|
|
|
|
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/20/2008 1:15:57 PM | Existence of God is ireffutable. Atheists can brag about all they want, but even the modern day physicists have started to admit recently the the theory of intelligent designer is not out of the question.
Lets forget God for a minute. Lets say God doesn't exist.
Let me think like an atheist for a minute. I agree to be an athiest and willing to give up on Islam, if you can just come up with a better explanation than the big bang theory as the basis of the creation of this universe.
The way this whole universe, it can't happen due to just one stupid explosion and with some random events in the nature that have occured through out the course of history.
Even if its evolution, who has moderated this so called slow change?
In computer programming we call this looping and conditioning. A programmer relies heavily on looping and conditioning to generate the desirable results from his computer program.
And that's how see this world. With a lot of loopings and conditions set by God.
There is has to be some one above. This whole universe can not be a coincidence.
My mind refuse to accept. | |
|
ousu
| Joined: 6/2/2005 Msg: 52 | |
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/20/2008 2:36:10 PM | The source of evil is hardly any religion but human nature itself. You take away from believers one religion, and obviously after a while they have found something else to explain fundamental questions to which they do not find answers otherwise.
A religion or an ideology, unfortunately, can be used to make the divisions like "we" and "others", or as an excuse for some social/political actions. As long as a person keeps his believing system more as a private matter - something between he and his god - I believe a religion can be beneficial for him. (A method to deal with his life.) I do not mean that when a belief is shared with other believers, it automatically becomes something dangerous - only that a group of people is usually more dangerous than a single person. (Sorry, cannot explain better my reasoning...)
So, I do agree with OP when he is saying "there are social and cultural reasons" for believing, but I would add there also a psychological reason. What I do not agree is the statement a religion to be the true evil. It just becomes easily a tool for human nature to justify other needs. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/20/2008 3:57:23 PM | But just as with "money is the root of all evil"
It is not the above but,
The love of money is the cause of all sorts of evil.
Religion is used by power seekers to control the people. Just as with the above the mass of people have heard that line and many believe that the quote is money is the root of all evil but the actual line reads the love of money causes all sorts of evil, one line blames money for all evil the other blames the actions of people (loving money) for causing many evils, much different context but most would say the former is the quote from scripture.
If a person loves money it would be to their benefit to make it seem as all money is bad rather then just the lust for power and they certainly would not want everyone to lust after the money or power, too much competition. So they spin a tale that money is the root of all evil is in the scriptures when the truth is that what is in the scripture is that the lust for power and control causes all sorts of evil to be inflicted upon men by men and is not in step with a God of love.
Continuing with money is the root of all evil you can change the evil nature of your money by sending me a donation to the cause and I will say a prayer over it and ask for a blessing it will make the rest of your money good etc.
Simple controlling of the masses perception if money is the root of all evil you need to do something good with your money ie. give some of your money to the church because the church is better then you and knows how to spend your money better then you do. It goes on and is deep seated into the psyche of many.
The true evil of the world is those that use religion to advance control and power over their fellow men. The truth will set you free not make you a subject of the church. | |
|
| |
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/20/2008 6:29:47 PM |
In a way I agree, there are a huge number of wars that would never have been fought if it hadnt been for religion.
Name a few. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/20/2008 9:10:06 PM |
Existence of God is ireffutable. Atheists can brag about all they want, but even the modern day physicists have started to admit recently the the theory of intelligent designer is not out of the question.
So is the non-existence of God. God's existence can be no more proven than disproven. That is why it is one of the classic questions/problems of religious philosophy and is a matter of faith not reason.
Let me think like an atheist for a minute. I agree to be an athiest and willing to give up on Islam, if you can just come up with a better explanation than the big bang theory as the basis of the creation of this universe.
The way this whole universe, it can't happen due to just one stupid explosion and with some random events in the nature that have occured through out the course of history.
Even if its evolution, who has moderated this so called slow change?
In computer programming we call this looping and conditioning. A programmer relies heavily on looping and conditioning to generate the desirable results from his computer program.
And that's how see this world. With a lot of loopings and conditions set by God.
There is has to be some one above. This whole universe can not be a coincidence.
My mind refuse to accept.
The fallacy of argument from incredulity...I cannot fathom it, therefore it cannot be real or what is...
Not an uncommon logical fallacy but really not the first time it has shown up in one of these type of discussions... but not exactly on topic either eh? A lot of people seem to take this one. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/20/2008 10:45:05 PM | quote the op "ask yourself the question of why you don't believe in Thor, or Poseidon or Santa Claus ---- could please do a little research before you actually start a topic ..as a matter of fact I do believe in St. Nicholas aka Santa Claus. Saint Nicholas was a real person. Did you know that?
more of the op "but in the end they simply amount to brainwashing as a child. If you indoctrinate your children into any faith, you are in a sense brainwashing them to believe in your invisible god creature"
what proof do you have of that? because I can introduce you to hundreds of people who turned into ....mmmm...lets say Jesus Freaks....in their 20's , 30's and 40's ...I am one of them....and these people had no faith based upbringing....they most likely acepted Christ later in life because of the lack of him in their childhood and they didn't want to raise their own children in such a Godless way. where does your opinion that they are brainwashed come from ?? Hollywood movies???
can you see the wind??? I can't but I know it is there....I witness the results of the wind just like I witness the results of God.... sight is only one sense...would you like to tell a blind person their is no God...simply because he can't be seen....I guess they would say ...So what! everything is invisible to me
and this post is obviously a duplicat of a previous post :  | |
|
DonQ
| Joined: 1/10/2008 Msg: 58 | |
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/21/2008 7:42:53 AM | anything and everything that is taken to extremes can be very deadly. Throughout our sad history, man has happily slaughtered each other over one premise: my god is better than your god. This leads inevitably to "worship my god or I have to kill you". The typical response is "go ahead and try it. My god protects me from your you and your god" and then the fight is on.
In the end only the carion feeders are happy because now they get a free meal out of the whole thing.
The same can be said of patriotism/nationalism. Think of all the wars that have been fought over "our nation is better then your nation". Its actually quite sad in my opinion. And very very stupid.
I hope one day we actually grow up and get past such pettiness but I know my bones will have long ago turned to dust by then. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/21/2008 10:33:57 AM | yes religion is the cause for many wars and a stupid reason to start wars too...but it depends how the person is brought up...my best friends are super religious but don't expect the whole world to change there views about religion because they believe strongly...they still respect others with different views cause others show them general respect... i believe god is a name for a higher power and the bible is a bunch of BS that someone made up while really really bored....church is an excuse to get money from religious people...the higher power is anything you want it to be...a tree, purple, black,water,etc... i also feel religion is used to control people to a point...so no matter what anyone says if you believe there is a higher power then thats all you need as far as religion goes...it doesn't matter what you do with your life...its how you handle each situation...and do you change for the better or worse... | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/21/2008 1:19:25 PM | I love how many atheists I meet attempt to cram their lack of belief in something down my throat as if to justify their own beliefs. "You're wrong, therefore I'm right." Well, what if we're both wrong?
On that same note it goes for believers of any faith.
Certainty is the death of progress. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/21/2008 1:52:45 PM | One thing is certain. ^^^^^
How beliefs are transmitted from human to human and how that very act perpetuates belief even against your will. Advertisers know it all to well, you don't even have to make a good product you just have to repeatedly advertise it and it will sell. Why? because that is how the brain works. Anything put in is accepted as a belief and then you have to actively disbelieve in attempts to not believe. Which actually makes the belief stronger oddly enough. It's a win win for religious groups that prey on people for their survival.
I can see a day when Freedom of speech will be changed one day so enjoy it while it lasts. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/21/2008 6:46:04 PM | Scorpio:
One of my instructors once said that religion and general motors have much more in common than many would like to believe... and I totally concur. --->It would be more accurate to say that religion and the motor car have much more in common than many would like to believe. There are many non-polluting motor cars, and the design does not need to run on petroleum at all. But the "fat cats" and the political leaders forced it to be run on oil, by banning any other substance to be used as fuel. In that way, it is incredibly similar. However you wish to twist the correlation is fine with me as that is a reflection of your belief system....
But I prefer to keep it the way it was as I find it infinitely more accurate to compare religion to a large corporation concerned with things like quantity of consumers, distributing their product, advertising and profits... Imo that cannot be denied regardless of which religion is being discussed...
Taranis:
But just as with "money is the root of all evil"
It is not the above but,
The love of money is the cause of all sorts of evil.
The true evil of the world is those that use religion to advance control and power over their fellow men. The truth will set you free not make you a subject of the church. I think you took my quote out of context... as it turns out, you are saying essentially the same thing as what I was attempting to convey:
But just as with "money is the root of all evil".. Imo it is not the money or the religion itself.. rather, it is how the power entailed within each is used that truly matters...
When we are talking about something with such an immense amount of power over the masses.. the temptation is HUGE to abuse it... and people do... everyday.
Crazylilting:
How beliefs are transmitted from human to human and how that very act perpetuates belief even against your will. Advertisers know it all to well, you don't even have to make a good product you just have to repeatedly advertise it and it will sell. Why? because that is how the brain works. Anything put in is accepted as a belief and then you have to actively disbelieve in attempts to not believe. Which actually makes the belief stronger oddly enough. It's a win win for religious groups that prey on people for their survival. As though people are mindless drones incapable of questioning?? If that were the case we would ALL be indoctrinated considering the extreme efforts put toward that eventuality...
What is the difference between the one who tips his head back for his daily dose and the one who questions? For one thing a lack of victim consciousness as to the difference his choices CAN make... as well as a healthy desire to learn and grow... to know the truth despite what others think/say/do... and to have the courage to stand in it no matter who agrees..
Those people DO exist and imo should not have to suffer because many others choose to not exercise the same power and authority over their own mind.
I can see a day when Freedom of speech will be changed one day so enjoy it while it lasts. Freedom of speech should be altered because some people are too afraid to question?
If that were the case crazylilting.. who would be there to question freedom of speech itself? ;) | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/21/2008 10:21:32 PM | | they who ever they are say that religion is mans way of distracting a % of the population to be distracted by a belief that is based on comon sence and basic parables so that a greater source could persuade a harsh judgement of shame and guilt to motivate people.....sounds kinda evil | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 3:02:28 AM |
But it's exactly how that belief manifests itself that I'm talking about. As for what's "evil" that's to do with human behaviour and intrinsically the concept, to some, of what god is. What I’m saying is that this is not true and easily misconceived.
I hear people say that a lot and it seems like a completely empty statement.
Do you think that without religion people would be blowing themselves up and flying themselves into buildings? Absolutely not. Religion directly causes those things.
You can have your opinion and I must give credit to those that have destroyed the beauty of the Christ, but, There is a God and even the aliens of outer space worship and know the God that is God.
And until you back that statement up with some proof it holds just as much power as saying the aliens KNOW there's a Santa Claus.
I'm an International Relations grad. Studied conflicts for my major. It's a pitiful myth that religion has started all, or even most, wars.
No it isn't.
Wars have been about greed and property since the dawn of man.
And the institution of religion feeds directly into those cravings.
Dennett is built in the same vein - setting humans of any group against humans of any other group is traitorious to all of humankind and Mr. Atheist Champion is as evil as Bush in that way.
In what way does Dennett set people against each other? SURELY you aren't so daft as to interpret his speaking his beliefs as a call to violent conflict?
None of them have managed to glom the simple fact that all their 'proof' of the impossibility of the Divine is based on the pathetic amount of knowledge that humans have managed to amass thus far.
I was under the impression that we can all be in agreement that neither side in this argument can ever definitively prove their belief.
That being said, the burden of proof lies with the theist. Everything looks and operates as it would without a god, theism creates a mystery where none exists.
We are not even close to the epitome of all that can be known; indeed every day that which was formerly taught as certainty is changed. The atom is not the smallest particle. There may have not been a Big Bang. Now we find the universe is shrinking, rather than expanding. In short, we know absolutely nothing and therefore pronouncements by the Dennetts are worth precisely that.
It's a common misconception that atheists claim to have answers for everything. Of course we don't.
How anyone with any sense can follow a Dennett and think that man knows any better than the rest of the humans on the planet baffles me. We, not one of us, have the slightest clue of how the universe actually works; therefore none of us can state categorically that anything is possible or impossible. It's the most ridiculous of conceits to even attempt it.
This struck me as ironic. It isn't atheists who claim to have been let in on a secret from god. THEISTS, not atheists, claim to know things they can't possibly know.
Please, do yourselves a favour and never again repeat the utter falsehood that 'religion causes wars'. Greedy humans cause wars and wield whatever tools they will to serve their cause. Religion is victim, not villain.
Simply false. The Israelis and the Palestinians are a perfect example of this. They've been warring for generations in what is basically a land struggle. Without religion telling them the land they're fighting for is holy, the two sides would have come to a two state solution long ago. Only with religion could that conflict continue to rage.
And of course human beings are inherently greedy. Religion simply feeds into that.
I don't think it's religion per se that is evil. I think the evil comes from some people's need to have an unbending interpretation of religious dogma and the need to impose their belief on someone else that is evil.
Another common misconception. The holy books of all three monotheisms are incredibly immoral and violent.
Once in a great while a man comes along to show mankind 'the way' to a better reality after death. These messages always seem to get corrupted in such a way by 'leadership' that we are made to believe it's ok to hate, ok to kill on a large scale because our brethren of another tribe have religious views that are not exactly as ours.
Again, wrong. It doesn't require a madman to understand that, for example, Leviticus 20:27 NAB
-A man or a woman who acts as a medium or fortuneteller shall be put to death by stoning; they have no one but themselves to blame for their death.-
plainly advocates the murder of fortunetellers. Don't anybody try and tell me that's a metaphor. It means what it says.
And just as much evil has been done in the name of irreligion.
BIG mistake here. It is a well known fact that atheist regimes have slaughtered millions. But they didn't do what they did in the name of atheism.
To call oneself an atheist doesn't suggest a certain morality. An atheist can be a fascist, a demagogue, a psychopath. But no violence is ever done BECAUSE they're atheists, the same cannot be said of Christians, Jews or Muslims.
the ones who think religions are the true evil are making up there own rights and wrongs and rules and morels as they go and forcing us to go along.
Ah, yes. The good old 'how would we know right from wrong if it weren't for religion' argument.
So you truly believe that before Moses revealed the ten commandments people lived and died under the impression that murder, theft, perjury, rape, etc were all OK? Of course not, they wouldn't have ever made it that far were that the case.
And what about the story Jesus tells about the good samaritan?
"A man was going down from Jerusalem to Jericho, when he fell into the hands of robbers. They stripped him of his clothes, beat him and went away, leaving him half dead. A priest happened to be going down the same road, and when he saw the man, he passed by on the other side. So too, a Levite, when he came to the place and saw him, passed by on the other side. But a Samaritan, as he traveled, came where the man was; and when he saw him, he took pity on him. He went to him and bandaged his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. "
Obviously that man was not a Christian as the idea didn't even exist at the time.
Tell me why the worship of this God, or that God can be evil.
Because every religion, in some form or another, demands that people give up their reasoning. Furthermore, pick a monotheism and I will supply you with plenty of unaltered, in-context quotes from the source material as to why it should be considered evil.
Some have a tendency to profess that their God is better than other Gods.
Yes, because that is what religion tells them. You can't tell somebody that there is an all powerful celestial dictator and then turn around and tell them they should respect other beliefs.
Religion teaches us peace, love and brotherhood. How can that be evil? Religion teaches us right from wrong. How can that be evil?
Well, as I already covered, our morality does NOT come from religion.
Here's a taste of some of the morality of the Christian bible
human sacrifice
"At the LORD's command, a man of God from Judah went to Bethel, and he arrived there just as Jeroboam was approaching the altar to offer a sacrifice. Then at the LORD's command, he shouted, "O altar, altar! This is what the LORD says: A child named Josiah will be born into the dynasty of David. On you he will sacrifice the priests from the pagan shrines who come here to burn incense, and human bones will be burned on you." (1 Kings 13:1-2 NLT)
rape and murder
"As you approach a town to attack it, first offer its people terms for peace. If they accept your terms and open the gates to you, then all the people inside will serve you in forced labor. But if they refuse to make peace and prepare to fight, you must attack the town. When the LORD your God hands it over to you, kill every man in the town. But you may keep for yourselves all the women, children, livestock, and other plunder. You may enjoy the spoils of your enemies that the LORD your God has given you." (Deuteronomy 20:10-14)
Or how about citing examples that do NOT include the Abrahamic religions instead of bandying the term religion like all religions are the same as those we are most familiar with?
I could, but don't you think the fact that the large majority of religious people believe in one of the big three monotheisms warrants focus on them?
Would you call Hitler calling for the death of the Jews because they are a plague on humanity and on the Germans, as rational humanism?
No, because Hitler did not murder the Jews based on the presumption that there is no god. (side note: up until the very end the Catholic church celebrated Hitlers birthday every year)
Where does it say that anyone was killed as an action "SPECIFICALLY committed in the name of any religion"?
I'm all ears as to how 9/11, 7/7, The Salem Witch Trials, etc could have occurred without religion.
But that is not any different than killing priests because they don't believe in Soviet authority.
Actually it is. The Soviet who killed the priest killed him because he opposed Soviet rule, not because he believed in god. Simply because an atheist performs an immoral act doesn't mean he performed it due to his atheism.
Sorry. But where is this in the OT? Or Judaism? You do know that this is forbidden in Judaism since the start, don't you?
The Bible advocating the murder of apostates:
"If your own full brother, or your son or daughter, or your beloved wife, or you intimate friend, entices you secretly to serve other gods, whom you and your fathers have not known, gods of any other nations, near at hand or far away, from one end of the earth to the other: do not yield to him or listen to him, nor look with pity upon him, to spare or shield him, but kill him. Your hand shall be the first raised to slay him; the rest of the people shall join in with you. You shall stone him to death, because he sought to lead you astray from the Lord, your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, that place of slavery. And all Israel, hearing of this, shall fear and never do such evil as this in your midst. " (Deuteronomy 13:7-12 NAB)
"Suppose a man or woman among you, in one of your towns that the LORD your God is giving you, has done evil in the sight of the LORD your God and has violated the covenant by serving other gods or by worshiping the sun, the moon, or any of the forces of heaven, which I have strictly forbidden. When you hear about it, investigate the matter thoroughly. If it is true that this detestable thing has been done in Israel, then that man or woman must be taken to the gates of the town and stoned to death." (Deuteronomy 17:2-5 NLT)
And here are some quotes from the Talmud that aren't too keen on the idea of apostates either
"Heretics, traitors and apostates are to be thrown into a well and not rescued." Abhodah Zarah (26b)
And let's not forget the sexist prayer many Jews recite every day when they wake up: Baruch Atah Adonai, Eloheinu Melech ha-olam, shelo asani ishah or Blessed are You, O Lord our God, Ruler of the Universe, Who did not make me a woman.
But making any implication that religion was somehow involved in murder and atheism was not, would imply that intolerance was NOT at the root of this idea, unless you claimed that all atheists are tolerant of others, and don't try and ridicule and put down anyone who doesn't share their beliefs.
Atheists have certainly murdered and commited other immoral acts, but not due to their atheism.
Christians/Muslims/Jews have certainly murdered and committed other immoral acts precisely because of their faith.
By the way, I would not quote from Dawkins, because he has published a book called "The God Delusion", which by its very title, is in contradiction to what most psychologists believe about religious belief.
Please clarify what you are referring to when you say the title contradicts "what most psychologists believe".
He stated on National Television in the UK, that he thinks all forms of acupuncture are bogus, but he is willing to propose his own ideas on behaviour, based on "selfish" genes, when no-one claims that he has followed the Scientific Method in his claims, in that he has not done clinical trials on his own claims.
That makes no sense at all. So Richard Dawkins believes acupuncture is BS. No big deal there.
As far as his ideas, the key words are "propose his own ideas". He's not pretending to have any mystical answers for things science can't explain yet. There's nothing wrong with him saying 'well, if I had to guess, I'd say...' If you disagree with him spiritually, fine. But don't muckrake the mans educational background, he's an excellent scientist.
However, we must play fair. Blame all or none. If atheism is not at fault, then neither is communism, or theism, or religion.
False. It might sound nice to say 'let's all be equal' but in this case it makes no sense.
In what way would lack of belief in god cause somebody to hurt another individual?
On the other side of the coin, it's quite easy to understand why somebody who thought god wanted them to wipe another group of people out would commit murder.
Thousands of years of human history... thousands of years of human mythology... thousands of years of human experiences... all of which contains religious experiences and written accounts... is wrong. (according to you)
Yes.
The billions of humans who lived before you who have believed that God or any Diety existed are all wrong. (according to you)
Yes.
There is no God, no Divinity, no Divine beings whatsoever; and everyone who believed that God exists... before you were even born... are all wrong. (according to you)
Yes.
Furthermore, you are saying that "I" am wrong about what I believe and that I was brainwashed by my parents to believing what I believe.
I don't know you personally so to say you were brainwashed would be going too far. But yes, I believe you're wrong.
Take a look at human history, name the civilizations that developed in isolation... that did not believe in God.
That proves nothing.
Imagine being a human being 4,000 years ago. Imagine how absolutely terrifying an earthquake or tsunami would be. We are pattern seeking creatures. Religion is our first and worst attempt to explain these things.
If there is any brainwashing going on at all pertaining to what you posted... it was you brainwashing yourself into believing that you are right and the billions of other humans (since the dawn of civilization until now) who have believed in God or any Diety are wrong.
Do you really think that simply pointing to the majority backs up your belief at all? If most of my friends believed they could jump off of a building and live would that make it so?
I can see how affiliating yourself with those of like mind may give you the false impression that the world is "realizing there is no God."
The world is still very much a mostly religious place. But atheism has been growing, despite still being a very small minority.
Nearly every isolated civilization has believed that there is some metaphysical reason behind their existance, and that is almost always linked to a god in some form.
And? As I said, religion is simply mankinds first, worst effort at explaining the wholly terrifying natural world.
I only modify the original argument to say that religion that preaches "exclusive truth" is the true evil in the world.
Well you've just thrown out Islam, Judaism, Christianity and many other religions.
How exactly do you preach that there's an all power creator with a plan for you but that it might not be the "exclusive truth"?
Existence of God is ireffutable.
OK, let me see the evidence.
Atheists can brag about all they want, but even the modern day physicists have started to admit recently the the theory of intelligent designer is not out of the question.
Of course not, and anybody who says they can definitively disprove the idea of god is an idiot. You can never 100% rule out intelligent design (which is a terribly ironic name) the same way you can never 100% rule out pink unicorns creating the universe.
The way this whole universe, it can't happen due to just one stupid explosion and with some random events in the nature that have occured through out the course of history.
Uh, yes it can. I can provide you with science that would suggest exactly that. What can you provide me other than your word?
Even if its evolution, who has moderated this so called slow change?
Just by asking that question you've demonstrated a complete lack of comprehension as to what evolution is all about.
I can introduce you to hundreds of people who turned into ....mmmm...lets say Jesus Freaks....in their 20's , 30's and 40's ...I am one of them....and these people had no faith based upbringing....they most likely acepted Christ later in life because of the lack of him in their childhood and they didn't want to raise their own children in such a Godless way.
This is true. To say that all religious people are only religious because they were taught it as children is not true.
However, you must concede that some people ARE religious because it was inculcated from birth.
can you see the wind??? I can't but I know it is there....
The wind can be measured. You can scientifically test it and get the same results every time.
my best friends are super religious but don't expect the whole world to change there views about religion because they believe strongly
Then they are ignoring parts of their holy books.
I will close up this post with a two part challenge, borrowed from Christopher Hitchens.
First, name me one moral action performed or one more statement uttered that could not have been performed by an unbeliever. I have never seen this done.
Second, name me one IMMORAL action performed or one IMMORAL statement uttered that could only have come from faith. Probably by the end of this sentence you will have already thought of one. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 9:33:38 AM | Non of what i said makes us victims or mindless drones. It is simply how the brain works. You of all people should know this as you are in the mental health profession sassy. If you don't i'd suggest its not me who is afraid to question it is you.
Its funny my special someone was doing some research on addictions last night because i am having a difficult time quitting smoking. One of the things that came up was the 'fact' that people need outside sources to take over where abusive people that aren't in their life leave a void. This is where addictions come in, as well as you guessed it religion. Often the latter come into play after being on a self destructive pattern has been established and religion fills that void which is the original void left by abusive controlling people.
This is quite an accepted view on the subject so i don't know where you find it in yourself to read more into it then needs to be. We are not mindless, conditioned yes. Even those who think they are enlightened thinkers to some degree are conditioned. Even you sassy have been conditioned, to deny it would be ridiculous. Its just a question of making a mind map to find out what you are conditioned to think.
Conditioned people don't see they are conditioned much like someone who is in denial won't see they are in denial. Governments, religions, and advertisers are well aware of these things and so their consultants who specialise in designing the perfect campaign for target audiences that work.
We only think its ok to spread our beliefs (religions) to others because we are taught that it is our freedom to do so. But it is not freedom, its a compulsion. If we recognised a belief as a cult action is taken, why? If something existed before we understood its danger and has been accepted as a belief system it is much harder to speak out against it with the new information we have learned, but that doesn't change the devastating effects on the mind the belief system might be causing. I am not singling out one belief system i am talking about all belief systems that have been turned into religions. Buddhism is the closest religion to freedom i've ever encountered but it still utilises it's formula for freedom as a means of controlling people. It teaches you to question everything even itself, however the relationship is already formed with itself and so is its dependency on the system so finding fault will only cause pain to ones self.
Seeing ones freedom through the eye's of a religion is not freedom it is the acceptance of conditioning and living in denial. Believing in a god as long as it is a personal belief is perfectly acceptable and I would even advocate people to question and be free to choose any belief they feel is going to serve themselves at any given time. I have heard others say it is our freedom to choose this religion or that religion and to express that belief. And that is partly right you are free to choose to believe anything you want including the purple dragon, but that is where your freedom ends. The moment you open your mouth to spread that religion you are controlling other peoples minds, especially if you have children that look up to you, as this is the most powerful way for beliefs to be transmitted to another person. I recognized this when my son was very young, and stopped speaking about my beliefs from a personal point of view and started asking what he thought. Their is nothing cute about conditioning our children to believe as we do.
On the comment about freedom of speech. Its not about the fear to question. Its about the limiting of peoples choices by implanting what they should question and seek for. In a society that isn't dominated by the basic needs for survival do you really think the question of god would come up if people weren't conditioned to believe there is a god? I doubt it very much. In fact the people i've met who haven't been conditioned to believe in god wonder if people have lost their minds. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 12:27:56 PM | Crazylilting:
Non of what i said makes us victims or mindless drones. It is simply how the brain works. You of all people should know this as you are in the mental health profession sassy. If you don't i'd suggest its not me who is afraid to question it is you. I was merely pointing out what I saw as someone using victim consciousness to justify an insatiable desire to disavow others of their belief system as though he has constructed none... placing himself somehow above the same judgments he applies to others...
It is in yours hands as to whether you take my view on as truth or to reject it due to what YOU determine to be true... see how that works crazylilting?? Its called choice and we each have one... regardless of how powerful a message may be...
Yes, to some degree we are all "programed" by our environment/society/family of origin/past experiences, etc... but we also have the ability to question how and in what ways... I would rather focus on that which I DO have control over as opposed to projecting my fears outward onto everyone else as though they should see things my way simply because it would make me feel more comfortable in this world...
Its funny my special someone was doing some research on addictions last night because i am having a difficult time quitting smoking. One of the things that came up was the 'fact' that people need outside sources to take over where abusive people that aren't in their life leave a void. This is where addictions come in, as well as you guessed it religion. Often the latter come into play after being on a self destructive pattern has been established and religion fills that void which is the original void left by abusive controlling people. Addictions are a way to self-medicate for pain that has not been dealt with in healthy ways.... once a person quits their addiction that pain leaks out and threatens to overwhelm unless dealt with and worked through in new and healthy ways...
Many times when a person quits an addiction he turns to religion/spirituality to fill that void he feels inside... to assauge his pain... to find the stability and support he requires at such a raw time... I do not see that as a negative necessarily.. often the person becomes a tad pedantic in the process... but it must be said that it is certainly a more positive direction than that of coping through addictions... and things usually balance out eventually....
If turning to religion/spirituality brings a person who is dealing with pain from the past comfort, then who is to judge? Certainly not I.
Even you sassy have been conditioned, to deny it would be ridiculous. Its just a question of making a mind map to find out what you are conditioned to think. It is my responsibility to look at where that has taken place and to challenge it.... or should I just throw my hands up and accept my indoctrination/socialization while railing at those who forced their views on me?
Many people never individuate... cannot seem to unravel all of the pieces that make them whole and unique so that they become a fully conscious being.. one who KNOWS who he really is... but to imply NONE do is ridiculous in my mind... to deny the power we each have to determine for ourselves that which we believe as well as to direct our own destiny imo is pure victim consciousness... which is precisely what the power mongers feed on ;)
Conditioned people don't see they are conditioned much like someone who is in denial won't see they are in denial. Governments, religions, and advertisers are well aware of these things and so their consultants who specialise in designing the perfect campaign for target audiences that work. True enough, but SOME people see past it... to imply that everyone is a victim to those who are in power is such a defeatest view to me that I sit here incredulous as to what the world must look like to you..
It teaches you to question everything even itself, however the relationship is already formed with itself and so is its dependency on the system so finding fault will only cause pain to ones self. Are you Buddhist?? If not you cannot possibly say that with any kind of confidence.
We only think its ok to spread our beliefs (religions) to others because we are taught that it is our freedom to do so. But it is not freedom, its a compulsion. So the religion and those who transmit the beliefs to others is at fault.. and the poor little victims who bought into it are blameless?? I strongly and thoroughly disagree. Where is their responsibility in the matter?? If I was in an abusive relationship where someone took advantage of me, eventually I will have to take responsibility for the fact that I allowed it or the pattern will inevitably repeat itself... paying attention to that which YOU have control over is the only power you have...
you are free to choose to believe anything you want including the purple dragon, but that is where your freedom ends. The moment you open your mouth to spread that religion you are controlling other peoples minds, especially if you have children that look up to you, as this is the most powerful way for beliefs to be transmitted to another person. I recognized this when my son was very young, and stopped speaking about my beliefs from a personal point of view and started asking what he thought. Their is nothing cute about conditioning our children to believe as we do. Childern are an entirely different story.... to indoctrinate a child is abuse in my mind.. they have not developed enough yet to question and take on anything put foward, especially if it is fear based, BUT you CAN empower a child to question... I tell my children to question even me in spiritual matters if it does not match their inner self... and am proud of them when they stand in their truth even as it differs with my own... the positive feedback they recieve gives them the courage to do it again...
On the comment about freedom of speech. Its not about the fear to question. Its about the limiting of peoples choices by implanting what they should question and seek for. Aint nobody limiting my beliefs unless I agree to it... I know where my freedom lies and I intend to exercise it to the fullest.. you of course have the freedom to do with yours what you will :) | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 12:34:14 PM |
Are you Buddhist?? If not you cannot possibly say that with any kind of confidence.
That makes no sense. I don't need to be a Christian to point out how being told you're a lowly sinner who deserves to burn in hell traumatizes children.
So the religion and those who transmit the beliefs to others is at fault.. and the poor little victims who bought into it are blameless??
Blameless in the sense that it was probably inculcated in them since birth. None of their actions are excused. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 12:41:02 PM |
Are you Buddhist?? If not you cannot possibly say that with any kind of confidence. --->That makes no sense. I don't need to be a Christian to point out how being told you're a lowly sinner who deserves to burn in hell traumatizes children. Your example has NOTHING to do with what was being discussed..
[Buddhism] teaches you to question everything even itself, however the relationship is already formed with itself and so is its dependency on the system so finding fault will only cause pain to ones self. Here crazylilting states that to question the ideas put forth by Buddhism causes pain to the Buddhist.... how could that possibly be known unless he has himself experienced it? | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 12:56:44 PM |
Your example has NOTHING to do with what was being discussed..
That is why it's an example.
Here crazylilting states that to question the ideas put forth by Buddhism causes pain to the Buddhist.... how could that possibly be known unless he has himself experienced it?
Again I refer you to the idea expressed in my example. One doesn't have to take part in order to understand why it would cause pain, just like one doesn't have to be a Christian in order to see why that ideology would cause pain. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 1:37:51 PM |
And the institution of religion feeds directly into those cravings.
You trying to say that atheists or atheistic organizations, do not have those cravings?
That being said, the burden of proof lies with the theist. Everything looks and operates as it would without a god, theism creates a mystery where none exists.
It's a common misconception that atheists claim to have answers for everything. Of course we don't.
Your second statement contradicts the first. There is a lot more mysteries for the atheist then there is for the theist.
It is a well known fact that atheist regimes have slaughtered millions. But they didn't do what they did in the name of atheism.
Over a 170 million people in the 20th century alone by these atheist regimes. I would contest that it wasn't in the name of atheism. The goal was/is to eradicate religion and replace it with atheism which at its core is just another religion. What it speaks volumes about however is the morals or rather lack of them in atheistic regimes. People beaten, tortured and murdered for no reason.
To call oneself an atheist doesn't suggest a certain morality. An atheist can be a fascist, a demagogue, a psychopath.
Interesting how you put that. You saying those are the only choices for an atheist? An atheist can choose to be an angel or a devil or anything in between. His/her morality is changeable and based on whatever the individual wants from life. Every man is a law unto himself and can do as he pleases to the degree his neighbours allow him to get away with it or he has the power to enforce it. Think they call the result, anarchy.
In what way would lack of belief in god cause somebody to hurt another individual?
That should be an easy one to figure out since more people have been hurt by atheists then by the religious when one looks at the statistics. The reality is that for an atheist a reason is not needed to hurt another. "I felt like it" is good enough when you see god in the mirror every morning. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 1:44:54 PM |
Here crazylilting states that to question the ideas put forth by Buddhism causes pain to the Buddhist.... how could that possibly be known unless he has himself experienced it?
This isn't an accurate interpretation. If i can make it clearer i'll try. If you are indoctrinated in any belief system. You identify with it, it becomes part of your story so to say. So the act of questioning the belief would become a self defeating behaviour that depending on how deeply you believe would cause pain. So Even though Buddism says to question even what buddhists teach the buddhist will question it through the frame they have adopted through their belief.
I have experienced a lot in my time thus far, and have looked into many belief systems. Buddhism being one of them. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 1:55:35 PM | You trying to say that atheists or atheistic organizations, do not have those cravings?
I guess you missed the part where I explained that being an atheist is no declaration of immorality. Human beings are innately selfish creatures and religion feeds into that by telling us that the universe was created with us in mind, and that it's possible to know what god wants us to do. The selfishness is already there, religion makes it worse.
Your second statement contradicts the first. There is a lot more mysteries for the atheist then there is for the theist.
No there aren't.. Of course science can't explain everything yet. But the universe looks and works as it would if there were no god. An atheist sees fossils and understands what they are and why they're there. The theist has to come up with an explanation that fits with their already established beliefs.
The theist has to wrap their minds around the question as to why a just and moral god allows babies to be born with heroin addictions.
The theist has to explain why the human body has to many imperfections if we're modeled after god.
Over a 170 million people in the 20th century alone by these atheist regimes. I would contest that it wasn't in the name of atheism. The goal was/is to eradicate religion and replace it with atheism which at its core is just another religion.
Simply incorrect. That's like saying my not believing in flying unicorns led me to kill a man.
And atheism is not a religion.
What it speaks volumes about however is the morals or rather lack of them in atheistic regimes.
Another absolute falsehood. Go and re-read what I said about our morality not coming from religion.
People beaten, tortured and murdered for no reason.
Wait, which is it? Were they tortured because they were religious or for no reason?
Of course in reality the real reason is that those regimes were simply power hungry dictators. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 4:51:08 PM | It's not the gun that kills; it's the person that pulls the trigger. Don't blame religion for all the evils of the world. No, it's not the true evil by any means. You're stereotyping, generalizing and judging those you don't know. It's the sinners and hypocrites that call themselves Christians that cause many of our major problems in our society and throughout the world. They are fools that believe that what ever they do is right because they stand behind a so-called Christian faith. It's about personal gain with no real love or conern for others.
I personally have a belief in a Higher Power. It's just something I feel inside my heart and soul. To each their own. We all have opinions like ass holes, but I don't force my beliefs on others. I could care less what others believe as long has they don't attempt to spread any negative energy in my face then it becomes a personal matter inwhich I will take care of.
A true Christian to me is spreading the word of God through their love for mankind. They don't judge nor would they tell others how they should be living their lives. They have wise words and give good advice, but they tend to their own business and stay out of others.
The tongue really is sharper than a sword and it does hold life and death. I know this for a fact from personal experiences. Some people just need to keep their mouths shut and listen; one will actually learn more from life by doing this when it's called for. Let the fools speak their foolish thoughts, let the sinners continue to sin, let the evileness run rampant...after all, regardless of what one's opinion is or who is right or wrong, we'll all find out when we die. | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 4:56:29 PM |
I could, but don't you think the fact that the large majority of religious people believe in one of the big three monotheisms warrants focus on them?
I think that if you are going condemn religion itself, a reasonable person would be obliged to provide examples stemming from religions other than three monotheisms... especially considering those three all spring from a common source and culture of belief.
But the fact is that such examples are few and far between with other religions, and are generally as incidental in nature as those atrocities folk claim spring from atheism. Non-monotheist, not beleiving that they have the one and only, and existing within a completely different paradigm of beleif than the monotheists, have historically been tolerant of other religions and not inclined to wage war for such reasons. In contrast, virtually the entire history "the monotheisms" is a history of religiously motivated violent atrocity.
If you could provide examples from other beliefs, well, there is an open floor... | |
|
| Religion is the True EVIL in the world Posted: 2/22/2008 5:09:56 PM | wow is it that hard for anyone to accept the fact that everyone has a right to there view on this issue??? i mean ya we're not all gonna agree on this but damn some could write book about there feelings on this...i think if the topic is that big of a deal it should be left alone for the sanity sake.. theres topics i avoid too cause i be ranting and get super defensive if i had to answer questions on my views... calm down people its just the forums...we're all hear to express are feelings on issues and topics but no need to get all upset now... | |
|
|
| Page 3 of 31
|
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31 |
|