| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/9/2007 9:37:08 AM | http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070209/ap_on_he_me/flu_masks
Students wear masks to try to stop flu Thu Feb 8, 8:06 PM ET ANN ARBOR, Mich. - Hundreds of students on the University of Michigan campus are part of a research study that could change the way the world looks at influenza.
Researchers are trying to determine whether wearing surgical masks and hand sanitizing can prevent the spread of flu or other respiratory illnesses.
There's only one public place in his residence hall where Ken Miguel doesn't wear a surgical mask — the cafeteria.
"It's kind of hard to eat with this thing on," the University of Michigan freshman said recently from behind the blue mask. "It's kind of hard to do a lot of things with this on."
But every day, Miguel, 18, wears the mask while he studies, does laundry and sprints to class. It's gets a little uncomfortable, but it's for a good cause, he says.
Flu hit the university late last month and students in the study have since been divided into three groups: those who only wear masks; those who wear masks and use hand sanitizer; and those who do neither.
They'll fill out surveys every week, answering questions about their physical health and how often they wear the mask, which is optional outside the residence halls. The students will wear the masks until the flu outbreak has died down, but no longer than six weeks, the researchers said.
Funded by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the research is the first of its kind, said Dr. Allison Aiello, a Michigan epidemiology professor who designed the study with principal investigator Dr. Arnold Monto.
Scientists say the world is long overdue for a deadly flu epidemic, one that could emerge if the bird flu in Asia mutates to spread easily among people. A pandemic could kill millions of people. Right now there's not enough research to determine whether wearing masks and washing hands would be effective during such an event, Aiello said.
U.S. health officials have made no recommendation about wearing face masks. The government is stockpiling a vaccine officials hope would be effective against a pandemic flu strain but there isn't enough. Cotton masks and hand sanitizer could be a first line of defense.
"We know the clock is ticking, we just don't know when the alarm will go off," said Dr. William Schaffner, chairman of the Department of Preventive Medicine at Vanderbilt University. "We already know there's going to be regular influenza annually, and even that's enough to grab our attention."
The results of the Michigan study "will be widely discussed, no matter the outcome," he said.
Schaffner says the study has important "real life" circumstances at its base. College dormitories, where students eat, sleep and study together, are the perfect breeding ground for airborne illnesses, he said.
In Alice Lloyd Hall, one of the dorms chosen for the study, masked students can be seen behind the front desk, hurrying down hallways and studying. About 1,200 students on campus were signed up as of last Wednesday, and more are recruited every day.
For participating, they can receive $100, an incentive for many college students.
Several students acknowledged they're only doing it for the money. Miguel said he'll save the cash for a trip to Peru this summer, while Alicja Sobilo, 18, said she's going shopping.
Some worry that the students aren't taking the science seriously.
"The importance of this research isn't a message that seems to be getting to all of them," said Allison Sponseller, 22, a resident adviser and study recruiter. "My biggest concern is in a week they will all forget about it and stop wearing the masks."
But Schaffner says that's one of the study's advantages.
"That actually will add to the real life aspect of it," he said. "Those of us involved in real life public health know that we can never achieve perfection — it's what we can do in a semi-controlled environment."
Aiello said the researchers are also hoping to get information on how students feel about the masks — whether wearing them is "socially acceptable."
So far, it doesn't look good for the masks. Students say they're "goofy-looking," inconvenient or just plain annoying.
"I wouldn't wear it outside the hall," said Jeff Van Laere, 20. "But I feel obligated to wear it in here. We know how important it is when we sign up for it and we honor that. I'm getting paid for this commitment."
This should be interesting.... most aspects of this (wearing a surgical mask and washing hands) seem very obvious that it will protect those students from the flu... but I don't think it has been shown in the real world to help, even though in the hospital it is common practice for certain diseases to prevent the spread between patients. Will have to keep an eye on it..... | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/9/2007 9:47:49 AM | OMG................................LMOL
Hell NO!!!
People are so stupied at times.
Now in a hospital enviostupides, but I have heard of people wearing one at work and at the mall.
OK...OK I can also see it if they have a health problem, themselves and catching the flu could be a very serious thing in their life.
But, people that are afraid of dieing never seam to live. People that fear being hurt never seam to love.
Nough said | |
|
LBP
| Joined: 12/27/2006 Msg: 3 | |
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/9/2007 11:55:21 AM |
But, people that are afraid of dieing never seam to live
Very true. I'd do it but only if there were serious reasons to like SARS was going around or something to prevent a deadly epidemic.
I think its probably over all more healthy to expose yourself to viral infections though because it builds your immunity. | |
|
| |
| |
1Kam
| Joined: 1/15/2007 Msg: 6 | |
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/10/2007 10:48:07 PM | I didn't wear a mask when SARS hit my part of the country, why the hell would I wear one for the flu?
What can't kill you makes you stronger. | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/11/2007 2:50:19 PM | I don't mind wearing a mask at Halloween... so I don't see why I'd mind wearing one for avoiding plague and pestilence. I'd prefer it not be a surgical mask though... I'd rather have something more interesting/colorful. Now I'm imagining going to the mall and everyone is wearing these cool masks... wild and colorful. | |
|
| |
| |
| |
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/12/2007 12:17:56 AM | There's a new thing that you can do to not get influenza, it's called immunization! I worked in a hospital for over 20 years and have not had the flu since I started getting the shot in 1988. Does it work? Methinks so..... | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/12/2007 11:30:04 AM | I have to agree with the previous poster. I, too, work in a hospital, more specifically in the Emergency Room. I get my flu shot every year, and I do not get the flu.
It would be more effective if Americans were more respectful, like the Asian cultures. When Someone is sick & ventures out of their house, THEY should wear a mask to prevent the spread of germs. Or better yet, they should just STAY HOME! | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/12/2007 3:40:06 PM | | Unfortunately, the flu shot is only good for 3 viruses that the experts think might be a problem for that year.... some years they get it right, other years not. The other problem is that that vaccination isn't available to everyone (at least in Canada).... different groups of people are given preferrence, depending on their risk factors like age (very young and old), other health problems (HIV status, transplant patients), profession (front-line health care workers) and a few other things. I think the US has similar criterion... but don't quote me on that! | |
|
| |
| |
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 2/13/2007 11:19:28 AM | | When one is sick with a transmitable disease I think they should do whatever possible not to infect others. The trouble is what do u do, and when? This is an interesting study for me as I have been under the impression that wearing a mask will substantially reduce transmission especially if the infected person is wearing one. I look forward to seeing what they conclude. | |
|
| |
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 3/9/2007 10:10:12 AM | | No I would not for the simple fact this would weaken your immune system and you would have to wear it all the time. Which would be majorly uncomfortable. | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 3/9/2007 10:20:58 AM | Flawed study design. Had the investigators used hand/sanitizing PLUS behavioral mods (reducing touching hands to face transmission of flu virus, etc) as an group to compare to the mask only study group, it would have been a useful study.
In fact, it probably would have shown that wearing masks at best provides a limited improvement in reducing flu virus exposure. | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 3/9/2007 12:50:10 PM | Sounds like a good study, hand washing/sanitizing will win, I'll bet. We're oblivious to just how many times we touch something and then touch our nose or eyes or lips -- obvious vectors for the flu bug.
Too bad they didn't include (white cotton) glove wearing too, as that's a pretty solid substitute for hand washing/sanitizing. (most pharmacies stock them)
Flu hit the university late last month and students in the study have since been divided into three groups: those who only wear masks; those who wear masks and use hand sanitizer; and those who do neither. | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 7/19/2008 12:00:08 PM | Well, I get a flu shot every year, and it seems the strain of flu I get isn't covered by that particular shot. Go figure! I stay home, away from people, and in bed until it passes.
It seems that the university students are experimenting to see what, if anything if more effective. Good luck to them.  | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 7/19/2008 2:38:34 PM | | I wear a mask because I am hideous and don't like to shock children. One of the side effects has been that I haven't had a cold or the flu since before I was an adoloescent. | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 7/19/2008 2:58:30 PM | I remember several years ago I had to go to Toronto for a family emergency and at that time there was a minor SARS outbreak. To go inside the hospital you had to wear a mask and use some type of antibacterial disinfectant lotion on your hands. It was quite nerve recking and all I can think was catching this flu.
So, in these rare events I would wear a mask to prevent from getting ill.
Oh by the way, after I came home back to the states. My job gave me a week off with pay because they were nervous that I might have had some contact with SARS. I thought it was funny, but awesome too....Free vacation. | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 7/19/2008 3:32:50 PM | Nope!
We already live in a World overdosing on Fear.
Of course, IF and WHEN the epidemic does hit us, then of course perhaps wearing a mask or taking some kind of precaution is logical.
But in the mean time, I intend to get on with my Life normally thanks very much! | |
|
| Would you wear a mask to prevent the flu? Posted: 7/20/2008 3:14:02 PM | No, I wouldn't. The ONE thing that I know seriously affects my immune system is stress, and a lot of that stress comes from worry. If I start wearing a mask as a result of worrying about catching the flu, then that is going to weaken my immune system severely, and that will mean my body would be far more weakened to protect itself than if I had not worn the mask in the first place.
I've caught pneumonia twice, and both times it was when I was under stress. Conversely, I've been exposed to an epidemic of hepatitis, but at the time, I was enjoying my life, and I never caught it, even though over 200 people at the same place did. I don't want to increase my chances of getting pneumonia again, and the best way I can see to do that is to take sensible precautions, and be happy. Sensible precautions include not shaking hands with someone after they've just got snot all over their hands, and having lots of vitamin C to give my body what it needs to fight the infection. | |
|