|
|
|
|
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 7:21:12 AM |
Not really. If you research it, you'll discover that doctors have openly said that B vitamins improve your mood, and that many vitamins and minerals improve your cognition. So I am actually in tune with what doctors state about the mind. Again:  As to my claim that vitamins and minerals increase cognition and clear thinking:
It is important to understand the effect of specific deficiencies on the brain and the mind, that can cause extreme sadness and helplessness in what is commonly termed depression. Mental health is frequently regarded as being connected with the condition of the mind as opposed to the brain as an organ. Naturally, any deficiency that interferes with the chemical processes necessary for the correct operation of the brain as a physical entity will interfere with human consciousness or psyche that is an abstract manifestation of the way the brain works.
Vitamins known and accepted as affecting mental processes include the B vitamins, of which even slight deficiencies can have an adverse effect on mental health. Significant deficiencies can be related to serious mental illnesses such as severe depression. Each one of the B vitamins is known to have a specific effect.
Thiamine (Vitamin B1) deficiency can lead to depression, anxiety, fearfulness and irritability. The B vitamins are used to create specific enzymes needed for some of the functions in the brain, and it is a lack of these enzymes that ultimately leads to psychiatric disorders. Studies have determined a thiamine deficiency in a large proportion of psychiatric patients. Alcoholics and patients suffering from malnutrition have also been found to suffer from psychiatric disorders, and both of these conditions can lead to a deficiency in thiamine.
Riboflavin, too, has been studied in relation to psychosis. A few studies have indicated a deficiency of riboflavin, vitamin B2, to be associated with increased levels of depression and hysteria. Riboflavin, like thiamine, is essential for the formation and proper use of brain enzymes. The other B vitamins are also known to be essential in the biochemistry of the brain, and depression is a common result of a vitamin B12 deficiency. Other symptoms include psychosis, memory defects and a slowing of the mental processes in general.
In all of these cases, a vitamin B complex supplement appears to have fairly rapid positive results, especially in the treatment of depression. Whether the more severe conditions are helped or not is uncertain since vitamin treatment has rarely been a significant part of the treatment of severe cases of psychosis. It is difficult to see how it could do harm, though while it makes sense for any deficiency to be treated with a corresponding supplement, the damage is generally caused by the presence, or lack of, a chemical farther down the biochemical pathway.
It is well known and accepted that depression is a symptom of insufficient vitamin C intake. Vitamin C is a powerful antioxidant, and is also needed for the production of serotonin. Produced by the pineal gland deep in the brain, serotonin is a neurotransmitter responsible for mood and depression, and sometimes called the 'molecule of happiness'. A lack of serotonin leads to depression.
It is not only vitamins that are essential for good mental health, however. Mineral deficiencies also feature in some mental problems, particularly magnesium and zinc. Take zinc first: this mineral is responsible for a large number of enzyme syntheses in the body, and influences nerve impulse transmissions and also the activity of the thyroid gland. A deficiency will give several symptoms including depression and bevioural problems.
Magnesium takes part in hundreds of biochemical reactions, and a deficiency can be caused by stress since stress increases the demand for magnesium. The deficiency then affects the ability of the heart to react to the stress, and it becomes a vicious circle. The magnesium deficiency manifests in the form of personality changes, depression, irritability and anxiety.
These are known effects and many studies have been carries out to confirm that knowledge. Many more vitamins and minerals, such as folic acid, manganese, iron and potassium, are known to be necessary components of the human biochemical pathways that lead ultimately to chemicals essential for the proper functioning of the brain as an organism, and deficiencies of which can affect the mind. Mild depressions have been significantly reduced by use of the appropriate supplements but should not be regarded as a cure.
Since these known deficiencies cause known psychiatric defects, particularly depression and anxiety, it is only sensible to assume that intelligent and appropriate supplementation should help to avoid them, if not cure them. Some deficiencies are due to alcoholism and malnutrition. In alcoholism, the B vitamins are rapidly depleted in the body by the alcohol, even though there is no deficiency in the diet. Malnutrition speaks for itself, and while supplements can have a dramatic effect in that case, alcoholics must be cured for the effects of vitamin supplements to take real effect.
Vitamin and mineral supplements can be used to avoid many of the mental problems that a deficiency can cause. Of these, the various members of the vitamin B complex is that which is indicated most, and also zinc and magnesium supplementation are amongst the essential minerals required.
The treatment of minor disorders with supplements has had a degree of success but it is doubtful if any significant advantages can be gained by using them for severe symptoms. The more traditional methods have been found to be more effective, though some herbal supplements such as St. John's Wort might have some beneficial effects. These remedies, however, cannot be regarded as cures for depression or any other psychiatric disorder. The connection between mental health and supplements can be used towards finding a cure for many mental conditions. http://www.disabled-world.com/artman/publish/article_1497.shtml
& lets not forget the side effect where your pee turns a VERY bright yellow, thought I'd digested an internal organ of some sort when I first noticed that...  Don't worry about that, it's a sign that you are getting enough B2, but it's not harmful. This is what the USA's Department of Energy has to say about it:
Something that can really change the color of urine is the vitamin B2 (riboflavin). If you swallow a vitamin B2 supplement, and the amount is more than your body needs, the vitamin is excreted in the urine. The urine will be a VERY bright yellow - almost fluorescent (except it probably will not glow in the dark!). But there is nothing wrong with you when this happens - it is just your body getting rid of extra vitamin B2. Some health authorities use this as an example that taking large doses of vitamins only makes expensive urine. However, nutritionists who advocate large vitamin supplementation counter by saying that it is only when the excess amounts of vitamins spill over into the urine that you know for sure that your body is getting the maximum amount of the vitamins. http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/newton/askasci/1993/biology/bio021.htm
FYI, it fluorescent property is used in industry to detect leaks:
Because riboflavin is fluorescent under UV light, dilute solutions (0.015-0.025% w/w) are often used to detect leaks or to demonstrate cleanability in an industrial system such a chemical blend tank or bioreactor. (See the ASME BPE section on Testing and Inspection for additional details.) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riboflavin#Industrial_Uses
Vitamin supplements may account for the bright yellow colour:
To avoid deficiency, adults should consume about 1.2-1.5 mg of vitamin B2 each day. This can come through dietary intake, or vitamin supplements. When taking vitamin B2 supplements, the dosage is usually about 50 mg, with the excess accounting for some of the body’s non-absorption of the riboflavin. http://www.wcyh.org.uk/medical-science/vitamins/vitamin-b2/
So a typical vitamin supplement contains 3,333%-4,166% of the Recommended Daily Allowance of vitamin B2, which means that 1 pill contains the RDA for over a month. The highest dose is in the average portion of broccoli or mushrooms, which each contain 0.3 mg of vitamin B2, 20-25% of the RDA, and 0.6% of the average B2 supplement. Source:http://www.lenntech.com/fruit-vegetable-vitamin-content.htm
Were you taking vitamin supplements at the time? If so, this is the most likely cause. But it is not a big problem, as cases of fatal toxicity are rare.
However, I would advise you not to take more than the recommended dosage, as it is possible to cause damage if you absorb too much of any vitamin, as it may be too much for the body to be able to get rid of all the excess. My Human Biology teacher told us that one guy obsessively believed that he didn't have enough vitamin A. He took loads of vitamin pills, and ate loads of carrots, turned bright orange and subsequently died. However, given the much higher dosages in vitamin supplements, it is almost certain it was the vitamin supplements that killed him, especially as carrots contain much water, and that water could have been used to flush the excess vitamin A from his system, which cannot be said about vitamin supplements, which seem to contain no water at all. It does happen, but only with vitamin supplements. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 8:02:31 AM | As to my claim that vitamins and minerals increase cognition and clear thinking And a sure sign of clear thinking is being able to stay ON TOPIC!!!
Which is...
"Religion is the True EVIL in the world"
If by evil we mean the opposite of good then I'd say yes, most religions are evil in my opinion.
I can't think of one single good thing-- not one-- that couldn't have been achieved without religions -- but I can think of many evil or bad things that were done in it's name or because of it...again in my opinion.

JMHO
| |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 8:03:58 AM | 'Before you slam into me for not believing in God - ask yourself the question of why you don't believe in Thor, or Poseidon or Santa Claus (assuming that you don't) ...There is no rational reason to believe in belief... there are social and cultural reasons - but in the end they simply amount to brainwashing as a child. If you indoctrinate your children into any faith, you are in a sense brainwashing them to believe in your invisible god creature. please have a listen to Daniel Dennett - an awesome modern Philosopher'
I had to giggle at your above quote....brainwashing sounds accurate to me...anyone who puts their beliefs onto others is to an extent brain washing but only if you want to believe it....this is called FREEWILL... Personally, I take onboard a lot of different cultures, listen to different preachers but that is there opinion of religion...again personally I believe that man used religion as a type of law to organise society...look at Ireland for example the church is one of the most feared and controlling estabishments in its society...I dont disrespect any religion as for most people it gives them a sense of belonging and stability in their lives...if it makes you happy in your life then it should be noted as a good deed, a positive outcome. People are their own makers in life, however society, family and law in some countries do brainwash individuals to a certain extent....
 | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 8:19:26 AM | Thanks for getting it back on topic, oldsoul, Vitamins?? Too funny. 
Anyway, in the interest of clear thinking, how much research and study have you dome of "most religions"? How many did you study and conclude that they are "evil" as you define it (the opposite of good). And please, try to be current. "Are" is a present state. Although, I doubt that you can find a"most" that fully satisfy the condition "were evil". And, yes, I know you said "IMO", but it's a claim and it should be supported. I'm sure if I said, "in my opini0n paganism is evil" or "in my opinion atheists are immoral" you'd be all over it. Thank you. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 9:18:29 AM | I'm not about to get into an intellectual debate with anyone when I clearly stated in my previous post (and many others) why I believed most religions are evil. If you re-read my very short and very simple post, I already said the reasons why I feel the way I do.
I'm sure if I said, "in my opini0n paganism is evil" or "in my opinion atheists are immoral" you'd be all over it.
Aw but you see, I didn't say that christians or muslims or any particular person or a specific group of people were immoral or evil...I said that in my opinion, RELIGION was!!! Surely one doesn't need years of research or studies to see the difference?? One can respect a student and the value of education and the acquisition of knowledge without necessarily thinking that we have a great educational system...no?
And on a final note --I've never made it a secret on these boards that I have absolutely no formal education, but in case you missed it I'll say it again-- I'm just a high school drop out-- grade 10 to be exact-- so anyone is free to skip over my posts if they feel they are beneath their intellectual level. It's funny but I didn't read anywhere on the rules that one needed a high school diploma, let alone years of studies and research to post their own personal opinions on any given topic in these forums.
And, yes, I know you said "IMO", but it's a claim and it should be supported.
As far as having to support my claims --I claim NOTHING. Where in any of my posts did I ever claim anything but my own opinions? Am I not entitled to have my own opinions just like everyone else...WTH??
As far as the TOPIC of this thead, I still stand by my earlier post...if by evil we mean the opposite of good...then yes, I think that most religions are evil in MY opinion...that is the question that was asked in the opening post and I have the right to answer and state MY opinion in the affirmative or negative...and I have.

JMHO | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 9:36:53 AM | It goes right to the core of "wars and atrocities committed in the name of religion". They aren't committed in the name of religion. That is just what the winners of today's society wrote about these wars and atrocities. All historical evidence points to a religious motivated "war". Just because you say "the winners get to write the history" does not make it a non-religiously motivated war. I will provide the pertinnet data to support my assertion, as you have clearly NOT. The rest of your response to this is, once again, irrelevant.
The crusaders marched on Jerusalem to retain control of lands held by European allies, which included the Byzantine Empire. Please read post 231.
Do you mean the crusaders went to war against european allies, or that they went to war to regain captured land that was ONCE HELD by europeans? This still does not even state the MOTIVATION for them marching on jerusalem, as you have not even made clear.
You were claiming that torture and murder happened because of religion. I showed that this was NOT the main reason for torture and murder. NO, you merely ASSERTED it. Provide evidence from a credible source Again, you discount anything that contradicts your opinion. That is self-invalidation, a known property of the mind. So no evidence then? Why am I not suprised at this point.. BTW, you can psycoanalyse me when you recieve your degree in psychiatry.
On the contrary, I gave you a dose of your own medicine, and you didn't like it, because my application of your usage was far more appropriate than your attempt was. Try harder. Poor response for your lack of imagination.
Pertinent references to my assertion that the crusades were motivated for religious and religion based reasons to come. As it stands, scorpiomover has provided NADA. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 11:52:47 AM | To add my 2 pence/cents/euro etc:
Guns dont kill people - stupid people kill people.
Religion isnt evil, stupid people make it evil.
Guns is an example that can be replaced with knives or whatever. The point being - the tool is there for a purpose, and if people use it for anything other than its purpose then you they should be the ones accountable for their actions.
The bible, torah, Quran and other holy scriptures were revelations passed down to live a good and decent life. When people start wars in the name of religion, this wasn't gods intention and fault.
Hope that makes sense. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 12:20:30 PM | | I just look at the Irish - Catholic against Protestant - anybody really believe that is about religion - no - its a battle over land and power - the labels just identify the combatants - Really believe Sin Fein is a religiously motivated organization? | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 12:34:53 PM | These days everything you buy comes with a warning of some sort. The bible however, does not. If it did, this is what it would say:
Warning! This is a work of fiction. Do NOT take it literally. Content Advisory: Contains verses descriptive or advocating suicide, incest, beastiality, sadomasochism, sexual activity in a violent context, murder, morbid violence, use of drugs or alcohol, homosexuality, voyeurism, revenge, undermining of authority figures, lawlessness, human rights violations & atrocities.
Exposure Warning: Exposure to contents for extended periods of time or during formative years in children may cause delusions, hallucinations, decreased cognitive & objective reasoning abilities, and in extreme cases, pathological disorders, hatred, bigotry & violence including, but not limited to, murder, fanaticism & genocide.
As a source of moral guidance it would be the absolute worse book to consult, had some other person not written the koran & taken the #1 spot.... | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 12:37:56 PM |
I just look at the Irish - Catholic against Protestant - anybody really believe that is about religion - no - its a battle over land and power - the labels just identify the combatants - Really believe Sin Fein is a religiously motivated organization? The Irish catholic/protestant situation is an excellent example of religion motivating violence. I will also present reference to THAT as well... | |
|
| |
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 1:48:38 PM |
FORCE, unregulated or ill-regulated, is not only wasted in the void, like that of gunpowder burned in the open air, and steam unconfined by science; but, striking in the dark, and its blows meeting only the air, they recoil and bruise itself. It is destruction and ruin. It is the volcano, the earthquake, the cyclone;--not growth and progress. It is Polyphemus blinded, striking at random, and falling headlong among the sharp rocks by the impetus of his own blows.
The blind Force of the people is a Force that must be economized, and also managed, as the blind Force of steam, lifting the ponderous iron arms and turning the large wheels, is made to bore and rifle the cannon and to weave the most delicate lace. It must be regulated by Intellect. Intellect is to the people and the people's Force, what the slender needle of the compass is to the ship--its soul, always counselling the huge mass of wood and iron, and always pointing to the north. To attack the citadels built up on all sides against the human race by superstitions, despotisms, and prejudices, the Force must have a brain and a law. Then its deeds of daring produce permanent results, and there is real progress. Then there are sublime conquests. Thought is a force, and philosophy should be an energy, finding its aim and its effects in the amelioration of mankind. The two great motors are Truth and Love. When all these Forces are combined, and guided by the Intellect, and regulated by the RULE of Right, and Justice, and of combined and systematic movement and effort, the great revolution prepared for by the ages will begin to march. The POWER of the Deity Himself is in equilibrium with His WISDOM. Hence the only results are HARMONY.
It is because Force is ill regulated, that revolutions prove fail-tires. Therefore it is that so often insurrections, coming from those high mountains that domineer over the moral horizon, Justice, Wisdom, Reason, Right, built of the purest snow of the ideal after a long fall from rock to rock, after having reflected the sky in their transparency, and been swollen by a hundred affluents, in the majestic path of triumph, suddenly lose themselves in quagmires, like a California river in the sands.
The onward march of the human race requires that the heights around it should blaze with noble and enduring lessons of courage. Deeds of daring dazzle history, and form one class of the guiding lights of man. They are the stars and coruscations from that great sea of electricity, the Force inherent in the people. To strive, to brave all risks, to perish, to persevere, to be true to one's self, to grapple body to body with destiny, to surprise defeat by the little terror it inspires, now to confront unrighteous power, now to defy intoxicated triumph--these are the examples that the nations need and the light that electrifies them.
There are immense Forces in the great caverns of evil beneath society; in the hideous degradation, squalor, wretchedness and destitution, vices and crimes that reek and simmer in the darkness in that populace below the people, of great cities. There disinterestedness vanishes, every one howls, searches, gropes, and gnaws for himself. Ideas are ignored, and of progress there is no thought. This populace has two mothers, both of them stepmothers--Ignorance and Misery. Want is their only guide--for the appetite alone they crave satisfaction. Yet even these may be employed. The lowly sand we trample upon, cast into the furnace, melted, purified by fire, may become resplendent crystal. They have the brute force of the HAMMER, but their blows help on the great cause, when struck within the lines traced by the RULE held by wisdom and discretion.
Yet it is this very Force of the people, this Titanic power of the giants, that builds the fortifications of tyrants, and is embodied in their armies. Hence the possibility of such tyrannies as those of which it has been said, that "Rome smells worse under Vitellius than under Sulla. Under Claudius and under Domitian there is a deformity of baseness corresponding to the ugliness of the tyranny. The foulness of the slaves is a direct result of the atrocious baseness of the despot. A miasma exhales from these crouching consciences that reflect the master; the public authorities are unclean, hearts are collapsed, consciences shrunken, souls puny. This is so under Caracalla, it is so under Commodus, it is so under Heliogabalus, while from the Roman senate, under Cæsar, there comes only the rank odor peculiar to the eagle's eyrie."
It is the force of the people that sustains all these despotisms, the basest as well as the best. That force acts through armies; and these oftener enslave than liberate. Despotism there applies the RULE. Force is the MACE of steel at the saddle-bow of the knight or of the bishop in armor. Passive obedience by force supports thrones and oligarchies, Spanish kings, and Venetian senates. Might, in an army wielded by tyranny, is the enormous sum total of utter weakness; and so Humanity wages war against Humanity, in despite of Humanity. So a people willingly submits to despot-ism, and its workmen submit to be despised, and its soldiers to be whipped; therefore it is that battles lost by a nation are often progress attained. Less glory is more liberty. When the drum is silent, reason sometimes speaks.
Tyrants use the force of the people to chain and subjugate--that is, enyoke the people. Then they plough with them as men do with oxen yoked. Thus the spirit of liberty and innovation is reduced by bayonets, and principles are struck dumb by cannon-shot; while the monks mingle with the troopers, and the Church militant and jubilant, Catholic or Puritan, sings Te Deums for victories over rebellion.
The military power, not subordinate to the civil power, again the HAMMER or MACE of FORCE, independent of the RULE, is an armed tyranny, born full-grown, as Athenè sprung from the brain of Zeus. It spawns a dynasty, and begins with Cæsar to rot into Vitellius and Commodus. At the present day it inclines to begin where formerly dynasties ended.
Constantly the people put forth immense strength, only to end in immense weakness. The force of the people is exhausted in indefinitely prolonging things long since dead; in governing mankind by embalming old dead tyrannies of Faith; restoring dilapidated dogmas; regilding faded, worm-eaten shrines; whitening and rouging ancient and barren superstitions; saving society by multiplying parasites; perpetuating superannuated institutions; enforcing the worship of symbols as the actual means of salvation; and tying the dead corpse of the Past, mouth to mouth, with the living Present. Therefore it is that it is one of the fatalities of Humanity to be condemned to eternal struggles with phantoms, with superstitions, bigotries, hypocrisies, prejudices, the formulas of error, and the pleas of tyranny. Despotisms, seen in the past, become respectable, as the mountain, bristling with volcanic rock, rugged and horrid, seen through the haze of distance is blue and smooth and beautiful. The sight of a single dungeon of tyranny is worth more, to dispel illusions, and create a holy hatred of despotism, and to direct FORCE aright, than the most eloquent volumes. The French should have preserved the Bastile as a perpetual lesson; Italy should not destroy the dungeons of the Inquisition. The Force of the people maintained the Power that built its gloomy cells, and placed the living in their granite sepulchres.
The FORCE of the people cannot, by its unrestrained and fitful action, maintain and continue in action and existence a free Government once created. That Force must be limited, restrained, conveyed by distribution into different channels, and by roundabout courses, to outlets, whence it is to issue as the law, action, and decision of the State; as the wise old Egyptian kings conveyed in different canals, by sub-division, the swelling waters of the Nile, and compelled them to fertilize and not devastate the land. There must be the jus et norma, the law and Rule, or Gauge, of constitution and law, within which the public force must act. Make a breach in either, and the great steam-hammer, with its swift and ponderous blows, crushes all the machinery to atoms, and, at last, wrenching itself away, lies inert and dead amid the ruin it has wrought.
It is not religion it is that people allow themselves to be led like sheep, by wolves. Ignorance is bliss the cry of the masses. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 5:01:20 PM |
It is not religion it is that people allow themselves to be led like sheep, by wolves.
It is only religion, however, that can claim to know what god wants for you.
No government could ever threaten you with hell. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 5:21:25 PM | The Crusades. The objective here is to show that the motivation for starting and thus maintaining the crusades was a religiously fueled one. Not only by the christians, but as well, the muslims.
From here: http://www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/endmiddle/bluedot/crusades.html
The Crusades were military or quasi-military expeditions launched by Christian secular and religious rulers against Moslems in the Middle East from 1096 to 1291. Religious fervour was an extremely important factor in arousing the Christians to organize military expeditions, as was the hope of gaining immense riches and increased power. So religious fervour, and hope of increased wealth and power for some. Some might contend that both may have been equal in the motivating, but as far as the evidence shows, it is the retaking of what christians at the time considered holy land that was the main driving force:
when the Seljuk Turks swept in from Asia and defeated the Byzantines at the Battle of Manzikert. Seizing all of Asia Minor as well as the Holy Land the Seljuk Turks soon impeded Christian pilgrimages to Jerusalem, forcing the Byzantine emperor, Alexius Comnenus, to ask Pope Urban II (1088-1099) for help against the Turks in the early 1090s. The Pope viewed this request as a great opportunity. Not only could it restore Christian control over the Holy Land, but it also provided a means of domestic pacification that focused the aggression of the European nobility towards the Moslems instead of each other. In addition, coming to the aid of Byzantium held the possibility of a reunion between the eastern and western Churches after almost four decades of schism, thereby strengthening the western Church in general and the papacy in particular. So here we have the christian pilgrims being denied access to the holy land by the seljuk turks. This blockade forces Alexius Comnenus' hand to request forces from pope urbanII. If those lands weren't considered holy, and there weren't any christian pilgrims to be denied, the first crusade may nary have happened. Urban saw other advantages as well, but again, the crusades were started to regain holy lands, as is obviously explained here. As in most wars, collateral benefits in politics are definitely a possibility. In this case, again, the thought of uniting the eastern and western christian factions held promise, which in effect would unite the christian RELIGION. One has to ask why the turks were there in the first place, and why did they invade the christian holy lands... Well, again, for reasons based on religion. From here: http://www.thearma.org/essays/Crusades.htm
Christians in the eleventh century were not paranoid fanatics. Muslims really were gunning for them. While Muslims can be peaceful, Islam was born in war and grew the same way. From the time of Mohammed, the means of Muslim expansion was always the sword. Muslim thought divides the world into two spheres, the Abode of Islam and the Abode of War. Christianity—and for that matter any other non-Muslim religion—has no abode. Christians and Jews can be tolerated within a Muslim state under Muslim rule. But, in traditional Islam, Christian and Jewish states must be destroyed and their lands conquered. When Mohammed was waging war against Mecca in the seventh century, Christianity was the dominant religion of power and wealth. As the faith of the Roman Empire, it spanned the entire Mediterranean, including the Middle East, where it was born. The Christian world, therefore, was a prime target for the earliest caliphs, and it would remain so for Muslim leaders for the next thousand years.
With enormous energy, the warriors of Islam struck out against the Christians shortly after Mohammed's death. They were extremely successful. Palestine, Syria, and Egypt—once the most heavily Christian areas in the world—quickly succumbed. By the eighth century, Muslim armies had conquered all of Christian North Africa and Spain. In the eleventh century, the Seljuk Turks conquered Asia Minor (modern Turkey), which had been Christian since the time of St. Paul. The old Roman Empire, known to modern historians as the Byzantine Empire, was reduced to little more than Greece. In desperation, the emperor in Constantinople sent word to the Christians of western Europe asking them to aid their brothers and sisters in the East.
That is what gave birth to the Crusades. They were not the brainchild of an ambitious pope or rapacious knights but a response to more than four centuries of conquests in which Muslims had already captured two-thirds of the old Christian world. At some point, Christianity as a faith and a culture had to defend itself or be subsumed by Islam. The Crusades were that defense. The above quote is from an essay by Professor Thomas F. Madden, director of the center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies at St. Louis university. Here is a link to a site with Professor Madden's credentials: http://www.slu.edu/departments/history/madden.htm
So to sum up in this post, the christian action of crusade was in answr to the expansion of the muslim religion. While jews and christians were allowed to practice within a muslim state, christian states, or any opposing non muslim state, was fair game for conquest. Again, crusades were started due to religious motivations, on one side muslim expansionism, on the other, the defence and retaking of christian holy lands.
Please note, that no offense towards peaceful muslims is intended here, it basically history here that is being explored, not any particular bashing of someone's beliefs and faith. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 5:33:40 PM | It is only religion, however, that can claim to know what god wants for you.
No government could ever threaten you with hell.
The above statement is just so wrong.
A governments threats of hell and punishment for non conformity by far out weigh a pastors and can be felt at the end of the whip with the only appeal to the government holding the whip. If you don't like what one religious creed tells you to do, you can change your creed, only the government can force you to be a certain religion, and even then you need only show outward conformity to the governments religious mandates. You true creeds can be kept in private away from the eye of the oppressors.
As an example the Catholic church says that it is the only true church but there are many others, its claim has no weight without the sword arm of governance. So the religion is not the problem it is the governments that force conformity of certain beliefs and those that allow themselves to be governed in that form.
America is another good example of how the great ideals of equality and justice for all has fallen into a mass of sheep baying that the constitution is based on Christian as they are willing to except it values. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 6:05:55 PM |
As an example the Catholic church says that it is the only true church but there are many others, its claim has no weight without the sword arm of governance. And the "sword arm of governance" as you put it has no impetus without the religion behind it. Take away the religion, and that "sword arm" is removed. It is the same as in theocracies found in the middle east. Governments operating under sharia law enforce strictly religious based laws and rules. Sometimes quite oppressive depending on your gender, class, and even denomination within the same religion.
So the religion is not the problem it is the governments that force conformity of certain beliefs and those that allow themselves to be governed in that form. Without sharia law, iran could well be a democracy, and some of those whom were oppressed, may have a better lot under a democratic, religion and state separated system, than under sharia law. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 6:21:49 PM |
" I, along with other academics who work in religious studies, find a frequently-heard comment quite superficial: "If it were not for religion, there would be no violence and no wars." There's no question that religious systems, Christianity included, have "played into" wars regularly and violently. But that religion, per se, separable from economic and other factors, alone is responsible for war strikes me as a historically problematic kind of claim. "
My comment: This is a position any sane person would agree with. Anyone capable of saying "If it were not for religion, etc" is utterly unWAIS. Alan Luxenberg calls our attention to an article on the subject: See the Spring 1998 Orbis on "Faith and Statecraft."
Ronald Hilton - 2/05/01
http://www.stanford.edu/group/wais/Religion/religion_causeofwar20501.html | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 6:45:18 PM |
A governments threats of hell and punishment for non conformity by far out weigh a pastors and can be felt at the end of the whip with the only appeal to the government holding the whip.
It appears you perfectly missed my point.
Picture the most vile kind of leader-worship society. North Korea is a good example. North Koreans are constantly told to thank the great leader for the little they have.
But the tyrant of North Korea can't threaten you with eternal torture. As Christopher Hitchens says, "at least you can die and get out of North Korea."
Only religion can terrify those who believe in it with torture FOREVER for noncompliance.
If you don't like what one religious creed tells you to do, you can change your creed, only the government can force you to be a certain religion, and even then you need only show outward conformity to the governments religious mandates.
Completely incorrect.
No religious person who takes their faith even slightly seriously could ever fall back on your convenient dogma-hopping idea. A serious Catholic can't bring themselves to become Protestant simply because there's something they don't like about Catholicism.
Furthermore, Christianity (among other religions) is more totalitarian than any nation or state could ever dream of. It tells us we're born with original sin. We didn't choose to put ourselves under heavens government, we didn't have a say in the crucifixion. Yet we are at its mercy. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 6:55:36 PM | In reply to the_reverend in the above post (msg 267)... Please point out where somebody, in this thread, has stated that religion is THE ONLY source of violence and war. Your above post, in that regard is a total strawman. You, through your quote, are implying the argument people are trying to make in this thread is that religion is the sole reason for violence and war. We are not, we are pointing out that religion indeed does play a part in SOME of the conflicts in human history, and is SOMETIMES even the cause and motivation. Sad when weak, ridiculous, cheap-shot strawmen arguments have to be dragged out.
In regard to the irish catholic vs protestant conflict in ulster. Apparently, all evidence I could find points to religion being one factor in the past violence that has occurred. It has long been a sorespot for the irish AND the british.
From here: http://atheism.about.com/library/FAQs/christian/blfaq_viol_northernireland.htm
The terrible combination of nationalism, politics and religion has had deadly consequences for the people living in Northern Ireland. Catholics and Protestants have been vilifying, attacking, torturing and killing each other in a seemingly endless cycle which has only recently begun to show hopeful signs of finally ending. Ulster, the focal point of most of the violence, is an amazingly beautiful province.
To present day:
The origins of Ireland's "troubles" lie in the distant past of English imperialism. The creation of an Anglican Protestant church also created a fundamental religious conflict with an Irish population having little interest in converting with their neighbors. It wasn't until the reign of Elizabeth I that Ireland was finally "conquered," but she was never able to halt regular Catholic uprisings
Ulster was drawn forever into the conflict when James I seized Catholic lands in and around the city in order to give them to loyal Protestants from England and Scotland. Evicted Catholics starved in the surrounding hills until a few crawled back and begged for menial jobs on their former farms. Unsurprisingly, revolts among Catholics continued across Ireland. When Puritan Oliver Cromwell took control of England, his reprisals against Catholics were amazing in their brutality.
Under 1700's Penal Laws, Catholicism was outlawed and priests were banished. Catholics who tried to continue their faith in secret were hunted with dogs and regularly killed outright. Although Catholicism regained legal status in the 1800's, Catholics had to pay tithes to the Anglican church. When this led to the "Tithe War," both sides perpetrated cruelties in the name of the same God
Finally, in this century, the southern counties of Ireland were finally liberated from English rule - and became a 90% Catholic country where even today divorce is outlawed and women have to travel to England to obtain abortions. But the descendants of King James' colonists voted to remain united with England - they feared how they would be treated in a predominantly Catholic nation.
Because the above source is from an atheist site, I also provide a second reference with no apparent affiliation to atheist sources: From here: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0108101.html
History
Ulster was part of Catholic Ireland until the reign of Elizabeth I (1558–1603) when, after suppressing three Irish rebellions, the Crown confiscated lands in Ireland and settled the Scots Presbyterians in Ulster. Another rebellion in 1641–1651, brutally crushed by Oliver Cromwell, resulted in the settlement of Anglican Englishmen in Ulster. Subsequent political policy favoring Protestants and disadvantaging Catholics encouraged further Protestant settlement in Northern Ireland.
Northern Ireland did not separate from the South until William Gladstone presented, in 1886, his proposal for home rule in Ireland. The Protestants in the North feared domination by the Catholic majority. Industry, moreover, was concentrated in the North and dependent on the British market. When World War I began, civil war threatened between the regions. Northern Ireland, however, did not become a political entity until the six counties accepted the Home Rule Bill of 1920. This set up a semiautonomous parliament in Belfast and a Crown-appointed governor advised by a cabinet of the prime minister and 8 ministers, as well as a 12-member representation in the House of Commons in London.
When the Republic of Ireland gained sovereignty in 1922, relations improved between North and South, although the Irish Republican Army (IRA), outlawed in recent years, continued the struggle to end the partition of Ireland. In 1966–1969, rioting and street fighting between Protestants and Catholics occurred in Londonderry, fomented by extremist nationalist Protestants, who feared the Catholics might attain a local majority, and by Catholics demonstrating for civil rights. These confrontations became known as “the Troubles.”
The religious communities, Catholic and Protestant, became hostile armed camps. British troops were brought in to separate them but themselves became a target of Catholics, particularly by the IRA, which by this time had turned into a full-fledged terrorist movement. The goal of the IRA was to eject the British and unify Northern Ireland with the Irish Republic to the south. The Protestants remained tenaciously loyal to the United Kingdom, and various Protestant terrorist organizations pursued the Unionist cause through violence. Various attempts at representational government and power-sharing foundered during the 1970s, and both sides were further polarized. Direct rule from London and the presence of British troops failed to stop the violence.
To sum up, although not the only motivation for violence, it certainly plays a role, along with nationalism and politics. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 8:20:50 PM | The Irish catholic/protestant situation is an excellent example of religion motivating violence. I will also present reference to THAT as well... Strawman ya self Changed ya tune
To sum up, although not the only motivation for violence, it certainly plays a role, along with nationalism and politics. Fact is religion played very little role in the "battle" other than as a convenient means of the identifying combatants squabbling over power, control and dirt.. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 8:21:46 PM | Religion is not the reason. Religion is a flag that is waved to arouse and unite the masses.
The Islamic fundamentalist for example are using Islam to call the people to action against the evil imperialist west. The cause is not Islam the cause is the imperialist west the rally cry is Islam.
The Spanish Conquistadors slaughtered the natives for land, gold and slaves the rally cry to the masses was to convert the savage heathen to Christianity and save their souls.
The European settlers of North America slaughtered the Natives for land and resources the cause, The rally cry was that the were heathens.
The Nazi slaughtered the Jews for power, control, resources again the cause the rally cry was that they were a devil race and killed Christ.
The old testament Hebrews slaughtered the inhabitants of the land they were to inherit for the land the cause again the rally cry was for God and country.
On the battle field for God and country has no bearing as the enemy whoever it is, is also fighting for God and country. Religion is just a flag that the masses respond to well. If a person can not be brought to a side by religion then leaders use gold as an incentive. If gold or religion does not work leaders will use the external threat to life and family by leaving areas exposed to enemy attack. They are just flags used to yoke the masses to the will of those in or in desire of control of the masses.
I don't think that there are any cases where religion is the cause of war. The cause is expansion, resources, control, power etc., but the easiest and cheapest flag to rally the masses under is religion. Why pay a man to fight if you can get him to fight for God. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 8:40:48 PM | The Irish catholic/protestant situation is an excellent example of religion motivating violence. I will also present reference to THAT as well... Strawman ya self Changed ya tune Strawman? Here, I'll do you a favor: Go to this link: http://onegoodmove.org/fallacy/toc.htm Browse down to the "Missing the Point" section, there you will find strawman... in fact, you should perhaps give the whole page a good read.
As to the "change ya tune" comment?? You bet. That's what following the evidence is all about. That's what intellectual honesty is all about. Although it was not a prime cause, the religious motivations were still there and played a part... THAT is what the evidence tells us, so of course the outlook changes.
I don't think that there are any cases where religion is the cause of war. The cause is expansion, resources, control, power etc., but the easiest and cheapest flag to rally the masses under is religion. Why pay a man to fight if you can get him to fight for God. Obviously missed my previous post on the crusades and the irish conflict.
The Islamic fundamentalist for example are using Islam to call the people to action against the evil imperialist west. The cause is not Islam the cause is the imperialist west the rally cry is Islam. Evidence? Not expecting any, just thought I should ask..
The Spanish Conquistadors slaughtered the natives for land, gold and slaves the rally cry to the masses was to convert the savage heathen to Christianity and save their souls.
The European settlers of North America slaughtered the Natives for land and resources the cause, The rally cry was that the were heathens.
The Nazi slaughtered the Jews for power, control, resources again the cause the rally cry was that they were a devil race and killed Christ.
Care to explain where somebody blamed these above on religion. I don't remember anyone mentioning those conflicts as religiously motivated...
The old testament Hebrews slaughtered the inhabitants of the land they were to inherit for the land the cause again the rally cry was for God and country. Thanks..
Here is a link that lists some atrocities apparently done in the name of religion: http://www.religioustolerance.org/relhateex.htm
| |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 9:52:34 PM |
The Islamic fundamentalist for example are using Islam to call the people to action against the evil imperialist west. The cause is not Islam the cause is the imperialist west the rally cry is Islam.
Explain to me how hatred of the west results in Sharia Law. How does the existence of the United States result in a culture that believes women should be barely seen and treated as property?
What is it about the UK that causes Middle Eastern people to perform honor killings on their daughters?
Those things happen because of religion and ONLY because of religion.
Don't tell me people turn to that just as a banner. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/17/2008 9:57:28 PM | Anyone read the book or watched the documentary by Richard Dawkins called "the God Delusion"? Quite the eye opener especially part 2. You can watch the streaming movie at http://video.google.ca/videoplay?docid=-4321574955310561251
ENJOY | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 3/18/2008 10:13:19 AM | Religion is not the CAUSE of atrocities religion is the excuse.
Why do you beat your wife? God told me to. Oh that makes sense I want to beat my wife too. Why do you hate the Jews? God told me to. Why do you hate the West? God told me to. Why do you hate Muslims? God told me to. Why did you shoot John Lennon? God told me to.
Well if God told you to thats good enough for me I was inclined to do such and such any way.
Just because someone says or even believes that God told them to do something does not make it true.
Who did these atrocities? Not ME. Parents have heard the Not ME excuse forever and most people would think a parent that believes the Not Me excuse in the least gullible. The same applies to the God told me to, if a person believes that reason they are in the least gullible. So saying that religion is the cause is in the least gullible, but is actually more complicit. | |
|
|
| Page 11 of 33
|
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33 |
|