online dating service

Free Dating Site    

REGISTER | MAIL/PROFILE | HELP | NOW ONLINE | SEARCH | RATING | FORUMS | SUCCESS STORIES
Plentyoffish dating forums are a place to meet singles and get dating advice or share dating experiences etc. Hopefully you will all have fun meeting singles and try out this online dating thing... Remember that we are the largest 100% free online dating service, so you will never have to pay a dime to meet your soulmate.
     
Show ALL Forums  > Current Events  > Monkey Shirt Racist? Thread Closed      Mod Threads Home login  
Page 5 of 11 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
 Author Thread: Monkey Shirt Racist? Thread Closed
 vicious_vixen

Joined: 7/28/2006
Msg: 101
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 4:33:45 PM

It's not a guilt trip over something your ancestors did, it's an acknowledgement that they did it, so maybe we shouldn't perpetuate the same bullshit on the next generation.


that's exactly my point! slavery and the tradgedy of it has been acknowledged nearly to the point of exhaustion where it has become somewhat whiney. constantly reminding people of said terms and treatment and carrying on protests, using deragatory terms in rap and hip hop, and using the race card as an excuse when something doesn't go someone's way is simply carrying it to a different and obnoxious platform. history should be taught no doubt, yet protesting and publicizing things to a point of ridiculousness isn't helping the cause. why aren't jewish people protesting at every turn? the treatment they received has happened since the dawn of time and the historical tradgedy happened in a more recent time period yet they do not behave in a fanatical or agressive fashion.
 CharlesEdm

Joined: 9/16/2006
Msg: 102
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 4:59:15 PM

that's exactly my point! slavery and the tradgedy of it has been acknowledged nearly to the point of exhaustion where it has become somewhat whiney. constantly reminding people of said terms and treatment and carrying on protests, using deragatory terms in rap and hip hop, and using the race card as an excuse when something doesn't go someone's way is simply carrying it to a different and obnoxious platform. history should be taught no doubt, yet protesting and publicizing things to a point of ridiculousness isn't helping the cause. why aren't jewish people protesting at every turn? the treatment they received has happened since the dawn of time and the historical tradgedy happened in a more recent time period yet they do not behave in a fanatical or agressive fashion.


Actually segregation is more recent than the jewish mistreatment., and you'll find extremely militant Jews as well, in fact a they have their own country.

So now only are you the whining, you're whining isn't even particularly valid.
 jmarquise

Joined: 1/27/2008
Msg: 103
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:05:46 PM

Actually segregation is more recent than the jewish mistreatment., and you'll find extremely militant Jews as well, in fact a they have their own country.

So now only are you the whining, you're whining isn't even particularly valid.


you are right. those democrats really did treat women and minorities like total crap. they should be ashamed of themselves.

on a serious note, most organized religion is evil charles. it is set up like governments. they instill fear and to make people chose sides pitting brother against brother. all they want is your money. maybe now you see why I hate government so much.
 vicious_vixen

Joined: 7/28/2006
Msg: 104
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:07:28 PM
everyone who's debating this issue is whinning and complaining over an issue that will never have an ending. nothing about the t-shirt being offensive is really valid since more people than myself did not see it as comparing a black person to a monkey but rather comparing a politician to one...just like george w. was.



and you'll find extremely militant Jews as well, in fact a they have their own country


so by that standard, any african countries that have violence are "their own country" and are militant extremists? point blank, in the united states, this isn't the case...segregation is not tolerated or thought of in the usa unless people choose it to be. you cannot tell me that jewish people react to things in the united states the same as black people do. i watch american news regularly...more jesse jackson and groups similar to this on the boob tube protesting over trivial things.
 CharlesEdm

Joined: 9/16/2006
Msg: 105
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:10:19 PM
you are right. those democrats really did treat women and minorities like total crap. they should be ashamed of themselves.


They don't have to worry about it anymore, they same places that elected those pro segregation Democratic party members now vote for pro racism southern republicans (you know like in texas) (Hey who was the president that ended segregation anyway?)

and we all know the south is never short on shameful behavior.


on a serious note, most organized religion is evil charles. it is set up like governments. they instill fear and to make people chose sides pitting brother against brother. all they want is your money. maybe now you see why I hate government so much.


Oh I've always known why you dislike government, it doesn't mean I think your right.


so by that standard, any african countries that have violence are "their own country" and are militant extremists?


Um no, thats not what I said, what I said is that your statement about Jews being all fine and dandy with their mistreatment, and never being violent is absurd.



point blank, in the united states, this isn't the case...segregation is not tolerated or thought of in the usa unless people choose it to be.


Yup, now that desegregation was imposed upon the south they are increasingly having to make due with racism on the sly, you know monkey t-shirts for black people that sort of thing.
 jmarquise

Joined: 1/27/2008
Msg: 106
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:27:05 PM

They don't have to worry about it anymore, they same places that elected those pro segregation Democratic party members now vote for pro racism southern republicans (you know like in texas) (Hey who was the president that ended segregation anyway?)

and we all know the south is never short on shameful behavior.


who was the president that ended slavery? whose faces are on mount rushmore? no area is short on shameful behavior, but I would love for you to see where I live. it's the south, but it's full of beach bums. the only thing people around here are racist against are, is sharks. need to get a grasp on those stereotypes.


Oh I've always known why you dislike government, it doesn't mean I think your right.


you don't have to think it's right, but it's valid.

I have a thread about the economy in the south waiting for you. you said some crappy stuff about a region of the country and I posted some information you might like to read.
 whothehellknows

Joined: 7/23/2006
Msg: 107
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:30:09 PM

Norman said he has sold out of his stack of 50 t-shirts. He was planning to donate the money from the shirts to the Muscular Dystrophy Association. But MDA officials said they do not want Norman's money. They said that their attorneys were drawing up a letter asking him to stop using the name of the MDA in connection with sales of the shirts.


This is the saddest part of the article, that people actually bought this trash. But as you can tell by many of the previous posts that many like the shirts. You can't wear the hoods anymore, but apparently T-shirts are okay.

Of course this is in the same state that fought to retain their 'stars and bars' a few years ago while claiming heritage, not hate. No explanation why they changed the state flag to that rag during the Civil Rights Movement as a form of protest. Only later do they defend it as "heritage" when at the time they did not even hide the hate.
 CharlesEdm

Joined: 9/16/2006
Msg: 108
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:33:09 PM

who was the president that ended slavery?


Oddly enough, when he did the south split away to try and maintain it. Odd that huh? Sorry to tell you but the two parties really started reversing their positions on race and being progressive before either of us were born.
 jmarquise

Joined: 1/27/2008
Msg: 109
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 5:54:57 PM

Oddly enough, when he did the south split away to try and maintain it. Odd that huh? Sorry to tell you but the two parties really started reversing their positions on race and being progressive before either of us were born.


the civil war wasn't fought over slavery in my opinion. I have said lots of times that it was the republican party, which currently is evil, were the ones who allowed minorities and women to vote in primaries. can you name something that the republican party has done that has been detrimental to minorities. or better yet, since I am a libertarian, can you name a stance that the libertarians have that is detrimental to minorities?
 Ezzee

Joined: 7/26/2004
Msg: 110
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 6:23:53 PM
Your right, jmarquise. The civil war wasn't about slavery. That was a bi-product of what it was about, but when it comes down to the heart of the matter, the civil war was fought over states rights. That is what the civil war was truly about. Anyone who says the civil war was about slavery is ignorant to the real problems of what the civil war was fought over. That is like saying that the Revolutionary War was fought over Tea.
 vicious_vixen

Joined: 7/28/2006
Msg: 111
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 6:36:10 PM

Um no, thats not what I said, what I said is that your statement about Jews being all fine and dandy with their mistreatment, and never being violent is absurd.


i'm talking about it as an issue in the US, where there are protests over t-shirts, and every other little thing. quite frankly the country to which you are making reference has been violent for centuries. north america has moved far past that stage and it is time for people on both sides to realize that. go nit pick a rap or hip hop artist or something if you feel that strongly about it. go to a neighborhood where the homies call eachother the "N" word and preach to them.
 stillwatersaredeep

Joined: 3/18/2008
Msg: 112
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 7:09:23 PM
Reading this thread was certainly eye opening in regards to white privilege and how we continue to deny racism in America today. The tee-shirt is most certainly racist and is a historically well known mocking of POC and monkeys. For those of you who haven't heard of it, it's not okay to think it's acceptable just because you weren't aware of the racist past.

For those of you who assert that you didn't personally own slaves or hurt POC and believe that if we'd just "drop it" this generation wouldn't remember racism, please rethink that. Martin Luther King Jr and his "I have a dream" speech was just in 1963, less than three years before I was born. I was two years old when he was assassinated. Segregation was within my lifetime and for many of yours as well. Racism is alive and well today; just ask any man of color who drives a nice car how many times he'll be pulled over by the police just to make sure it isn't stolen. Please ask any woman of color shopping at a high-end department store how often security follows her versus her white counterparts. Do you realize how many skin heads and neo-nazi groups are still alive and well in America today? Ask any white person who is married to a POC or has multi-race children how accepted people of color are in current society.

We have come a long way from where we were, but racism is still alive and well and heavily felt by all that are not white. We all have a responsibility to acknowledge it and *not* excuse it nor continue to sweep it under the rug. We can think ourselves blameless, but as long as we deny the real racism that has been and continues to be felt in America, we dishonor any person who isn't white and we (un)knowingly keep segregation alive and well.

Concerning comments that the ceding of the South during the Civil War was not due to slavery is called "revisionist history" is not completely true. Race and slavery were huge reasons for the war based upon the economics of slavery and crop production. Please don't revise history. The least we could do is be honest and own up to our downfalls of our country if we are to be honest and accountable.

I find it pretty sad that two of the best comments that jumped out in this thread were by men who are not American, yet see it for what it is and don't excuse it. That would be the madfiddler and charlesEdm.
 trubblemakr

Joined: 4/29/2006
Msg: 113
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 7:43:21 PM
but racism is still alive and well and heavily felt by all that are not white. We all have a responsibility to acknowledge it and *not* excuse it nor continue to sweep it under the rug
---------------------------
umm this is a sweeping comment here and had to comment
it isnt just non whites that get sterotyped or" racist " comments and actions against them
whites as well are victims of racial and cultural biasses and attacks ,

--------------------------
We can think ourselves blameless, but as long as we deny the real racism that has been and continues to be felt in America, we dishonor any person who isn't white and we (un)knowingly keep segregation alive and well.
------------------------------------
i know your from the united states and all but for your information that isnt the beginning and end of the civilized world, all this america this and america that shows you are basically only concerned for " america" . realistically " this america " you refer to doesnt exist, and wouldnt exist unless the rest of the world allowed it to . today the hype is about a monkey being used to signify the attack on a black/brown wanna be president , but it wasnt that long ago when the " americans" were all up in arms with derogatory insults and racist comments about muslims. iraquis etc
blaming the 9/11 thing on evil muslims and all the rash of propaganda spewn out thru media etc.
it isnt thru acceptance of these pathetic behaviours that a culture grows but thru the destruction and non acceptance by the vast majority that a culture grows, i dont recall any americans signing petitions to stop the bigotry and racism aimed at iraquis or saudis or iranians even to this day , maybe this little act of bigotry against a man running for presidency will push him to drive the racist ideology from the american hearts and in turn create a better neighbor to the south
since the united states was formed upon slavery and racism id say its high time to make a drastic change

it wasnt that long ago that toronto was trying to create all black schools
talk about a resurgence in segrgation
 LoonyTunz

Joined: 8/11/2006
Msg: 114
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 8:06:07 PM

I do find it ironic that Pres.Bush was compared to a chimp and nobody complained.


Yes, a monkey he had the misfortune of sharing a name with. To be clear, I don't think thats really ok either, but it isn't racially charged.

So it is only racist if the target is of african heritage? How quaint and racist. Do african people nned special protection due to some sort of inferiority? I don't think so, atleast any that I know are pretty much the same as anyone else of any other background.

I'm talking about cultural and historical realities, and some people who don't want to face them. You're claiming that a white adult male dressed up with a white hood and a white robe couldn't be construed to have a different meaning then a black kid in a cheap ghost costume.

You compare apples and oranges here. How many adult males of any group at all are going to "dress up as a ghost" in such a costume?
By your logic a poor white kid should not be allowed to dress up as a ghost because someone may misconstrue his intend and have their feelings hurt. The kids would be responsible for neither what some other group did with that image or your perception of what their intent was.
As Freud said, "Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar."

I'm sure a wealthy upper class person who was the freaking wife of the president REALLY can speak for the poor black population.

Now this is just sickening. Robbing people of their individuality by lumping them all together like that. Tribalism combined with a victim mentality at its' worst.
Here is a newsflash for you. One poor black person will study hard to get scholarships and better his or her life, another with look to crime as a source of an easy buck, another may use sports or music as a means to get ahead and yet another may be quiet content without a great deal of material things but a rich family life..... They're all just people like you and me, with the same diversity.

Hmmm, I suppose you think that, if I work with a black man named James that insists everyone call him "Jim", only fellow members of the same ethnicity may call him "Jim" as others using that name MIGHT be referring to "Jim Crow".

Sorry still thinking the shirt may have been insensitive, but that doesn't mean it must be racist.
 stillwatersaredeep

Joined: 3/18/2008
Msg: 115
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 8:41:14 PM

but racism is still alive and well and heavily felt by all that are not white. We all have a responsibility to acknowledge it and *not* excuse it nor continue to sweep it under the rug
---------------------------
umm this is a sweeping comment here and had to comment
it isnt just non whites that get sterotyped or" racist " comments and actions against them
whites as well are victims of racial and cultural biasses and attacks ,


Oh, I agree with you that whites experience discrimination too. I'm in the position of being of two races, so I've personally felt discrimination from both sides. It took me awhile as a kid to even attempt to figure it out.

However, what I've felt is absolutely nothing compared to a POC. That's what "white privilege" refers to. It's the knowledge that we can never even pretend to know the depths of what people of color experience, and it's very narcissistic to think that we can.


--------------------------
We can think ourselves blameless, but as long as we deny the real racism that has been and continues to be felt in America, we dishonor any person who isn't white and we (un)knowingly keep segregation alive and well.
------------------------------------
i know your from the united states and all but for your information that isnt the beginning and end of the civilized world, all this america this and america that shows you are basically only concerned for " america" . realistically " this america " you refer to doesnt exist, and wouldnt exist unless the rest of the world allowed it to . today the hype is about a monkey being used to signify the attack on a black/brown wanna be president , but it wasnt that long ago when the " americans" were all up in arms with derogatory insults and racist comments about muslims. iraquis etc


Yes I am an American and based my entire comment and interaction on this thread based upon an American Presidential candidate and American history of racism which is what this thread was based upon. I was not U.S centric because I think we're the "end all" as you suggest, but because I understand the country that I live in and have my entire life. I don't think America is the best and only truth out there and frankly wish I were a Canadian, so you can put to rest the assumptions that I favor where I live.


blaming the 9/11 thing on evil muslims and all the rash of propaganda spewn out thru media etc.
it isnt thru acceptance of these pathetic behaviours that a culture grows but thru the destruction and non acceptance by the vast majority that a culture grows, i dont recall any americans signing petitions to stop the bigotry and racism aimed at iraquis or saudis or iranians even to this day , maybe this little act of bigotry against a man running for presidency will push him to drive the racist ideology from the american hearts and in turn create a better neighbor to the south
since the united states was formed upon slavery and racism id say its high time to make a drastic change


"POC" stands for people of color which also means the Muslims that have experienced discrimination stateside. Lets add to that Native Americans which we stole the land from and immigrants from Latin America who are called terrible things on a regular basis.

If you're insinuating that I'm racist or against any minority in America, rethink it. Racism is a world wide problem and it extends to many groups. I'll restate: white privilege is alive and well, regardless of country.


it wasnt that long ago that toronto was trying to create all black schools
talk about a resurgence in segrgation


I heard about that and frankly was very surprised coming from my neighbors to the North!
 vicious_vixen

Joined: 7/28/2006
Msg: 116
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 9:02:29 PM
Trustees with the Toronto District School Board have voted to approve an "operational model" for an Afrocentric school, a controversial plan to help struggling black students in the city's education system.... 22 Black groups, which calls itself the Coalition of African Canadians, cites the following
reasons for calling for major changes to the staus quo::
(1) Out of more than 60 homicides in the GTA this year, a record 41 have
involved a firearm. Black community leaders say that 90% of the homicides
have involved blacks.
(2) Large numbers of black youths have dropped out or been expelled from
schools.
(3) Blacks believe they are one of the most underserviced, underemployed,
poverty-stricken, and racially-victimized groups in the GTA.

(4) Society is already segregated for certain groups such as aboriginals
and francophones who have been granted their own schools and services.


these groups ask for the segregation...the "white man" isn't enforcing it!

Today we know with certainty that segregation is dead. The only question
remaining is how costly will be the funeral. ~Martin Luther King Jr.
 Miniwheatswheatswheats

Joined: 4/24/2008
Msg: 117
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 10:26:12 PM
This thread has reminded me why it's pointless to argue on the Internet.

The most annoying, though, has got to be people like LooneyTunz, who come in and post without reading at least some of the thread and bring up points that have been clearly refuted already, Good God...I'm outta here.
 CharlesEdm

Joined: 9/16/2006
Msg: 118
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 11:05:59 PM

the civil war wasn't fought over slavery in my opinion. I have said lots of times that it was the republican party, which currently is evil, were the ones who allowed minorities and women to vote in primaries. can you name something that the republican party has done that has been detrimental to minorities. or better yet, since I am a libertarian, can you name a stance that the libertarians have that is detrimental to minorities?


Ron Paul has stated that the south should have been allowed to leave and continue slavery and that the civil acts right was wrong.

He is also a member of the republican party.

thats two counts.

As for the south leaving over something besides slavery, look at the southern states various declarations of independence.
http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/csa/scarsec.htm

It talks about state rights alright, the state right to slavery.

So once again, the democratic party used to be the party of slavery and racism. The republicans have long since taken up the mantel.
 sarabara24

Joined: 2/19/2008
Msg: 119
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 11:42:24 PM

these groups ask for the segregation...the "white man" isn't enforcing it!

betcha all your facts were written by the "white man."
 CharlesEdm

Joined: 9/16/2006
Msg: 120
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/15/2008 11:49:20 PM
Trustees with the Toronto District School Board have voted to approve an "operational model" for an Afrocentric school, a controversial plan to help struggling black students in the city's education system.... 22 Black groups, which calls itself the Coalition of African Canadians, cites the following
reasons for calling for major changes to the staus quo::
(1) Out of more than 60 homicides in the GTA this year, a record 41 have
involved a firearm. Black community leaders say that 90% of the homicides
have involved blacks.
(2) Large numbers of black youths have dropped out or been expelled from
schools.
(3) Blacks believe they are one of the most underserviced, underemployed,
poverty-stricken, and racially-victimized groups in the GTA.
(4) Society is already segregated for certain groups such as aboriginals
and francophones who have been granted their own schools and services.


How fun, now instead of talking about the historical realities now you're talking how people of colour are currently strugling. Of course this has nothing to do with the subject of the racist t-shirt, but hey, it's all about moving those goal posts!


So it is only racist if the target is of african heritage? How quaint and racist. Do african people nned special protection due to some sort of inferiority? I don't think so, atleast any that I know are pretty much the same as anyone else of any other background.


Hey loonytunes, I'll reply to your posts when they actually discuss what I'm saying, I enver said anything about black traits, I'm discussing HISTORY, and SOCIAL REALITIES.


Now this is just sickening. Robbing people of their individuality by lumping them all together like that. Tribalism combined with a victim mentality at its' worst.
Here is a newsflash for you. One poor black person will study hard to get scholarships and better his or her life, another with look to crime as a source of an easy buck, another may use sports or music as a means to get ahead and yet another may be quiet content without a great deal of material things but a rich family life..... They're all just people like you and me, with the same diversity.


Wow what a great completely irrelevant post, I was talking about a first lady saying "nobody can make you feel inferior unless you let them" and now you're giving me some pathetic feel good message about people.

Some people are so wound up at the idea that white people have it soooooo bad, that they can't even acknowledge when a racist dick down in georgia is putting racist imagery up on a fucking t-shirt.

Realities.

1. Racist groups historically stated that Blacks were closer to Monkeys and apes than humans in order to justify their mistreatment and slavery.

2. Modern racist groups still make derogatory statements about people of african descent comparing them to monkeys and apes.

3. Somebody in a state known for it's racist heritage produces a shirt comparing a black man to a monkee.

4. A bunch of white people come on here saying how it's not racist. It IS racist but freedom of speech is AOK. and WONT SOMEBODY PLEASE THINK OF THE POOR WHITE PEOPLE WHO HAVE IT SO HARD IN NORTH AMERICA.

5. You accuse *me* of racism because I don't ignore facts 1-3 in order to fit into your white washed fantasy land of racial utopia that is the united states. Loony, you're fucking way off base. I'm not talking about anything inate to blacks and whites, I'm talking about history.
 stillwatersaredeep

Joined: 3/18/2008
Msg: 121
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/16/2008 12:53:08 AM
I heard about that and frankly was very surprised coming from my neighbors to the North!
Maybe your hearing is a bit off as you seem to have missed the part where it states the black community wants black only schools so as to teach black curriculum. Black history, black social skills etc. . Or maybe you conveniently decided not to add that part to make it seem whites want to foot the bill just to keep our kids safe and the black population down trodden.


Well perhaps your hearing is a little off as I do understand that it's the poc themselves who asked for it and did not make the assumption they were being white repressed. Saying neighbors to the north and being surprised didn't mean "white." I didn't feel I should comment earlier on something I don't know enough about to form opinions or make commentary's about. I was surprised when I first read about it some months back as I didn't realize that there were problems of that magnitude there.



Native Americans which we stole the land from.
Shame on you stealing is wrong. They lost the war back then but are winning the new one as mainstream society doesn't even know it exists. We in Canada have new landclaims almost weekly by Indians. The province of British Columbia has native landclaim suites totaling over triple it's landmass. They pay no taxes, we have about 1million natives who get 12billion dollars anually plus from the federal government. We build their free housing. We build them businesses wich they build in urban areas to compete with the other businesses except the indians pay no land, income, business,payroll or other taxes. This is actually forcing their competitors to fund the native business through taxation. They have the gaming rights and the casinos make good money. Yet they still want more and everytime they claim racism if we don't buckle soon enough. They have taken up arms against the country, barricaded our road, blocked rail lines, and gone against say this is all because the white man owes them. But that of course wouldn't be racism. Just like your KKK is racist but not the NAACP, puzzling that thinking.


Interesting to read. How does this change the fact, though, that Native Americans in the states had massive losses of land, life and liberty? And also, where have I stated that minorities don't make mistakes or have anger, too? Still, whites are just never gonna get it and we we still have a responsibility to acknowledge the past and that present racism does still exist.


Every society or nearly every society has at one time in their history had slaves. I belive Andrew Jackson was a slave at one time or was it one of your other presidents?
Why is it only in North America that we are forced to subdue those who's forefathers upheld slavery? Does anyone know, of the blacks who captured people in India and used them as slaves in the mines, how many of their ancestors are made to submit to the Indian peoples to try and raise them above a level they themselves can reach.


Yep, slavery is one of the oldest human rights violations known to man kind. Still doesn't negate recent racism problems in the states. Twelve of our presidents owned slaves at some point in their lives and eight of them owned slaves while serving as president.


I'm not even American and i'm still being punished by blacks who never went through slavery nor segregation because i have white skin. But hey you can't be racist against a middle aged white male in Canada it isn't possible because we are the only racists who exist in this country.
Note i use the word racist in protest because i believe we are talking about bigotry not racism. Racism to me is mearly an acknowledgement that there are different physical and cultural characeristics unique to different races or peoples as i preffer to call them. Bigotry on the other hand is an unsubstantiated hatred of other persons based mainly on ignorance and mistrust either learned or inferred.


Racism means more than the above:

Definitions

While the term racism usually denotes race-based prejudice, violence, discrimination, or oppression, the term can also have varying and hotly contested definitions. Racialism is a related term, sometimes intended to avoid these negative meanings. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, racism is a belief or ideology that all members of each racial group possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially to distinguish it as being either superior or inferior to another racial group or racial groups. The Merriam-Webster's Dictionary defines racism as a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular racial group, and that it is also the prejudice based on such a belief. The Macquarie Dictionary defines racism as: "the belief that human races have distinctive characteristics which determine their respective cultures, usually involving the idea that one's own race is superior and has the right to rule or dominate others."[citation needed]

[edit] Legal definition

According to the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination,

the term "racial discrimination" shall mean any distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference based on race, colour, descent, or national or ethnic origin which has the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment or exercise, on an equal footing, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural or any other field of public life. '[1]
 Twistability

Joined: 2/13/2008
Msg: 122
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/16/2008 2:48:15 AM
I think it's unfortunate that the animal in question is a monkey because of the racist reference to black people being likened to monkeys

But wtf .. He does look like curious george!!!

And George W looks like one of the pg tips chimps
 AceOfSpace

Joined: 5/28/2007
Msg: 123
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/16/2008 3:12:23 AM
Here's the thing. The tendency to regard others who seem different with disdain is natural. We all have it.

We are hard-wired to instinctively favor those who appear to be similar to ourselves, because those who favor their own genes tent to propagate better than those who don't.

However, just because it is natural doesn't make it moral. I also have instinctive urges to go out and kill people who I believe might be a threat to me or my family. However, I think we all agree that things would go downhill pretty fast if we all acted on those urges, and that I would be a rather bad citizen if I went around doing that.

Like the urge to kill--which is perfectly natural as part of our instinctive heritage--the urge to exclude those who seem different is another one that leads to evil acts whenever it is left unchecked.

It doesn't matter who does it or what their excuse is. Anyone who tries to encourage, justify, or cover up an attitude of disdain (which I think is a more accurate term than "prejudice"), is at best practicing bad citizenship and at worst promoting evil.

It can sometimes require a bit of self-restraint to refrain from acting on a natural urge like that, even when we know that to do so would be evil. Yet, that is what we expect of each other and we are well within our rights to do so.

So, while it might be wrong for the descendents of Black slaves to regard all White people with disdain, that does not excuse any White person who attempts to make light of the ugly images that were once used to reinforce an institutionalized attitude of disdain directed againt Blacks.

White people who take glee in reviving those images, are indulging in criminality. It would be like members of the Manson Family wearing T-shirts that said, "they deserved it."

It's just as sick, and just as evil.

The fact that racist images were once commonplace just makes it all the more ugly.

You don't have to be Black or Liberal to reject such evil when you see it. We don't when it comes to murder. If you're smart, you won't wait until the disdain is pointed at you and becomes institutionalized before you speak out against it. Institutionalized disdain is ... well ... tyranny.

The only people who like to promote a climate of disdain are the ones who fancy themselves in the role of a tyrant. Isn't that what those slavemasters were, when it comes right down to it?
 REBEL2080

Joined: 5/1/2008
Msg: 124
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/16/2008 4:19:33 AM
Doesn't anyone feel sorry for the monkey? I mean being compared to Obama? How do you think he feels? Sorry George.
 Ezzee

Joined: 7/26/2004
Msg: 125
view profile
History
Monkey Shirt Racist?
Posted: 5/16/2008 4:37:51 AM
So I think after 5+ pages of discussion now, the conclusion can be made that everyone has their own views on this and whether or not it is racism. It's kind of like porn, I guess. What may be porn to one person may be art to another. There is no clear cut definition, and all attempt in order to provide one just leaves more questions. As I have stated before, I personally think this is more of a statement of Barrack Hussein Obama's political thoughts and him as a politician. This has nothing to do with the color of his skin.

On an interesting side note, I took a class in college called "Race and American Politics." The professor of this class, easily my favorite professor throughout my college career, made the statement that everyone is racist. It didn't matter if you were white, black, Asian, or indigenous. He backed up this claim by asking this question. "When you see someone, what is the first thing you notice about them?" It isn't there hair, their eyes, there face, or anything like that. He argued that the first thing that a person notices about another individual when they see them is the color of the skin, and that right there is racism. I think he had an excellent point, and one that I tend to agree with.

The last interesting point I'd like to bring up is that I think that this thread is also proving how this election is not and never will be about the issues. Sadly to say, in the 2008 election, it is all about things that shouldn't matter. Sadly, thanks to Barrack Hussein Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton, this entire election is being turned into a three-ring circus of sex, race, and religion. It is sad that we can't have an election on the issues, and it is even more pathetic that we can't get past this entire race thing when we consider everything including the kitchen sink to somehow be "racist."
Page 5 of 11 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
 
Show ALL Forums  > Current Events  > Monkey Shirt Racist? Thread Closed