/31/2007
Msg: 212
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 2:23:15 PM
"Let's face it people - LOOKS DO MATTER - and those who deny this fact are often overweight themselves, or are very "undesirable" looking"

prettyface2: you broke out two items here - overweight and undesirable looking. So my statement stands. You said "LOOKS DO MATTER" It is reasonable based on your two statements here to extrapolate that you insist on physical beauty in your partner, and you certainly didn't indicate or specify in those statements that your issue was only fat people.

Your comment about "Ms. Piggy" (well, most of your post actually) was disrespectful. Being thin does not equate to moral superiority, no matter that you practice what you preach!
 rachelmybell

Joined: 7/6/2007
Msg: 213
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 2:24:15 PM
It's not the not dating someone you're not attracted to spiel. It's the referring to other human beings as nasty names that I take issue with. Quality people don't negatively comment on other people's appearances, not to their faces and not behind their backs. There's not an issue with not being attracted to people. There is an issue with cruelty, a lack of compassion, and a lack of depth in assuming that it is easy for a person to lose weight if they really want to.

And with this particular issue of someone gaining weight after marriage, it's especially heinous. It's supposed to be "til death do us part", not "til your fat butt gets too big to tolerate." If something like weight could destroy a marriage, why bother ever getting married? Most people do gain weight as they age.

Fortunately, it is not hard to spot these types of people, and most know to avoid them. I once dated a guy who always described girls in terms of size (as in, "Nice girl, but big." and "Pretty girl. Really thin."). Another guy told me that if I stopped dieting, he'd never call me again. I think he was joking, but it told me volumes about his character, and I was the one who stopped calling him. The last straw was when I wanted a candy apple at the mall, and he dragged me away from the store, staring at me in unabridled horror and mewling, "What about your DIET?" I wanted to slap his face, but restrained myself. He was another one of those "nice" guys complaining about girls always using him for expensive meals and never calling him back. Perhaps they would have called him back if he didn't stare at her chicken parm dinner at the diner and loudly say, "Whoa, is THAT allowed on your diet?"

Or the obese 350 pound plus guy I dated in high school who told me I was too fat to show his friends, but just good enough to screw in private. Thanks.

Or the guy who met me in on a mall bench for a date and yelled across the mall when he saw me, "LOOKING GREAT, SWEETIE! YOU LOOK AT LEAST FIFTEEN POUNDS LIGHTER THAN TWO WEEKS AGO!"

Such gems.

Once being fat and now being more moderate in my weight (still could lose some, but my ribs show now, at least), I have gotten to see first-hand the way people treat you based on your weight, and it's intolerable and disgusting. People who have never struggled with a weight issue have no idea how hard the life of a fat person can be, and presuming to know, or judging the person for being overweight in the first place, is a terrible quality to have, let alone divorcing someone because of their weight.
 bostonsportsgal789

Joined: 12/4/2007
Msg: 214
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 2:33:45 PM
It's not the not dating someone you're not attracted to spiel. It's the referring to other human beings as nasty names that I take issue with. Quality people don't negatively comment on other people's appearances, not to their faces and not behind their backs. There's not an issue with not being attracted to people. There is an issue with cruelty, a lack of compassion, and a lack of depth in assuming that it is easy for a person to lose weight if they really want to.


If you made the above comment, then why would you make the following comment below.



It breaks my heart to see so many overweight women who I CAN TELL are delightful, wonderful, intelligent, and kind people be overlooked and ignored by people who don't bother to look past the outside. I have fallen in love with people who weren't the most attractive people in the world, but I looked past that and ultimately found them beautiful. Quality people do the same.


On the first comment, you stated that you have no problem with not dating someone that you aren't attracted to. Yet on the second comment, you are basically stating that people shouldn't reject a person based on weight. Many people aren't attracted to people who are extremely overweight. Just like some people aren't attracted to thin women like myself.



And with this particular issue of someone gaining weight after marriage, it's especially heinous. It's supposed to be "til death do us part", not "til your fat butt gets too big to tolerate." If something like weight could destroy a marriage, why bother ever getting married? Most people do gain weight as they age.


There is a huge difference between gaining some weight due to age and gaining a lot of weight due to not taking care of yourself.
 Ravenstar66

Joined: 8/27/2007
Msg: 215
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 2:44:00 PM
Yes

Everyone is going to put on a few pounds over the years... but I have to say that most people do not get married thinking the other is going to blow up like a Zeppelin.

I know, I know...it isn't PC to say these things... Oh well. If it's a bit of weight... I think they should suck it up.. but in the case of a great deal it has now become a health issue. It would be a long the same lines if someone started smoking after marriage or became an alcoholic (or any self-destructive habit)... it can be a serious health threat, and will definitely put a strain on a relationship. How it is handled I guess is up to the couple and each of their beliefs and standards in this area.. and whether they choose to handle it as a couple or not.

That's all I am saying about this issue.
 average_anomaly

Joined: 11/16/2007
Msg: 216
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/10/2008 4:28:27 PM
hummm,

Well - lots of people say that it doesn't matter but having had to deal with trying to keep the weight off my entire life I know that it does in reality. People like to think that they like you for you -but the truth is I know there are lots of men that look at my "pretty face" and pass when they see I am not thin. So maybe it shouldn't matter but it sure seems like it does.

As for the "for better or worse" question" I guess my values say that you stay in it as long as both partners are trying to keep it working. If the fat and depressed woman doesn't feel happy about life perhaps its time to address that issue. OH but if you think for ONE SECOND that problem is subject to women, YOU ARE WRONG! There are plenty of porky husbands walking around out there too!

peace
 Sheezadyme

Joined: 1/10/2006
Msg: 217
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/13/2008 7:02:55 PM
Being overweight influences my relationships definately, because I choose to be honest with myself and my dates I put that out there with no shame! For me it's not entirely about the way it looks phsically to be too fat , it's just that I have enough trouble trying to exercise enough willpower to keep my own luscious fanny in a size 10/12!

I have to surround myself with people who will encourage me, via example, to remain healthy. Diabetes, heart disease and all that jazz are rampant in the Black/Latino community and I know that all I need to do is indulge one too many times on a stack of cakes or cookies and I'd be the next statistic.

So if I met a man and he had a couple of extra pounds, I'd date him long enough to check out his lifestyle and if I found that he made (for the most part) healthy lifestyle choices we can keep it movin'!
 fairlady57

Joined: 12/17/2007
Msg: 218
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 1:13:08 PM
People change, move on!! I believe the answer is a personal perference for either slim or overweight, man or woman, hair or bald, nice smile or rotten teeth, clean fingernails, blonde, red head, or burnette, tall or short, black or white, country or rock-n-roll,............there are some many influences that can get into the way of any relationship. I personally know some pretty homely people who are beautiful because of their personalities. I myself would be very uncomfortable around the perfect person!

And why does this thread seem to be directed to women? And lets be real and honest with ourselves and others and move on. For most of us on this thread are probably 50 or over. Let's be happy and promote world peace, not a judging, stero-type, ridicule,
sarcastic, and faultfinding world. Let's beam with positivity and maybe the negative will go away.
 outofthedesert

Joined: 12/9/2007
Msg: 219
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 2:41:16 PM
I think if the person was heavy at the onset of the relationship, it should not be an issue. I can understand how it becomes an issue when it gets out of hand. By this I mean, few of us weigh what we weighed in High School. I weigh 20 pounds more and can not get it off. My measurements are proportinate. If I were to gain lots of weight, I can understand how it might affect my s/o--if I had one. Not everyone is attracted to the same thing. The other issue would be--was the weight gain medical or because I ate too much and exercised too little? I would hope he would be understanding if it was truly something I could not help.
 MJ_Reaper

Joined: 11/26/2007
Msg: 220
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 2:51:23 PM
I don't see why weight should matter in a relationship because bodies change all the time whether we like it or not, especially as we get older.

So to say to men "Would u still be with a woman if she let herself go?" you'd also have to say to women "Would you love your man any less if he became short, fat, and bald?"
It's gotta be equal or the equation doesn't add up, or be fair, and in relationships equality is VERY important to be successful, or so I see it.

It's a trend for men to let themselves go once they have that wedding band on their finger or once they're comfortable in a relationship while they expect their partner to love them as much as always, so I think it's only fair if the shoe was on the other foot and it was the woman who let herself go.
 outofthedesert

Joined: 12/9/2007
Msg: 221
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 2:58:14 PM
I don't disagree about the boths sides, but a man can't help if he balds but he can watch his weight.

My dad is 76, 6-2, 175 and has always watched his weight. My mom died last year at 75 and before she became ill, she was 5'6 and weighed 125. Her mother weighed 200 at death.

I know how my body reacts to which foods. I love sweets but they are not what my body needs. I am talking about myself and no one else.
 quietcowboy

Joined: 12/25/2007
Msg: 222
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 3:23:36 PM
In the beginning of a relationship seeing someone being over weight does effect me negatively. If weight gain from that point on happens gradually it doesn't so much.
 jayeedublef

Joined: 5/30/2007
Msg: 223
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 3:36:25 PM
Wow, you think this person is "ugly" on the inside because he or she states an obvious fact? Believe me Twinky....it IS a fact! Most, not all men, don't want to be with a fat girl & if this fact pisses you off then you don't know squat about men & what they want.
Calling sombody ugly on the inside because they bring this fact to your attention is just stupid. This person wasn't saying they hated fat girls now were they? You are offended by the statment for some reason, hmm...what could that be? Some guys like fat girls but most don't & thats a fact!
 MOAB4U

Joined: 6/21/2007
Msg: 224
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 4:12:08 PM
True love is blind but fat can still be felt.. eeeeeeeewwwwwwwwww gross.

If I was in a committed relationship and my significant other started putting on the poundage I would say something. Eat healthy and get active. Guts hanging over a belly, jiggly butts and flab please stay dressed and covered as I find it unattractive and a turn off. THere is no excuse except medical. Eating from a trough rather then a plate is just gluttony. And gluttony is a sin.
 flawedbutfun

Joined: 6/19/2007
Msg: 225
view profile
History
Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?
Posted: 1/14/2008 4:27:18 PM
Keeping with fishing.....

it sounds like a bait and switch....that is just sooooooo wrong
Page 9 of 10 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
 
Show ALL Forums  > Relationships  > Does being/becoming overweight influence relationships?