|
|
|
|
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 11:50:13 AM | I am here for a text review, I am well aware that I need more AND better pictures. If you just can't help yourself, please feel free to mention it, but it's not going to be news to me. I have attemped to add some humor. I am curious how many perceive it to be humorous, and how many do not?
Thank you for your time, I do appreciate ALL comments, whether they be positive or negative.
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 11:58:35 AM | You need some better pics. Sorry, I could HELP it!
Your headline makes me think of psychedelic mushrooms. Those are the only ones I ever heard referred to as "shrooms." Do you mean wild mushrooms? Why not hunt for, oh, I don't know, pinecones instead? Most parts ARE edible. Remember Eulle Gibbons, the health fanatic? He's dead now.
Your comments about swimming -- okay. Your comments about not taking off your hat made me think a) you're possibly bald, or b) you can't remove your hat because it's actually grown into the skin of your head. Can you say you just LIKE wearing hats, maybe?
You kind of veer off into strange territory when you talk about marriage. Is it really necessary to mention it in your dating profile? Seemed a little cart-before-the-horse to me.
Also, your requirements -- as I understood them -- is that she either be widowed with no children OR have well-behaved children with no shared custody. Had a bad experience with the latter? Not all situations like that are horrible scenes, you know. Quite a lot of people manage to get on with their exes quite civilly for the sake of the kids. I'm just sayin.'
First date -- pretty interesting. I have no problem envisioning a hiking-rock climbing-nature-oriented woman wanting to go do those things with you. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 12:05:43 PM | I think it has just enough humor for a good chuckle. I find it difficult to read a complete profile when someone is trying to make every statement funny. I see nothing wrong with your pics. Just get a few more and yes, even one without your hat. I know how difficult that is. I call my camo hat "my hair" and I hate to leave home without it.
Now, if you only knew and understood what a powerful "virus" the horse passion is..... But I guess it's OK for me to dream! | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 12:15:30 PM | Generally, it seems like a toned-down version of "written by hank" profile. It is quirky and conveys your personality well.
A few text formatting issues - wrong words, spacing not quite right, punctuation that is not completely correct. In a way, it is charming in some of its imperfections, much like a cozy country house is charming as compared to ultra-modern electronics-filled penthouse.
Humor is gentle and generally works for me. Some situations can use a bit more humor to diffuse the preferences. E.g, you talking about how you like to be on water, but not in water. It comes a little over-demanding. Changing that sentence to says something like "...at least 35 years; and, unless a giant catfish pulls me overboard, have no intention of starting now." The hat passage that was mentioned by Ursula is another such case.
Agree about woman requirement situation. Seems a little strict. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 12:40:51 PM | Overall, I liked it.
As mentioned, more pictures, we want to see if you're bald ; ) Post more if possible.
I liked the humor you've instilled, just enough without sounding corny or anything. Good there and the interest section.
I agree with the other 2 reviewers about the lady's requirements coming off too strongly, sounded a tad barbaric to me. JMO
Thumbs up on the first date section, you made that sound interesting.
Good luck | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 12:42:42 PM | You need some better pics. Sorry, I could HELP it!
Why does this not surprise me.
Your headline makes me think of psychedelic mushrooms. Those are the only ones I ever heard referred to as "shrooms." Do you mean wild mushrooms? Why not hunt for, oh, I don't know, pinecones instead? Most parts ARE edible. Remember Eulle Gibbons, the health fanatic? He's dead now.
Ok, I am certainly NOT into the psycho stuff. Yes, I have hunting mushrooms in my interest section. I don't happen to live where there are many pinecones or the chancas are good I would hut those as well. I am not familiar with that name.
Your comments about swimming -- okay. Your comments about not taking off your hat made me think a) you're possibly bald, or b) you can't remove your hat because it's actually grown into the skin of your head. Can you say you just LIKE wearing hats, maybe?
I could, but it was an attempt at humor. I will place you in the NONHUMOROUS column. lol
You kind of veer off into strange territory when you talk about marriage. Is it really necessary to mention it in your dating profile? Seemed a little cart-before-the-horse to me.
Ok,point taken,the reason this is in there is that I know from past experience that a woman that has children is VERY unlikely to even come remotely close to agreeing with me on discipline. Substantually less than 1% from past experience, and this is from a data base of over 800 that I have "talked to" in the last three years. I will consider removing. But the reason I put it in there in the first place, was because some got upset that I didn't spell those conditions up front.
Also, your requirements -- as I understood them -- is that she either be widowed with no children OR have well-behaved children with no shared custody. Had a bad experience with the latter? Not all situations like that are horrible scenes, you know. Quite a lot of people manage to get on with their exes quite civilly for the sake of the kids. I'm just sayin.'
Ok,I will need to revise this. Widows would certainly be allowed to have children. I will clarify. It goes a little deeper than simply "getting along with the ex". The children get "shuffeled" back and forth. One set of rules this weekend,another set the next weekend. Not to mention,as I did state, If I am to become a part of a childs life, I want to be their father not their step father, I simply do not want to share parenting duties.
First date -- pretty interesting. I have no problem envisioning a hiking-rock climbing-nature-oriented woman wanting to go do those things with you.
Thank you for your insight, any follow up comments will also be considered.
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 12:48:02 PM | Thank you for your input! The hat "joke" might ned to go though. It is not very popular so far.
Best wishes
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:00:22 PM |
Generally, it seems like a toned-down version of "written by hank" profile. It is quirky and conveys your personality well.
Yes Yev, you may have missed it, but I did say on his post that he took a very similar approach as I did.
A few text formatting issues - wrong words, spacing not quite right, punctuation that is not completely correct. In a way, it is charming in some of its imperfections, much like a cozy country house is charming as compared to ultra-modern electronics-filled penthouse.
Very insightful, (was not intentional) do you recommend correcting? Or staying with "cozy"?
Humor is gentle and generally works for me. Some situations can use a bit more humor to diffuse the preferences. E.g, you talking about how you like to be on water, but not in water. It comes a little over-demanding. Changing that sentence to says something like "...at least 35 years; and, unless a giant catfish pulls me overboard, have no intention of starting now." The hat passage that was mentioned by Ursula is another such case.
I like this! Thanks Yev!
Agree about woman requirement situation. Seems a little strict.
I realize it is very strict, my problem is that I have some VERY deeply held views on discipline that are VERY nearly a thing of the past. Unfortunately, it is VERY uncommom for me to see children that I would be "proud to call my own". I simply do not want to live with what I consider disrespectful children. Therefore my hands are pretty much tied.
Thank you for your insight.
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:07:20 PM | Suggestion (just 'cause it popped into my head)
"Nature Nut - let's go spy on snakes!"
I assume you shortened to "shrooms" due to the character restriction, but Ursula is quite right that is has certain specific connotations.
Aside from that, I have nothing to add beyond what the others have said. I like your writing style, it seems to convey your personality well. The few tweaks suggested should help iron out the few weak areas.
Cheers!  | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:07:30 PM |
"I agree with the other 2 reviewers about the lady's requirements coming off too strongly, sounded a tad barbaric to me. JMO
I have been wrestling with this issue for as long as I have been searching. I have been told this many times. I wish I could change it,unfortunately,I can't, it is who I am. My only other alternative is to drop it, and then need to explain to 95% of the ladies that contact me why we are not compatible. Do you think this would be the better option?
Thank you for your insight.
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:16:15 PM | Haha, I always love the chance to rip apart a fellow friend! Strap on yer slickers and a ball gag, this may get sticky.
Okay, it probably won’t but I wanted to set the stage at least! So the profile… let’s start from the top. I’ve been meaning to ask you this, but is there a reason it’s spelled cou and not cow? Is there a meaning there somewhere? You don’t drink, smoke, or have illegitimate children… what kind of cowboy are you?! ;-)
Lots of great interests, and surprisingly for a redneck like yourself some of them are unisex. Try and get all your interests highlighted so it’s uniform in that section.
Uh, disclosing your lack of underwear collection may leave some questions to the imagination of the reader, as in “only 4?! He’s a man… he probably only does his laundry once every…. EWWWWW”. I did like the mention about the hat though. That was classic.
I think you start the humour off well in your profile but you fail to bring it home. As Yev mentioned you could have used a fish story to cap off the no swimming thing, or made some comment about how the pool banned you for doing azzcrackers in your Wranglers and clogging up the filters when you were a kid. And the running shoe/loafer bit you could have continued the thought with a semi-colon and then listed off a number of formal events where you feel sneakers are acceptable, such as weddins, funerals, staff Christmas parties, the first couple formal dates with her until you are comfortable to show up barefoot or in your Jesus sandals, and the remaining 9 days a year you go to church. Lots of missed opportunities to make a girl smile, and let’s face it if you can do that you are nearly there. You are a good-looking guy to boot, even under that roughneck motif.
I’m going to follow suit here and echo the other’s sentiments about your requirements. This will drive most women from your page, even the ones that fit it. It’s a little too demanding and also a tad unrealistic. My ex and I are amicable. We fight about the kids and about certain things in the divorce settlement, but to me that’s called negotiating. But my girlfriend will NEVER have to deal with my ex in terms of my kids, even if we move in. She’s moving in with her boyfriend in six weeks and while he’s talked to me about the kids and his role in their lives I’ve made it abundantly clear that they will never be HIS kids the way his are, but I expect him to treat them all equally. But if I have an issue with the kids he’ll never have to deal with me directly unless he crosses a line with them. If this is really an issue for you I’d suggest just leaving it out and self-filtering. I mean, you can figure out within the first conversation or two via email or MSN usually what her custody situation is like as well as her relationship with her ex. If it seems toxic then you can simply disappear from her life without a mention and pretend like you forgot her number. Alright, I don’t advocate that type of behaviour that but you catch my drift I'm sure.
For a mountain man a good first date section. I liked the joking take on the morel hunt. Mmmmm....morels.
Overall, a good profile my good friend. It kept me interested and made me smile.
VVV ...and my personal favourite type of snake...the dreaded trouser snake. Watch as it swallows up females with a single bite. Once bitten they are forever smitten by the rascal. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:16:47 PM |
"Nature Nut - let's go spy on snakes!"
OMG! Are you serious? I thought "SNAKE" would be the LAST thing I should put in there! ROTFLMAO You have never heard a "thingy" refered to as a "snake"?
I assume you shortened to "shrooms" due to the character restriction, but Ursula is quite right that is has certain specific connotations.
Ok, point well taken, I am just a red neck, didn't think of the "other" ways it was possible to perceive that. That is why I came here.
Thank you for your input!
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:22:14 PM | OMG!! You are so right - I can't believe I completely missed the double meaning. I can be called LOSER for the rest of the day - I've earned it.
Squirrels?
Find Frogs?
Bother the birds? (No probably not so good)
I was kinda going for the alliteration thing, as I think it adds a bit of fun - but maybe that's just me.
Oh, and I had a thought on your problem of how to word your concerns regarding children. Could you say something like "I have some specific beliefs regarding children and child-raising, which I would be happy to explain when the time is right". Kinda puts it out there, but a bit softer.
Or maybe I'm still missing the mark. Definitely get feedback from the rest of the gang on that one. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:30:55 PM | Well, color me confused with what your ideas of discipline are, since you said only 1% out of 800 women agree with them. (That's, like, 8 right?)
If they're of the "spare the rod and spoil the child" variety, it might be best to say so.
I can't really imagine what your guidelines could be that so many other people with kids disagree with in such a significant way.
And you seem like such an easy-going guy... | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:48:55 PM | | Obviously, it will vary, but a lot of women in the right age bracket for a 42 year old would have adult children. A 45-year old woman I had a date with had a 25 year old daughter and a 20 year old son. And a 47-year old talked about her grandkids. In other words, couboy, you will not be dealing with young children, most likely. You might easily be dealing with young adults. I don't know how much that changes your outlook, if any, but it should be one of the things that you could consider. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:52:20 PM | Okay, it probably won’t but I wanted to set the stage at least! So the profile… let’s start from the top. I’ve been meaning to ask you this, but is there a reason it’s spelled cou and not cow? Is there a meaning there somewhere? You don’t drink, smoke, or have illegitimate children…
what kind of cowboy are you?! ;-)
It is "country" boy not "cowboy". lol
Lots of great interests, and surprisingly for a redneck like yourself some of them are unisex. Try and get all your interests highlighted so it’s uniform in that section.
Uh, disclosing your lack of underwear collection may leave some questions to the imagination of the reader, as in “only 4?! He’s a man… he probably only does his laundry once every…. EWWWWW”. I did like the mention about the hat though. That was classic.
LMAO This is getting tough now. You are the first one to even comment on the "undies",(apparently the others missed it or liked it) and two others prior to you DIDN'T like the hat part. LMAO Yev did give me a great idea for the swimming part though!
I think you start the humour off well in your profile but you fail to bring it home. As Yev mentioned you could have used a fish story to cap off the no swimming thing, or made some comment about how the pool banned you for doing azzcrackers in your Wranglers and clogging up the filters when you were a kid. And the running shoe/loafer bit you could have continued the thought with a semi-colon and then listed off a number of formal events where you feel sneakers are acceptable, such as weddins, funerals, staff Christmas parties, the first couple formal dates with her until you are comfortable to show up barefoot or in your Jesus sandals, and the remaining 9 days a year you go to church. Lots of missed opportunities to make a girl smile, and let’s face it if you can do that you are nearly there. You are a good-looking guy to boot, even under that roughneck motif.
I understand where your coming from bro! There is just one problem, I am not a "true comedian" like you are! If I make my profile too humorous, the ladies will be disappointed when they meet me in " real life". My personally is actually much closer to "serious" than "comedian".
I’m going to follow suit here and echo the other’s sentiments about your requirements. This will drive most women from your page, even the ones that fit it. It’s a little too demanding and also a tad unrealistic. My ex and I are amicable. We fight about the kids and about certain things in the divorce settlement, but to me that’s called negotiating. But my girlfriend will NEVER have to deal with my ex in terms of my kids, even if we move in. She’s moving in with her boyfriend in six weeks and while he’s talked to me about the kids and his role in their lives I’ve made it abundantly clear that they will never be HIS kids the way his are, but I expect him to treat them all equally. But if I have an issue with the kids he’ll never have to deal with me directly unless he crosses a line with them. If this is really an issue for you I’d suggest just leaving it out and self-filtering. I mean, you can figure out within the first conversation or two via email or MSN usually what her custody situation is like as well as her relationship with her ex. If it seems toxic then you can simply disappear from her life without a mention and pretend like you forgot her number. Alright, I don’t advocate that type of behaviour that but you catch my drift I'm sure.
I do get your drift, and I will take the advice given,and go back to sorting them the hard way.
For a mountain man a good first date section. I liked the joking take on the morel hunt. Mmmmm....morels.
Apparently you have had them?
Thanks for your input!
OFCB [Delete Post ] | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 1:55:49 PM |
I think it has just enough humor for a good chuckle. I find it difficult to read a complete profile when someone is trying to make every statement funny. I see nothing wrong with your pics. Just get a few more and yes, even one without your hat. I know how difficult that is. I call my camo hat "my hair" and I hate to leave home without it.
Thank you very much for the input! A fellow red neck.
OFCB
 | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 2:06:28 PM | Oh, and I had a thought on your problem of how to word your concerns regarding children. Could you say something like "I have some specific beliefs regarding children and child-raising, which I would be happy to explain when the time is right". Kinda puts it out there, but a bit softer.
Hmmmmmmmmmmm, yes, I totally agree, and I will certainly consider it! I am leaning toward what Deuce recommended and just turning them away as they come in.The draw backs to that are, it is both time consuming and some of the ladies get upset that I wasn't "upfront". This has been a very difficult issue for me to address since I have started my search.
Thanks for the thought
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 2:24:21 PM |
"Well, color me confused with what your ideas of discipline are, since you said only 1% out of 800 women agree with them. (That's, like, 8 right?)
Actually, I said less than one percent. More like 5 out of the 800.
"If they're of the "spare the rod and spoil the child" variety, it might be best to say so.
I have found even this to be nearly useless. When asked the question "how do you know when the child has had enough" they are literally "unable" to give ANY answer, or they say, well,three swats. Neither of those are passing answers in my book.
I can't really imagine what your guidelines could be that so many other people with kids disagree with in such a significant way.
This is a topic for another post. I would go nuts trying to do both here! lmao Not to mention it could be ruled "off topic". lol
And you seem like such an easy-going guy...
I can be very easy going, but you should go back and review my discription of myself.
Thanks for the thoughts
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 2:30:18 PM |
Obviously, it will vary, but a lot of women in the right age bracket for a 42 year old would have adult children. A 45-year old woman I had a date with had a 25 year old daughter and a 20 year old son. And a 47-year old talked about her grandkids. In other words, couboy, you will not be dealing with young children, most likely. You might easily be dealing with young adults. I don't know how much that changes your outlook, if any, but it should be one of the things that you could consider
Yes, and this is a part of the problem. I would MUCH rather have very young children. Young adults, improperly disciplined as children, tend to be on the disrespectful side of the spectrum. We see it on here every day, arrogence. I am not going there.
Thanks for the input!
OFCB | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 2:56:57 PM |
I have found even this to be nearly useless. When asked the question "how do you know when the child has had enough" they are literally "unable" to give ANY answer, or they say, well,three swats. Neither of those are passing answers in my book. You're...actually...advocating beating children as 'discipline'? And not just a swat or three?
Discipline does not have to mean 'beating.' My child is very well-behaved and I haven't spanked or swatted him since he was two -- and I had to, I'd said if he didn't stop, he'd get spanked. And he didn't. So to have any credibility as a parent, I did.
But I didn't like it, nor do I advocate it as proper or necessary child-rearing.
In light of this revelation, I think it best if you put "does not want children" and leave it at that. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 3:01:49 PM | | Realistically, do you intend to be getting 10 new contacts a day? Or more? If not then to send a couple emails out and then find out what their parenting philosophy and arrangement is isn't all that much work. I swear nearly every conversation I have with a woman on here ends up in the kids/ex area within three emails or if we start off in IM, MSN, or the phone it's within 10 minutes generally. So I could weed out the ones I wasn't interested in based on that nugget alone fairly quickly. | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 3:07:25 PM | I think for the most part you've done a great job with it... Your letting them know your humorous, or at least the type of humor you have... Plus, you've done a great job of stating the type of person you are... Many find that difficult...
Great Job!!!! | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 3:12:43 PM |
Realistically, do you intend to be getting 10 new contacts a day? Or more? If not then to send a couple emails out and then find out what their parenting philosophy and arrangement is isn't all that much work. I swear nearly every conversation I have with a woman on here ends up in the kids/ex area within three emails or if we start off in IM, MSN, or the phone it's within 10 minutes generally. So I could weed out the ones I wasn't interested in based on that nugget alone fairly quickly.
Absolutely, I am doing good to get two or three notes a week here. Part of my problem is that even if they are NOT a match many of them want to "continue talking" and I do NOT like to refuse ANYONE. LOL I am also on some other sites, so it does add up after three years. lmao
Thanks Deuce!
OFCB
ps I did delete the "marriage" paragraph, and changed a couple other things around. I have not had time to keep up. lol | |
|
| Humorous or juvenile? Posted: 5/16/2008 3:15:19 PM |
I think for the most part you've done a great job with it... Your letting them know your humorous, or at least the type of humor you have... Plus, you've done a great job of stating the type of person you are... Many find that difficult...
Thank you, I appreciate your input.
OFCB | |
|
|
|